S3 or R32 help please!
Author
Discussion

mda

Original Poster:

1 posts

192 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Hello,

First time on the forums! and intrested in some opinions please!

I'm looking at buying a 08/09 S3 or 08/09 R32. Ive looked at a few cars in dealers and a S3 seems like it will cost anywhere between 2-4k more than a R32 with similar milage. Do people think a S3 is worth the extra? I like both cars so having trouble making my mind up, I think at the moment I'm slightly leaning towards the audi but don't want to throw money away if its not worth it!

Would really appreciate any help/advice.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
For my money, R32.

I drove an 8P S3 and wasn't impressed enough, plus it was quite clinical in it's performance I thought. The R32 has more soul, IMO.

I'm maybe biased because already run a VAG 2.0T. The S3 was faster (much, actually), than my car, but I still wasn't impressed

Ok, tax is cheaper in the S3 and probably easier to eek out a few more Mpg, but V6's FTW!

Edited by FamilyDub on Wednesday 3rd November 22:54

Nasir 123

784 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Everybody is different. What do you want the car to do? The S3 is quicker than the R32, cheaper on fuel, cheaper on tax but it isn't the best of drives. A remap sorts that out, and 300 BHP with the 4WD is perfect. The V6 is heavy on petrol but the noise is phenomenal. The DSG downshifts and blips nicely adding to the excitement. Some people prefer the power delivery of the V6 uswel. Both are great cars and your in a good predicament.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 3rd November 2010
quotequote all
Nasir 123 said:
Both are great cars and your in a good predicament.
^^^ you, sir, are spot on.

fastbox

28 posts

199 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
R32 all day long smile

cuprabob

19,956 posts

245 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Every R32 owner has faced the same dilemma. You will also make the right decision.

Lefty

21,617 posts

233 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Difficult one. As far as I'm concerned it comes down to whether you will want to modify it for more power or not:

Easily tunable but dull four-pot turbo vs. howling but hugely expensive to tune v6.

That's about it really.

Oh, DSG is awesome on the r32.


Regarding tuning the r32: cams, full exhaust and remap will take you to 280-290bhp ish and cost £5k. After that you're looking at forced induction and another £5k-ish... There's a thread in readers cars somewhere of a chap who put a supercharger on his r32, I'll try to find it.

ge0rge

3,053 posts

236 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
S3, more power, tunable. Better looking. Better interior handles better, is faster...

matt173407

515 posts

260 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
It has to be the R32 (with DSG) , you dont see many , fabulous car to drive , the noise, the performance, the looks etc.

I love the fact that it doesnt look over the top as well.
to be honest i would not alter anything on it as you have to be careful enough not to hit silly speeds as standard before modding it.

In terms of fuel driver normally and can easily get 30mpg out of it.
I suppose its each to there own but there is definatly something special about the R !

u13rr1

527 posts

232 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Also consider an A3 3.2 (in DSG form as well). Much cheaper than the R32 which you can spend on full exhaust, cams and remap and possibly sort out the suspension. Plus, they're much more discrete than the R.

S3 if you want to brag in the pub about 0-60 times and BHP, R32 if you want a satisfying drive.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
S3 is better balanced and handles better, performance is very good and easily improved. VR6 engine and DSG box are a very heavy combination and all the wieght is up front.

S3 manual would be my choice for an excellent hot hatch.

That said, have to admit R32 / A3 3.2 makes nicer noise and power delivery has more character + better throttle responce, feels faster, but isnt really.

Hate to bring this into it, but S3 is slightly better on fuel and I believe cheaper road tax too.

Edited by Tame Technician on Thursday 4th November 18:03

rb5230

11,657 posts

203 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
S3 anyday, those rs4 style seats are a must. it handles better, is faster, more tuneable, cheaper to run, and less common.

ETA and has a nicer interior.

Edited by rb5230 on Thursday 4th November 18:20

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
German top gear track test.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jm0yMbccU08

Lap times
S3 manual 1:04.80

R32 DSG 1:06.71

And its widely regarded than DSG on track saves a second or so a lap. so its more like 3 seconds a lap slower.

Lefty

21,617 posts

233 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
German top gear track test.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jm0yMbccU08

Lap times
S3 manual 1:04.80

R32 DSG 1:06.71

And its widely regarded than DSG on track saves a second or so a lap. so its more like 3 seconds a lap slower.
Who's going to be buying either of these as a track car?!

kilarney

493 posts

254 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
s3 manual would be my choice with stg 1 chip

cuprabob

19,956 posts

245 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
rb5230 said:
S3 anyday, those rs4 style seats are a must. it handles better, is faster, more tuneable, cheaper to run, and less common.

ETA and has a nicer interior.

Edited by rb5230 on Thursday 4th November 18:20
Recaro buckets were an option on the R32 and look very much like the RS4 seats

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Golf looks better, Audi interior better, Golf sounds better, Audi goes faster, Golf expensive to tax, Audi expensive to buy...

6 of one, half a dozen of t'other; I'd buy a Golf GTI laugh

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
6 of one, half a dozen of t'other

TA03ORA

99 posts

198 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
kilarney said:
s3 manual would be my choice with stg 1 chip
That's the way to do it........biglaugh

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Friday 5th November 2010
quotequote all
TA03ORA said:
kilarney said:
s3 manual would be my choice with stg 1 chip
That's the way to do it........biglaugh
Yup, rocket ship! Potential for more without silly spend either.