Another 'What Car' thread!!
Another 'What Car' thread!!
Author
Discussion

cpas

Original Poster:

1,661 posts

271 months

Thursday 21st October 2010
quotequote all
I am considering buying a MK4 Golf GTi either 1.8T or GTTDi (130 probably). How happy am I going to be chucking either of these downm a country lane? I quite like the punchiness of the Diesel but was wondering how the petrol will feel? Also, is the Diesel lump much heaveier and therefore effect handling. My other thought was a Leon Cupra as these have a higher BHP. Does anyone have experience of comparisons between these?

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Thursday 21st October 2010
quotequote all
I've owned 2 x Golf 1.8T and 1 TDi 150. The diesel was a much quicker car but not as good into the bends. In fact both are poor handlers, but good on a dual carriageway/motorway.

TDi averaged 50 even when driving enthusiastically, high 30s was the norm on a run from the 1.8T.

I would have the diesel and an aftermarket suspension kit.

I can't help you on the TDi 130 comparison.

cpas

Original Poster:

1,661 posts

271 months

Friday 22nd October 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the info. TDi 150 sounds good to me. It's just thet there seems to be more of the 130s about. What are they both like on reliability?

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Friday 22nd October 2010
quotequote all
I know the fans can go on the diesels, didn't have that on mine. The rear bushes go at 80k+. they did on mine. Cambelt change at 5 years/60k is a good idea on both. Rear washer pipe detaches at the rear near side above the C pillar and fills the boot area with fluid causing electrical issues/alarm going off...had that on 2 of mine and 2 friends !

TBH nothing much else in my experience although I'm sure others can advise, although the coils on 1.8T are prone to failure.