MK V GTi intermitent engine stutter
Discussion
Car was serviced at VW DEALERSHIP at 50,000 miles and surprisingly they had no spark plugs in stock. After holiday I got plugs fitted then the car started to stutter, miss a beat when cold initially then intermitentlly all the time particularly changing from 3rd gear, up and down. No fault codes. DV Valve changed, they said it was torn. They said now all good and it stuttered when leaving garage so went back then they said they would get a sensor for fuel system ordered, as this showed up on fault code. They fitted that and no difference. So far I have paid for plugs part of service, DV Valve and refused to pay for no more as car was fine until they changed spark plugs. Tech said he was not happy with it but would have to leave car for a few days to let them check some more items. Kept saying no fault codes showing. Car going in again on Monday as I have had to wait 2 weeks on courtesy car. Any ideas. VW have started to really get to me. 05 Plate
Thanks for reply. I would have thought VW would have suspected them considering the amount of trouble they give according to these forums. When I drop car off on Monday I will inform them of your advice whether they listen or not. I am taking a hard stance as car was fine until they had it.
Thanks again. They did replace plugs again.The thing that confuses me there is no pattern to stutter.Can go couple of days OK then next day does it all the time. Also when sitting at lights idling sometimes car shakes like engine is rocking side to side. How do the coil packs work and is there just 1 unit or 1 for each plug?
Thanks in advance
Thanks in advance
Well car has been in VW for a week and they have changed coil packs with no joy.They are rather stumped for an answer. They admit there is a fault but it doesnt register on diagnostics, even had it plugged in whilst driving car and stutter still there but it doesnt register either.
They have said to hold onto courtesy car till next week.
Just goes to show no fault code, no idea!!!!!!
They have said to hold onto courtesy car till next week.
Just goes to show no fault code, no idea!!!!!!
Start of a new week and VW just phoned to say not any further forward. Waiting on part being delivered tomorrow. Wouldnt say what but guy didnt seem too optimistic. Now the touran courtesy car has a warning light. Cant wait to rid myself of VW. I have had 3 golf GTIs and all been the same, problematic.
Had a very nice woman from customer care asking how my recent experience was like, needless to say I bet she wished she hadnt called.
Had a very nice woman from customer care asking how my recent experience was like, needless to say I bet she wished she hadnt called.
Topjock said:
Start of a new week and VW just phoned to say not any further forward. Waiting on part being delivered tomorrow. Wouldnt say what but guy didnt seem too optimistic. Now the touran courtesy car has a warning light. Cant wait to rid myself of VW. I have had 3 golf GTIs and all been the same, problematic.
Had a very nice woman from customer care asking how my recent experience was like, needless to say I bet she wished she hadnt called.
I had a similar issue 99% solved by a new diverter/boost control valve. They ae known to fail but mine had no visible tear, just appeared to have a weak spring. I think the main issue on these engines are air leaks upsetting the mixture, so I checked all the connections aswell, some of which i'm not sure are sealing well. It not appears to be running much better.Had a very nice woman from customer care asking how my recent experience was like, needless to say I bet she wished she hadnt called.
I do wonder about the fuel pumps aswell , given the pressures they have to run with, whether in the long run they can sustain that.
1. Try the D type piston DV (black unit on this page) http://www.jkm.org.uk/performance/divertervalves.h...
2. Check Cam follower, which drives the fuel pump, see http://www.golfmkv.com/forums/showthread.php?t=764...
3. Luck of the draw from these popular problems, see http://forums.vwvortex.com/showthread.php?3366758
2. Check Cam follower, which drives the fuel pump, see http://www.golfmkv.com/forums/showthread.php?t=764...
3. Luck of the draw from these popular problems, see http://forums.vwvortex.com/showthread.php?3366758
Edited by the-photographer on Tuesday 2nd November 13:47
the-photographer said:
1. Try the D type piston DV (black unit on this page) http://www.jkm.org.uk/performance/divertervalves.h...
^^^ I've said it in a few threads... the VW OEM piston-type valve is strong enough to cope with the stage 2+ Audi S3's output, then it'll be fine for a more-or-less stock Golf GTI.Most boost problems on the countless Golf forums I use are coming from DIAPHRAGM valves failing.
The OEM 'Revision D' is only £50 inc VAT from VW & just as good as the Forge/JKM/etc piston type valves (at half the price), plus if you have axle stands, it's a DIY job in 10-15 mins.
PM me if you want the part number.
The main issues with the 2.0 TFSI are:-
1) Diverter Valve Issue - change to piston type. Part to fix ~£50.
2) Coil Pack and/or Spark plug failures - will cause a misfire. One a misfire is detected on a cylinder, move the coil/sparkie to another cylinder and see if the misfire follows. Coils ~£25, each & plugs ~£8-10 each.
3) Failed Inlet Manifold Pressure Control Valve (PCV) - Car will 'draw air' and potentially have an high-low erratic idle, and/or stay on the throttle when in neutral. May have boost problems and they are likely to be intermittent (if present).
4) Failed Mass Air-Flow Meter (MAF) - Again erratic idle, similar as above.
