S5 Tyre Advice
Author
Discussion

Mats

Original Poster:

252 posts

273 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
Hi All,

It's getting to the time where I need to change all 4 boots. I am pretty undecided in what to go for to be honest.

- OEM are the DUNLOP Sport Maxx

or I could go for

- Michelin Pilot Sports PS2
- Bridgestone RE050A

Can anyone advise from their own experiences?

Cheers

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
Mats said:
- OEM are the DUNLOP Sport Maxx
^^^ Known as 'Shyte Maxx' on the MKV GTI forums. I think on a bigger, heavier and far more powerful car they'd be ball0cks.

Mats said:
- Bridgestone RE050A
^^^ I had these on my last car and thought they were great; especially grip levels. They were barely broken in after 15k miles, too.

However, the ride was totally bouncy, but I think the cars low(ish) kerb wait - 1,200kg - would make the ride worse. It should be ok on an S5... more weight = more settled.

Mats said:
- Michelin Pilot Sports PS2
^^^ Highly rated in the various forum communities I know of. PS3's are out though now...


Edited by FamilyDub on Tuesday 12th October 17:22

Yertis

19,742 posts

297 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
My experience with quattros points to Michelin Pilots being hard wearing but not so "grippy", Dunlops (I was using Sport 9000s I think, it was a little while ago) being grippy, good in the wet but slightly soft and not wearing quite so well – they're the ones I kept going back to and I'll put them on my urQuat when it needs new boots. I use those Bridegestones on my Monaro now and they're great, strong sidewall so the car feels well planted. They wear quite quickly at the back but I think that's down to my driving.

blueg33

46,995 posts

255 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
My A6 quattro wears Vredstein Ultrac Sessantas, they are the best tyres its had by far. Previously had Pirelli Pzero Rosso and Dunlop SP 9000. The Vredsteings have best wet and dry grip and wear much better, currently 4000 miles more than the Pirelli's and counting.

The first 100 miles or so they are a little slippy (as are namy tyres) but after that they are great, and they are relatively cheap. My car uses 255/35 on 19 inch rims and I saved about £100 a corner with Sessantas

MBW

9 posts

236 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

I was in the same position with our S5, i.e. it came with Dunlops.
Changed to PS2s, and come replacement time will go for the same again (or PS3s I suppose).

It was a while ago, but I think that my initial thoughts were that the PS2s give more feed back, where the Dunlops felt a bit wooden.
Wear wise they (PS2s) last well given the weight and welly of the car, so no problem in recommending them over the Dunlops.

Sorry no experience with the Bridgestones on the Audi, but have switched from Bridgestones to PS2s in the past too and not regretted it.

Hope that helps!

Mark

cuprabob

19,943 posts

245 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
My R32 came with the Dunlop Sport Maxx from the factory and they were woeful. I now use Goodyear F1 Assymetrics and hae found them to be excellent with regards to grip, wear rate and price.

Can't go wrong with Michelins though especially if you have a Costco card.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 12th October 2010
quotequote all
The GTI boys love the Vred Ultracs thumbup

krusty

2,473 posts

280 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
I replaced my S5 tyres at the weekend and went with Continentals from Micheldever tyres at 200 quid a corner

Biggriff

2,312 posts

315 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
This month's Evo did a tyre test and in that the Conti 5P came top closely followed by the goodyear F1 A

Pablo16v

2,977 posts

228 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
Yertis said:
My experience with quattros points to Michelin Pilots being hard wearing but not so "grippy", Dunlops (I was using Sport 9000s I think, it was a little while ago) being grippy, good in the wet but slightly soft and not wearing quite so well – they're the ones I kept going back to and I'll put them on my urQuat when it needs new boots. I use those Bridegestones on my Monaro now and they're great, strong sidewall so the car feels well planted. They wear quite quickly at the back but I think that's down to my driving.
I kind of agree with this in that the Pilot Sports are hard wearing (18,000 miles on an A6 3.0 Quattro) but I thought they gripped very well indeed in the dry and wet. However, power wise the 225hp A6 isn't quite in the same league as an S5. They also coped quite well with a couple of harsh winters in NE Scotland.

Edited by Pablo16v on Wednesday 13th October 08:06

Mats

Original Poster:

252 posts

273 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
Thank you for all the responses.

