Anyone moved from a BMW 5 Series to A6?
Anyone moved from a BMW 5 Series to A6?
Author
Discussion

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
i would appreciate hearing of your experiences. I'm thinking of changing from my much loved E39 to an A6. Possibly a 2.7 or 3.0 Quatro. Not sure about saloon or Avant. Probably 2007 or 2008

BMW is a 1998 528 but even at 12 years old is a delight to drive. It's just that it is getting too old now. It has comfort seats with memory. So I would like something similar on the Audi and as many toys as possible Bose etc. Car has to have leather and be automatic.

Will probably avoid the S line cars as I want a good ride and to be wafted around in comfort so I am thinking SE. Any inside information and tips would be appreciated.

I've had a look around an Avant at an Audi dealer but not driven anything yet. I would appreciate advice on the Audi warranty. Is it extendable etc.

Also, any recommendations for Indy dealers in the West Midlands would be good.

Thanks in advance.

pp

Dilligaf10

2,431 posts

241 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Don't know about indys in the WM but can recommend Listers of Worcester for customer service.

R60EST

2,364 posts

213 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
Had a few e39's inc 2 M5's ( see profile )

The first E39 I had was back in 2001 , when I had a 97 P 523 with close on 150k on the clock. It was like no other car I'd owned in terms of build quality and refinement. The M5 which followed was another step up with every option including double glazing.

I got a 55 plate A6 at 3 years old , 2.7 manual FWD se , with quite a few options ticked

I never thought any car , especially a bland looking A6 Avant, would surpass the feeling I had when I first tried the E39 , but I'm shocked to say it did.

Much tighter screwed together feel , no rattles or flimsy plastic anywhere. The MMI / DIS sat nav are obviously more up to date and better integrated than the E39.

I went from the 55 Reg Audi to an 03 Range Rover ( Lots of familiar BMW items ) and as much as the RR looks a nicer place to be it's not as well thought out or assembled.

I will be looking to get a newer A6 Avant in the near future but this time I'll also want a quattro and Auto.



blueg33

46,966 posts

255 months

Sunday 29th August 2010
quotequote all
I went from a 2005 530d Sport to an 2007 A6 3.0 tdi quattro. I much prefer the Audi as a daily driver, quattro is great especially when its pouring with rain, and the interior is a nicer place to be and feels more upmarket. For fast driving on windy roads the 5 series was better seeming to shrink, whereas the A6 always feels big. For touring accross Europe its the A6 every time.

A6 has has electronics issues, the 5 series had mechanical issues.

If I was choosing again today, the A6 would still win over the equivalent engine 5 series (except M5).

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Thanks everyone. That sounds encouraging.

I will drive one in the next few days. There is hope I will break my 19 year BMW addiction!

pp

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
I tried the SE, S-Line and LeMans spec cars before making my decision. At around the same time I had an SE-spec 5 series loan car and also test drove a Sport version (both were saloons).

The best suspension of all was the 5 series SE spec. Unfortunately it also had the worst steering - the rack was way too slow.
The best steering of all was the 5 series Sport spec. Unfortunately the suspension was way too hard.
Between the A6 SE and S Line cars, I had a marginal preference for the S-Line but there wasn't much in it. I drove a Le Mans spec car and that was clearly the best overall compromise. It had steering almost as good as the 5 series sport but with slightly softer suspension. It is still fairly hard compared to an SE spec A6 (probably down to the 19" wheels) however, the standard spec for the LeMans made it just too good value.

If you want a high spec car (as I did) you may find it easier to look to a LeMans spec car rather than the SE which tends to be the cheaper end of the range.

Pickled Piper

Original Poster:

6,452 posts

266 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Cheers UVB,

I had initially thought SE only , thinking that S lIne and Le Mans models can not possibly ride well with those enormous wheels. I will give them a try now.

pp

blueg33

46,966 posts

255 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
Mine is a Le Mans and its no harder a ride than my 530 sport was on runflats. Personally I prefer a firm setup as it makes the kids less travel sick as well as the handling benefits

UVB

557 posts

224 months

Monday 30th August 2010
quotequote all
I guess it's all down to personal preferences at the end of the day and you should really just try all three and see which suits you best. Audi continually annoy me by producing excellent cars that are always let down by the suspension. My Gallardo Spyder rode bumps far more comfortably than the A6 as does my new Cayman S (which does have PASM however - without it would probably be a lot harder). I had a Jag XF when my Gallardo was in for service a couple of months back and that was an excellent setup. Shame I'd never have one; build quality and ergonomics in the cockpit weren't a match for Audi and I felt 10 years older every time I sat in it.

I'm hoping Audi get it right with the new A7 as that could be our A6 replacement in a year or so's time. They just need to fix the eye-poking rear windows! (I'm hoping they will by the time it reaches production).

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
We just used http://www.thevwaudispecialists.co.uk/ recently. Really good service.

agentsmith

412 posts

224 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
had an E39 540i, these days have a 2008 A6 3.0 TDI Q, A6 is excellent. Find the steering more vague, but it's really a very nicely put together machine, and the engine has plenty of thrust. Im going to get mine remapped to 280bhp next month as it's no slouch, but you always need more smile

PS. I dont find the Le Mans alloys shod with 255/35/19 rubber a problem ride-wise at all. Best thing is to try it.

Edited by agentsmith on Tuesday 31st August 11:27