Emmissions fail on MOT - Am I being sceptical?
Discussion
Ok, so my S4 went in to the dealers today for it's "Free MOT"
The car was serviced only 6 weeks ago by the same dealer, and no advisories were found, however, today they tell me the rear brake pads are very low, and will need replacing very soon.
But, it did fail on the Fast Idle emmission test, the limit it 1.30, and it came in at 1.31 They informed me that they would have to have the car in for a full diagnostic check etc, to try and remedy the issue (I did offer to give it a good run up the road to get it hot, but they said it should have been hot enough ticking over on the ramp)
However, once I got home, I dug out last years MOT (not completed at Audi but my local independent that I use for mechanical issues on my car and both mechanical & servicing on my wifes Gti) and realised the car was on the limit last year, but the reading from the analyser was 1.3. However, this was to 1 decimal place, not 2 as per the sheet Audi showed me today.
So, is it that Audi have a more effecient machine, or can gas analysers by tweaked to give 1 or 2 decimal places? If so, my reading of 1.31 would have rounded down to 1.3 anyway, thus a pass.
Sure, I may be doubting the dealers for no real reason, but to be told brake pads were shot (why did they not point that out on my service a few weeks ago) and then fail emmisions test, I have been wondering if they "may" be trying it on a touch to try and get a bit of money out of me for the "free MOT", especially when before the test, I declined the MOT warranty they could offer me for £49.50 which would cover me for up to £750 of problems at next years MOT
Thoughts?
The car was serviced only 6 weeks ago by the same dealer, and no advisories were found, however, today they tell me the rear brake pads are very low, and will need replacing very soon.
But, it did fail on the Fast Idle emmission test, the limit it 1.30, and it came in at 1.31 They informed me that they would have to have the car in for a full diagnostic check etc, to try and remedy the issue (I did offer to give it a good run up the road to get it hot, but they said it should have been hot enough ticking over on the ramp)
However, once I got home, I dug out last years MOT (not completed at Audi but my local independent that I use for mechanical issues on my car and both mechanical & servicing on my wifes Gti) and realised the car was on the limit last year, but the reading from the analyser was 1.3. However, this was to 1 decimal place, not 2 as per the sheet Audi showed me today.
So, is it that Audi have a more effecient machine, or can gas analysers by tweaked to give 1 or 2 decimal places? If so, my reading of 1.31 would have rounded down to 1.3 anyway, thus a pass.
Sure, I may be doubting the dealers for no real reason, but to be told brake pads were shot (why did they not point that out on my service a few weeks ago) and then fail emmisions test, I have been wondering if they "may" be trying it on a touch to try and get a bit of money out of me for the "free MOT", especially when before the test, I declined the MOT warranty they could offer me for £49.50 which would cover me for up to £750 of problems at next years MOT
Thoughts?
The trouble is, you'll always feel like you've been scammed.
I slipped up on one of our cars a few years ago when the dealer said they'd do the MOT free, and then failed it with £250 worth of work required (a chunky amount on a SEAT Ibiza) on a 4yr old 34K mile car. Got the money back off SEAT eventually.
I tend to use our village garage for MOT's. They charge the full price but it's 3 mins walk so no hassle getting into town and back. Only issue over half a dozen or so MOT's was one car had its headlights too low but he tweaked them up. He just passed the Ibiza the other day at 6yrs old with no issues at all.
I slipped up on one of our cars a few years ago when the dealer said they'd do the MOT free, and then failed it with £250 worth of work required (a chunky amount on a SEAT Ibiza) on a 4yr old 34K mile car. Got the money back off SEAT eventually.
I tend to use our village garage for MOT's. They charge the full price but it's 3 mins walk so no hassle getting into town and back. Only issue over half a dozen or so MOT's was one car had its headlights too low but he tweaked them up. He just passed the Ibiza the other day at 6yrs old with no issues at all.
I've spoken to my normal garage, and it's going in there next week for a re-test.
They reckon it will be no problem to fix it by .01, and were surprised Audi couldn't get it to drop by such a small amount in the first instance.
Means I lose out on my free MOT, but dont get shafted by ridiculous labour charges. Hey ho.
They reckon it will be no problem to fix it by .01, and were surprised Audi couldn't get it to drop by such a small amount in the first instance.
Means I lose out on my free MOT, but dont get shafted by ridiculous labour charges. Hey ho.
As suspected, car went through emissions first time, no worries whatsoever with my independent garage.
They also picked up the advisory on the rear pads, which they also said would have another 6k miles in them (thats at least 7 months for my mileage).
Thanks Audi Norwich....its been memorable.....but you wont be seeing me again
They also picked up the advisory on the rear pads, which they also said would have another 6k miles in them (thats at least 7 months for my mileage).
Thanks Audi Norwich....its been memorable.....but you wont be seeing me again
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