I used to use PS2's on the various ///M cars I have owned. An excellent tire which I found was very progressive. I am particularly interested to hear what they are like on a 4wd drive car as opposed to rwd. I've had quite a few conti's in the past (mainly sport contacts) which I found quite soft to be honest. Not sure how they would handle with the weight of an S5. To be honest I cannot really get on with the Dunlops. As someone mentioned they are like wood. Perfect analogy there. Vredestiens (sp?) good reviews and an excellent price but I do question whether or not they will cope particularly well in the winter (what with the tread pattern) I also read about the Conti 5's are they really as good as the PS2's? Does anyone have any experience with the wear. Forgive all the questions I want to make a reasonably informed choice.

Cheers

blueg33

46,995 posts

255 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
Pablo16v said:
Yertis said:
My experience with quattros points to Michelin Pilots being hard wearing but not so "grippy", Dunlops (I was using Sport 9000s I think, it was a little while ago) being grippy, good in the wet but slightly soft and not wearing quite so well – they're the ones I kept going back to and I'll put them on my urQuat when it needs new boots. I use those Bridegestones on my Monaro now and they're great, strong sidewall so the car feels well planted. They wear quite quickly at the back but I think that's down to my driving.
I kind of agree with this in that the Pilot Sports are hard wearing (18,000 miles on an A6 3.0 Quattro) but I thought they gripped very well indeed in the dry and wet. However, power wise the 225hp A6 isn't quite in the same league as an S5. They also coped quite well with a couple of harsh winters in NE Scotland.

Edited by Pablo16v on Wednesday 13th October 08:06
My A6 is just shy of 300bhp and is no slower than my mates S5 (that's diesel torque for you). Plus its heavier so has to work tyres harder. The Vredsteins are the tyres of choice. I also now have Vredsteins on the Tuscan.

Its worth looking at tyre tests online, but watch for the ones that factor price into the overall rating as this tends to make ditchfinders look like good tyres! Last time I looked the top tyres seemed to be Falken 452's, Vredstein Ultrac Sessantas and Goodyear Eagle Asymentrics


FUBAR

17,065 posts

269 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
I need to change all 4 tyres on my S4 in the next 1000 miles or so. My usual tyre place has given me prices for the Dunlop SportMax GT (which are currently on there), Pirelli Rosso Corsas and Conti SportContact 3s. I was leaning towards the SP3s, but I see there is the SP5 out now, so think I should get a price for those.

Out of those, are we in agreement the SportContacts (be it 3 or 5)? Anyone have a comparison table of the 3 and 5?

FUBAR

17,065 posts

269 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
Hmm, interesting. My tyre chaps said I should really keep the 96Y rating, and the Conti site only gives me the option of the SP3 for that rating?

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
I've just put 4 x Pirelli P-Zero Rossos on my V8 S4 (4WD) and think they're really quite good - not too expensive, but no road noise, grip seems good (though I've not gone crazy in them yet).

Mats

Original Poster:

252 posts

273 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
TonyHetherington said:
I've just put 4 x Pirelli P-Zero Rossos on my V8 S4 (4WD) and think they're really quite good - not too expensive, but no road noise, grip seems good (though I've not gone crazy in them yet).
Tony, do you find Pirelli's a little soft? My experience is that they do not last much more than 10K

Lostprophet

2,549 posts

200 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
TonyHetherington said:
I've just put 4 x Pirelli P-Zero Rossos on my V8 S4 (4WD) and think they're really quite good - not too expensive, but no road noise, grip seems good (though I've not gone crazy in them yet).
They dont last long though? The rubber is quite soft...

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
I'm not even 1000 miles in yet, so I'll tell you in about 10-15000 miles hehe

blueg33

46,995 posts

255 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
TonyHetherington said:
I've just put 4 x Pirelli P-Zero Rossos on my V8 S4 (4WD) and think they're really quite good - not too expensive, but no road noise, grip seems good (though I've not gone crazy in them yet).
Only got 18k miles out of these on the A6 others have all been better (Dunlops circa 20k, Vredsteins 22k and sill have 3mm left) and grippier in the wet. Pzero Rosso grip well in the dry though.

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Wednesday 13th October 2010
quotequote all
I'd be happy with 18k!