Audi A3 2.0tdi - turbo or gearbox fault?
Audi A3 2.0tdi - turbo or gearbox fault?
Author
Discussion

rickyquicky

Original Poster:

54 posts

202 months

Wednesday 6th October 2010
quotequote all
Hopefully a knowledgeable PHer can give me a bit of advice!

I have an Audi A3 2.0tdi DSG (2006) that hasn't proven to be the most reliable car, but nevertheless its running fairly well at the moment apart from an annoying niggle that has developed over the past month.

The car has an intermittent stutter/hesitation that happens mostly between 1500-2100 rpm, but is usually accompanied by a strange sound that resembles a turbo 'chattering' but it sounds less like air and more like a whirring/grinding noise.

The closest thing that the sound resembles is like a mix of a car in reverse gear and the fluttering turbo sound rally cars make. The noise is very short and is perfectly in sync with the hesitation aswell.

It also makes this noise if I floor the accelerator at low revs and quickly release again, it will make the same short whirring noise.

Im pretty competent as a 'home mechanic' but this has got me truly baffled! Do any of you guys have any experience of this or can suggest any diagnostic tests I can try to narrow the cause down? smile






Edited by rickyquicky on Wednesday 6th October 22:08

Mojocvh

16,837 posts

293 months

Wednesday 6th October 2010
quotequote all
Sorry can't answer directly BUT "noise is very short and is perfectly in sync with the hesitation aswell." could point our tame VAG tech in the right direction.

Mo.




Edited by Mojocvh on Wednesday 6th October 23:00

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Wednesday 6th October 2010
quotequote all
wonder if it is compressor surge at low revs - Is it happening only when asking for hard acceleration and it doesn't do it on gradual acceleration?

Edited by TDIfurby on Wednesday 6th October 23:36

rickyquicky

Original Poster:

54 posts

202 months

Thursday 7th October 2010
quotequote all
Cheers for the replies, the hesitation and noise that goes with it happens under normal driving cinditions. Hard acceleration through the gears actually makes the problem go away!

It makes a noise sometimes under hard acceleration if I come off the throttle suddenly at low revs.

Its the noise that is really making me worry!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 9th October 2010
quotequote all
rickyquicky said:
It makes a noise sometimes under hard acceleration if I come off the throttle suddenly at low revs.
That noise is compressor stall, sounds like a dump valve or waste gate from a rally car.

You shouldnt really be getting the same noise at light loads and low rpm like you describe, check all the boost pipe are ok, not split or leaking.

Even a minor boost leak will make all the turbo noises much louder than they should be. A boost leak will cause surges at 1500-2400 range too.

rickyquicky

Original Poster:

54 posts

202 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies so far! smile

So Tame technician you think its probably a boost leak? I'll have a good look tomorrow and see what I can find, thanks.

It does make the noise randomly accompanied by a stutter quite a lot too, and its the samer sound but in a different pattern if you know what I mean. Rather than the fluttering type sound its just a single sound with a hesitation, then its fine, and a few seconds later it will hesitate and make a sound again. Does that still sound like a boost leak do you think?

Really appreciate the advice, cheers.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
Very difficult to do noises without actually hearing it or drivning the car, but yeah i still think boost leak.

Look for split hoses to the intercooler or damaged intercooler ends. The boost system always carries an amount of oily vapour so any leak will be made visable by a covering of oil.

rickyquicky

Original Poster:

54 posts

202 months

Sunday 10th October 2010
quotequote all
I know its 10x harder for you to try to help diagnose a fault without hearing any sounds for yourself or even seeing the car, thats why your an asset to the forum mate!

Thanks a lot for the help, I doubt theres much more you can tell me without seeing it so i'll take it from here any update if I find anything.

Thanks again