Skoda Octavia CR vRS - Fuel economy/DPF problem?
Skoda Octavia CR vRS - Fuel economy/DPF problem?
Author
Discussion

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Friday 22nd October 2010
quotequote all
I recently bought a 2008 Octavia vRS estate with the 2L CR engine but after a couple of months of running it I've realised that I'm getting nothing like the fuel economy I should be.

When I fill the tank the range indicator shows around 550miles but I've never managed to get more than around 400 miles before having to refill as the range indicator has reached 0.

I drive 60 miles a day to and from work on the motorway and the car never returns less than 40MPG (according to the built in computer) and is usually closer to 50MPG.

I usually get around 55L in the tank, dividing that by a conservative estimate of 42MPG says I should get over 500 miles, so something isn't adding up.

Last week the DPF indicator came on and I drove the car on a 50 mile round trip expecting the DPF to perform it's regeneration cycle, but after 50 miles the light was still on and I parked the car up at home. The following morning the light had gone off.

I took the car to Skoda today and they told me it needs a forced regeneration as there is a large mass of ash in the filter. The route I take to work should allow the car to perform the DPF regen but it seems this isn't happening.

Is this related to the low fuel economy?

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Monday 25th October 2010
quotequote all
Poor form replying to my own topic, but does no-one have any suggestions?

weezb

4,251 posts

195 months

Monday 25th October 2010
quotequote all
I have a Fabia vRS and I've found the trip computer to be "optimistic" to say the least, but even so I think your economy does seem down.

If no-one else can chip-in on this portal you'd best ask on here:

http://briskoda.net/forums/forum/169-skoda-octavia...

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I've posted on Briskoda too.

In any case the car has been back to the dealer and after much head scratching, umming ahhhing they decided to clean the EGR valve.

I haven't run a tank thru but after nearly half a tank I'm perilously close to 200 miles so it doesn't seem to have made any difference.

I'm not sure what to do next, dealer seem to have no clue where to go next and all I can think is that I should reject the car as it's not close to it's stated performance and they can't fix it.


parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
Did the dealer do the DPF regen too?

I'm sure tame technician will confirm, but I seem to remember him saying the VAG DPF won't regen until it's at a fair load, like around 3.5-4k rpm, which would mean doing your drive to work without changing above 4th gear.

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
The DPF regen was done by the dealer a couple of weeks back, made no difference to fuel economy.

I'm still getting 400 miles to a tank or, in fuel economy terms, around 33MPG.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 9th November 2010
quotequote all
My VRS 170 did about 37/38 from memory, driven with reasonable gusto.

I don't have a suggestion for a fix but 33 is definitely low.

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
I've always been aware of a bit of white/blue smoke from my car and today I realised that I can make it happen at any time.

If I'm driving at around 1200/1500 RPM in 5th gear (so approximately 40MPH) and accelerate gently I get a plume of blueish/whitish smoke, I can reproduce this at will and it happens when the engine is hot and when cold.

This doesn't seem right and presumably could be related to my fuel economy problem?

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
How does it go? 2.0 TDIs do seem to have a bit of an apetitie for turbos.

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
It seems fine.

My wife has a 2001 A3 with the 1.9 130 PD TDI and, honestly, it feels quicker but I think that's down to the way each type of engine delivers it's power.

My Octavia doesn't feel slow or that there's any engine problem but that missing fuel is going somewhere!

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
iPhone double post.

Edited by MrLou on Wednesday 10th November 18:56

MonkeyHanger

9,268 posts

273 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
MrLou said:
The DPF regen was done by the dealer a couple of weeks back, made no difference to fuel economy.

I'm still getting 400 miles to a tank or, in fuel economy terms, around 33MPG.
That is definitely low. A friend has a vRS with the CR170 engine and gets 550-600 miles per tank. Even my 2.0 TFSi gets 400 miles on a good run.

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Yes, I have no doubt it's broken!

Logically thinking the smoke an fuel economy problem must be connected.

Smoke means that either excess water, fuel or oil are being burnt.

My coolant and oil levels are fine so that just leaves fuel and co-incidentally my fuel economy is awful.

The question remains why is my car burning excess fuel? Is it extra fuel being injected but not burnt, is it normal amount of fuel being injected but not burnt or is it something else?

I can't believe they're not connected!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Oh its smoking, why didnt you say so.

The smoke is fuel, simple. Explains the poor fuel ecconomy and the trip computer showing more than you get. Like I said before, leak, just into the cylinder rather than on the floor.

Here is what must be happening (values are not correct just for example)

The injector is open for say 10ms (milliseconds) , the car knows that in 10ms say 100mg (milligrams) of fuel are injected. Only your injector nozzels are worn/broken so infact in the 10ms 120mg of fuel are injected. You see a 20% drop off in MPG, but the ECU show 45-50mpg like every thing is fine.

ECU "knows" it injected the right amount of fuel, or at least it knows the injector was open for the right amount of time, and it knows how much fuel can going into the engine through the injector in that time. Does that makes scence.

Get it back to the dealer, show them the smoke if it can be reproduced that easily.

If it was an Audi rather than a skoda I could read some data from the car, send it to technical for them to look over and check and they could confirm if my theory is correct before we replace £2k's worth of fuel injectors. Audi call is a DISS report/technical query. Presumably skoda have a similar system.


MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
Oh its smoking, why didnt you say so.

The smoke is fuel, simple. Explains the poor fuel ecconomy and the trip computer showing more than you get. Like I said before, leak, just into the cylinder rather than on the floor.

Here is what must be happening (values are not correct just for example)

The injector is open for say 10ms (milliseconds) , the car knows that in 10ms say 100mg (milligrams) of fuel are injected. Only your injector nozzels are worn/broken so infact in the 10ms 120mg of fuel are injected. You see a 20% drop off in MPG, but the ECU show 45-50mpg like every thing is fine.

ECU "knows" it injected the right amount of fuel, or at least it knows the injector was open for the right amount of time, and it knows how much fuel can going into the engine through the injector in that time. Does that makes scence.

Get it back to the dealer, show them the smoke if it can be reproduced that easily.

If it was an Audi rather than a skoda I could read some data from the car, send it to technical for them to look over and check and they could confirm if my theory is correct before we replace £2k's worth of fuel injectors. Audi call is a DISS report/technical query. Presumably skoda have a similar system.
I mentioned the smoke to the dealer but they couldn't reproduce it. But your explanation makes perfect sense to me, I just wish the dealer had taken my report of smoke more seriously and linked it to the fuel problem, it's not rocket science is it?!

I found today that I could reliably reproduce the smoke by gentle acceleration from 40mph in 5th. Seems not to happen (or maybe I just don't see it) at higher or lower speeds. It was mildly amusing driving thru Basingstoke today leaving smoke signals!

I think I'll swing by the dealer unannounced tomorrow morning and see if someone will ride with me to see it happen.

Skoda do seem to have some method of communicating with their technical people as they've asked for my fuel economy spreadsheet but I guess the new info could be, dare I say it, the smoking gun smile

The one thing that I don't understand is that when they put the car on the diagnostic computer the first time, no faults were found, does the diagnostic not go to that level of detail (i.e. injectors)?

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
The diag computer is ok, problem is the car wont log a fault code if the injector nozzles are worn as I suspect. Electronically they are ok, and the ECU will even see them working, so it wont report a fault.

This limits what the technician can do, you cant do anything under warranty unless you can prove its faulty, no fault code print out, no claim.

The ecu will monitor injection duration and the diag computer can produce this data both live and an averages from some time ago. I cant remember exactly how its done but technical can work out from this data and some other factors if the reported injection quantities are plorsable.

I've done the test on a few V6DTIs 2.7 + 3.0, but there is a TPI that directs the tech to test certain values and help evaluate the data. We havnt had the same problem with the 2.0CR TDI yet so the information isnt available and without this even the best techs can struggle to know what to test and how to enterpret the data.

This is an example of what might be writen in a TPI to guide a tech.


White smoke from the exhaust system and juddering when the engine runs at idle speed for some time - V6 TDI 2.7l / 3.0l TDI.

Technical background

Mechanical wear of the needle attachment of the injector leads to an increased fuel injection into the combustion chamber. The fuel is not completely burnt, which causes white smoke (unburnt fuel) or juddering when the engine runs at idle speed for some time.


Read the measured value blocks 72 - 77.

3 values per measured value block appear there (for 300 bar, 600 bar, 1000 bar).

Should the values be higher than minus -45 ms (example - 60ms) or

on digit 2 be

higher than minus -15 ms (e.g. 20ms),

the needle attachment is worn and the injector is incorrect. To avoid repeat repairs, replace all 6 injectors.

>>>> Observe the algebraic sign (minus) in measured value block 72-77 !!!!! <<<<<[/i]

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Edited by Tame Technician on Wednesday 10th November 21:41


Edited by Tame Technician on Wednesday 10th November 21:42

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
lots of good stuff
Thanks, your help is appreciated.

I guess my remaining questions are:

If injectors do turn out to be worn, will they replace all 4?
What causes wear to injectors, is it likely to happen again in next 40k?

Car has 40k miles and 1 year warranty remaining.

Edited by MrLou on Wednesday 10th November 21:48

TDIfurby

1,997 posts

206 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
40mpg is worrying, unless you are driving @ 125mph on that motorway trip. Dad has an Audi TT quattro with the same engine, and he is able to get 50 easily, and I think thats a heavier car with 4wd losses too.

I have the same optimistic fuel range though. Tank right up and it often says 600 miles on that tank - Rollox does it! I am lucky to nudge 500 (45 litre tank and highly tuned TDI engine does not help though.....)

MrLou

Original Poster:

879 posts

252 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
40MPG would be an improvement, I'm only getting 30!

Anyway, I demonstrated the smoke problem to the service technician this morning and the car is booked in for next week; the injectors are the first on the list for investigation.

Here's hoping for a good result.

liner33

10,861 posts

233 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
TDIfurby said:
40mpg is worrying, unless you are driving @ 125mph on that motorway trip. Dad has an Audi TT quattro with the same engine, and he is able to get 50 easily, and I think thats a heavier car with 4wd losses too.

I have the same optimistic fuel range though. Tank right up and it often says 600 miles on that tank - Rollox does it! I am lucky to nudge 500 (45 litre tank and highly tuned TDI engine does not help though.....)
Not sure about that we have a pd 170 Octavia and a a CR170 Superb (same engine as the op) both average 41-44mpg day to day , its not easy to get 50mpg out of either unless driven very sedately