So, AllRoads then...
Author
Discussion

agent006

Original Poster:

12,058 posts

295 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
I'm looking for a tow car. Was considering various A6 quattros, but then I noticed that the 2.7 AllRoad has a towing capacity of 2300kg compared to 2100 for the larger engined A6s, which is useful as 2100 would be really tight for what I'm towing.

I'm loathed to go back to Audi after the complete disaster that was my A2 but the only other options are a Discovery TD5 and an M Class merc. Hardly illustrious candidates as far as reliability is concerned, but needs must.

Are AllRoads as hideously awful as everyone suggests? Would be a 2.7 not the TDI, probably a 2000 model due to the nasty tax on 2001 and later.

cptsideways

13,902 posts

283 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
The Tdi's in auto mode are best for towing, but they are not what you would call reliable, some hidously expensive pitfalls amongst them, so beware or take your chances.

535d is a better bet but they have their pitfalls too

agent006

Original Poster:

12,058 posts

295 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Sadly a 535d is twice my budget and 200kg short on capacity.

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Allroad is a ropey old thing and can eat money.

What horrible tax after 2000? The difference on a 2.7t is only 50 quid. Sure you're not thinking of post 06?

Dilligaf10

2,431 posts

241 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
A 2.7T Allroad will be horrendously thirsty especially when towing.

Diesel is a much better proposition but the 2.5TDi is not renowned for being the best engine unfortunately.

Kevin VRs

13,894 posts

311 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
For towing that sort of weight why not consider other SUV type cars. Jeep Grand Cherokee is rated for up to 3.5t. Currently good value for money, I have just bought a 2005 model for around £9K (top spec with extras). Returns just under 30mpg from the 2.7CRD engine.

agent006

Original Poster:

12,058 posts

295 months

Thursday 23rd September 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
What horrible tax after 2000? The difference on a 2.7t is only 50 quid. Sure you're not thinking of post 06?
It's only £50 more now. From 2012 onwards the 2006 break point for high tax band cars is being brought back to 2001 Y plate and newer. So with a 2.7 allroad being Band M it means £485 p/a.

Yertis

19,741 posts

297 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Allroad is a ropey old thing and can eat money.
Which isn't what they told me when I test drove one at Fontain but there you go. wink


But I agree on both counts. That said there's one (of the original type, presumably an urAllroad) on my drive now and for the foreseeable future, and whilst I have lots of niggles it's a very useful and very capable old bus. Cruises well, not awful mpg (well, not compared to a Monaro) and surprisgly good off-road. Not in a hurry to get rid for sure.

agent006

Original Poster:

12,058 posts

295 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
Ah, just the man.

How does it compare for reliability against your urS4?

I'm really struggling to get more than single sentence answers out of people about these. Mainly trying to establish if they're unreliable in catastrophic engine and gearbox ways (like a Discovery TD5) or is it more a case of lots of regular small problems (like a Merc ML).

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
If you can get one with sensible miles and lovely history then you'll probably be fine, one of the dealers we know has had one for years, maintained carefully and it's been fine.

However we see a lot of older, miley cars through with suspension and engine problems.

I've not yet seen anything firm about an increase for 2012...

Yertis

19,741 posts

297 months

Friday 24th September 2010
quotequote all
agent006 said:
Ah, just the man.

How does it compare for reliability against your urS4?

I'm really struggling to get more than single sentence answers out of people about these. Mainly trying to establish if they're unreliable in catastrophic engine and gearbox ways (like a Discovery TD5) or is it more a case of lots of regular small problems (like a Merc ML).
OK, I got it at 28k miles three years ago, and it's now at about 70k and in that time these things have gone wrong:

A CV boot.
Leaking rocker cover gasket
Alarm plays up intermittently.
A bit of interior trim is loose.

So I can't really complain. It just doesn't feel as solid as the urS, but I think my love for that car skews my memory a bit.

Get the 175bhp version, and get a manual. It's surprisingly quick. Bear in mind the old style AllRoad was beefed up in the body work, I don't think the new style version is reinforced to the same extent.

My main issues with the AllRoad are the steering (as usual) and the engine which sounds like a diesel Transit. It's got good brakes and if you can get past the steering can be hustled along quite quickly.