5) Clogged (with carbon) Manifold and/or throttle body. - needs cleaned or replaced. Symptom of the re-circulating system.
6) AN Other problem - fuelling? Are you using the right octane petrol? At least 98 RON?
I'm aware of all of these being an issue because I've had to deal with them all (apart from the MAF) in my 2-year ownership. Trust me when I say most VW/Audi garages are useless and also trust me in saying when you finally get it all fixed, owning a GTI is an excellent prospect - it's such a great all-rounder. I love mine.
The reason I've listed these problems in this order above is it's the cheapest/easiest fixes first. I use an Independent ex-Audi Mastertech who took *four* days to find & fix all my problems, so some 'computer says no' monkey at VW is unlikely have a clue.
Heck, a R32 owning pal of mine was turned away from our local VW after requesting an Haldex oil service with the gem 'that even AWD, mate'.
1) Diverter Valve Issue - change to piston type. Part to fix ~£50.
2) Coil Pack and/or Spark plug failures - will cause a misfire. One a misfire is detected on a cylinder, move the coil/sparkie to another cylinder and see if the misfire follows. Coils ~£25, each & plugs ~£8-10 each.
3) Failed Inlet Manifold Pressure Control Valve (PCV) - Car will 'draw air' and potentially have an high-low erratic idle, and/or stay on the throttle when in neutral. May have boost problems and they are likely to be intermittent (if present).
4) Failed Mass Air-Flow Meter (MAF) - Again erratic idle, similar as above.
5) Clogged (with carbon) Manifold and/or throttle body. - needs cleaned or replaced. Symptom of the re-circulating system.
6) AN Other problem - fuelling? Are you using the right octane petrol? At least 98 RON?
I'm aware of all of these being an issue because I've had to deal with them all (apart from the MAF) in my 2-year ownership. Trust me when I say most VW/Audi garages are useless and also trust me in saying when you finally get it all fixed, owning a GTI is an excellent prospect - it's such a great all-rounder. I love mine.
The reason I've listed these problems in this order above is it's the cheapest/easiest fixes first. I use an Independent ex-Audi Mastertech who took *four* days to find & fix all my problems, so some 'computer says no' monkey at VW is unlikely have a clue.
Heck, a R32 owning pal of mine was turned away from our local VW after requesting an Haldex oil service with the gem 'that even AWD, mate'.

Edited by FamilyDub on Thursday 4th November 09:41
Topjock said:
Had the fed up sounding VW man on phone yesterday. Car still giving intermitant stutter after several components swapped out. Didnt give details. Car has now been given to the software expert and they are keeping till next week.
Totally disillutioned with VW now.
Hi Topjock, any update?Totally disillutioned with VW now.
Firstly thanks for avice and ideas.
Picked car up yesterday.
They had tried 2 sets coil packs no joy
Various sensors.
another DV no difference
Air Flow Meter and this helped but still slight stutter occasionally
Repaired Air box, didnt give details.
They have run car for 3 days and no stutter.
Its now over to me, now to decide.
There was no charge, had courtesy car for 15 days. Assuming car not under warranty am pleased in the end. I will totally reserve judgement until next week, well wife will, I played dodgems with a Lexus on Friday as a pedestrian and now arm in a sling for a few weeks amongst cuts and bruises.
I know dealerships always give car a quick clean but leather looked and felt it had been polished up.Interior spotless.
Picked car up yesterday.
They had tried 2 sets coil packs no joy
Various sensors.
another DV no difference
Air Flow Meter and this helped but still slight stutter occasionally
Repaired Air box, didnt give details.
They have run car for 3 days and no stutter.
Its now over to me, now to decide.
There was no charge, had courtesy car for 15 days. Assuming car not under warranty am pleased in the end. I will totally reserve judgement until next week, well wife will, I played dodgems with a Lexus on Friday as a pedestrian and now arm in a sling for a few weeks amongst cuts and bruises.
I know dealerships always give car a quick clean but leather looked and felt it had been polished up.Interior spotless.
The 'stutter' sounds like a problem with airlow/ignition.
If coil packs have been replaced and MAF too, I'd point the garage towards the PCV, or perhaps a rather carbon-clogged throttle body is the issue?
Topjock, have they tried something as simple as new sparkies to go with the new coils?
If coil packs have been replaced and MAF too, I'd point the garage towards the PCV, or perhaps a rather carbon-clogged throttle body is the issue?
Topjock, have they tried something as simple as new sparkies to go with the new coils?
FamilyDub said:
2) Coil Pack and/or Spark plug failures - will cause a misfire. One a misfire is detected on a cylinder, move the coil/sparkie to another cylinder and see if the misfire follows. Coils ~£25, each & plugs ~£8-10 each.
As a footnote to this (as I had a Coil Pack problem on the S2000), if you don't stop the car and diagnose as soon as the problem appears, then the ECU tries to compensate for the problem cylinder which CAN throw-up misfires on other cylinders.So you're driving, it acts up, you get home and plug-in the Fault-code reader, and it shows problems on 3 out of the 4 cylinders. Not helpful...
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


