B7 RS4 (4.2 V8) Avant or C6 S6 (5.2 V10) Avant?
B7 RS4 (4.2 V8) Avant or C6 S6 (5.2 V10) Avant?
Author
Discussion

ParanoidAndroid

Original Poster:

1,367 posts

314 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Need an estate car and contemplating an RS4 however I've also noticed you can pick up a V10 S6 Avant for similar money. Assume the RS4 would be slightly more involving and rewarding to drive however the thought of a V10 does appeal, especially with the added space benefits the 6 brings over the 4.

Any thoughts, has anyone driven both?

Cheers,
Graham

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Yes, for RS4 you'll find plenty of info flickign through a few threads on here (even just today).

S6 is great value but even more thirsty (oil too) than the 4, you're not likely to get out of the teens even being very gentle with it. Lots of space, lots of pace (again, not RS4 fast), makes a lovely noise (particularly Milltek'd up) and we've not had any real problems with one.

It is the stealthiest of stealth weapons, there's virtually nothing to give it away unless you know what one is. Standard wheels pretty ugly.

ecain63

10,653 posts

206 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
RS4: very involving, quick, agile and looks the part. Some issues with the engine getting blocked up with carbon and drc suspension failures. Expensive to run but rewarding to drive. Lack of space could be an issue if you have a family to transport.
C6 S6: big heavy and dull. Wants to be an RS6 with the V10 but lacks real urge and the looks are very oldmanish. That said, its a fantastic cruiser and very comfy. No major reliability issues I know of but its only a pup. Plenty of space, great for the family guy but no good if your after a sports car. I'd be looking at a well groomed, late model C5 RS6 if you need space, speed and spirit.

Gio G

2,995 posts

240 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Even after a very long test drive in an RS4, I still went for an A6. I took the family out in the RS4, while I loved the speed and the noise, it did not have the comfort levels I really wanted, plus the ride and noise would become too much on long trips. It was by pure chance I took out the 3.0T S-line and loved it. The S6 to me was far too expensive and thirsty to be the better buy, however agree on the V10, but in the RS6..

I recently took my A6 to Italy on a 2,500 round trip, it had the perfect blend of performance, comfort and economy. Also, not too many of the road..

billy5

235 posts

237 months

Wednesday 29th September 2010
quotequote all
just get an a8 4.2 quattro and have done with it,
grace, pace, and aguility in sports mode,
superb comfort,