Mark 5 R32 questions
Author
Discussion

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I've been looking at these as a viable alternative to replace my BMW E46 M3.

Couple of questions. I am guessing the road tax license is in the top bracket. Are models 2006 and newer therefore £425 for a year?

I also noticed the tank was fairly small (55 litres) given an average of 26 mpg, how many miles (realistically) can I expect to clock up between fill ups?

Would you go for the DSG or manual?

Also, if anyone fancies giving me for and against the R32 I'd be happy to hear them, along with any other recommendations.

rb5230

11,657 posts

203 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
there is no way i would swap an e46 m3 for an r32. the m3 is in another league.

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Thanks, but that doesn't really answer my questions! It was always going to be difficult to replace the M3 but it has to be done! Can't really get close to it for the budget.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all

I replaced my 911 with an R32 and have no regrets.


AWESOME noise, FABULOUS DSG gearbox, 4WD, comfy, fast, safe, and cheap as chips to run (albeit a bit heavy on fuel). Also magnificently well built. Think of it as a mini RS4 to be honest.

I bought from VW dealer with 14k on the clock, got two years free servicing, two years warranty, so precisely zero costs for three years, other than tax (£435 pa) petrol and tyres.

I can get 340 miles out of a tank on a run, much less when commuting. Have had it down to 11mpg once, but I was "pressing on".


Clarkson had it dead right.

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/driving/jeremy_cl...



Edited by Soovy on Monday 8th November 09:49

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Republik said:
I've been looking at these as a viable alternative to replace my BMW E46 M3.

Couple of questions. I am guessing the road tax license is in the top bracket. Are models 2006 and newer therefore £425 for a year?

I also noticed the tank was fairly small (55 litres) given an average of 26 mpg, how many miles (realistically) can I expect to clock up between fill ups?

Would you go for the DSG or manual?

Also, if anyone fancies giving me for and against the R32 I'd be happy to hear them, along with any other recommendations.
1. Don't expect similar performance to an e46 m3! It's a quickish car but a PWR of ~166bhp/mT isn't exactly "fast". Still, it's quicker than most day-to-day cars and acceleration up to 125-ish is pretty good.

2. I average a bit less than 26mpg to be honest, more like 23. BUT, my commute involves b-roads and visits to the red-line... I've never seen more than 310 miles to a tank.

3. DSG is absolutely superb. I tested a manual box and much preferred DSG. The only gripe I have with it is that selcting manual mode doesn't disable the kick-down switch which annoys the crap out of me.

4. Yes, road tax is top bracket. it's only money...

5. Servicing is very cheap and I've had superb service from VW.

6. With regard to other alternatives, I suppose the Audi S3 is a close competitor. There was a thread recently with some fairly divided opinions! I considered one of these but a few things put me off; namely the really dull engine, the fact that every other car on the road is an audi a3 and awful audi customer service. Gaving said all that, the a3 is much easier and cheaper to liberate extra power if that's your thing. The VW is, in my opinion, a much more interesting choice. The engine is an absolute peach and I do prefer the interior of the golf to the a3. There is also the 3.2 a3, not sure if these came with DSG?

Getting away from the s3, you could consider BMW 130, rwd but much smaller and much uglier.

There is also the Alfa 147GTA, amazing engine but really struggles a bit without the slippy front diff (which was only an option I believe). Worries about depreciation and reliabilty put me off.

If 4wd is one of your requirements, considered the current-shape Impreza hatch? Not as "smart" as either of the VAG products but permie 4x4...

DSG, 5-door in black was my choice.

Hope this helps!

Edited by Lefty on Monday 8th November 10:07

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all


Do not consider the four cylinder R. It's very very expensive and the four is not a patch on the beefy six.

S3 has four pot turbo. Quick and tuneable, but very very very dull.

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I've considered the R32 along with the Mazda 6 MPS, both similar performance and 4wd. I'm yet to drive the Mazda but I owned a Golf Edition 30 before the M3.

I'm also looking at sticking with BMW and have driven the 330i and 330d but also quite fancy a 530i. The clutch on the 330d was ridiculously stiff, I'm not sure that is normal, it did put me off a little.

The R32 seems to tick all the boxes really and it sounds fabulous.

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
The r32 is a real jack-of-all.

It's quiet, smooth and comfortable when you need it to be. We've done week-long family holidays (with 2 kids and a shed load of stuff in a roofbox). Also done a camping trip to france with 4 big blokes ( try that in a 1-series). Done a couple of trackdays in it and b-road blasting is it's daily grind.

Hard to fault really.

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
They're certainly very different!

I actually think that a supercharged r32 with ~300-350bhp would be absolutely perfect (and suit the car much more than a turbocharger).

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Republik said:
I've been looking at these as a viable alternative to replace my BMW E46 M3.
^^^ mmm... most folk would be trying to go the other way... scratchchin

Republik said:
Are models 2006 and newer therefore £425 for a year?
^^^ Yeh, But that does mean you could get a mint '55, or VERY early '06 plate and pay £245 VED/pa...

Republik said:
Would you go for the DSG or manual?
^^^ [spec secret!] DSG gives Highline and MFSW as standard and the DSG will really suit the V6. Personally, on a GTI/ED30/S3, I'd stick with manual, but on the V6 - DSG every time.

As someone mentioned, the A3 was available with the 3.2 and DSG. It's a real Q-car, however Audi's customer service is far, far worse than VW.

Republik said:
I also noticed the tank was fairly small (55 litres) given an average of 26 mpg, how many miles (realistically) can I expect to clock up between fill ups?
^^^ My theory has always been to knock 5-6mpg off the published figures to get a 'real world' combined mpg (it's worked for my last two cars). About 300 miles, then?

I average 27 mpg in my MKV GTI, so I reckon 26mpg is a bit optimistic when you have a gorgeous V6 and an extra ~150kg to lug about.... I'm told the DSG combined is 29.1mpg, though.

Edited by FamilyDub on Monday 8th November 10:49

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for all the input chaps. My choice of R32 is not set in stone but is certainly a contender.

If anyone can suggest a practical car in terms of size with the performance and drivability of an E46 M3 for under £14k then please speak now!

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Impreza/Evo. If you can live with the image/looks/crap interiors...

wink

Do you need 4wd?

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
It's not essential I have 4WD, I've driven an E90 330i which also interests me.

Not keen on the Evo/Subaru image even though they are great cars.

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
£14k is a ripe area for some seriously tasty cars.

E39 M5
E55 AMG
Monaro
Maser 3200! (How brave are you?) wink
Nissan 350Z
Benz SL (just)
Subaru Forester can give great performance without the barry image.



Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Early 996?

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Lefty said:
£14k is a ripe area for some seriously tasty cars.

E39 M5
E55 AMG
Monaro
Maser 3200! (How brave are you?) wink
Nissan 350Z
Benz SL (just)
Subaru Forester can give great performance without the barry image.


Aye, but how many of them will be low limeage and still be under manufacturer warranty?


Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Lefty said:
Early 996?
Been there.

Bravery needed.

Republik

Original Poster:

4,525 posts

221 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
I took out a 330D E90 at the weekend. Cracking car, sharp turn in, handles well and feels quick (as a passenger) not so much when you're driving strangley. I couldn't live with that clutch though, far too stiff for my liking (unless the one I drove had a suspect one?) If I went down that route it'd have to be the auto.

Lefty

21,618 posts

233 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Soovy said:
Lefty said:
Early 996?
Been there.

Bravery needed.
rofl

I daresay. Maybe we need some more specifics on what, exactly, the OP is looking for in his new motor!

I saw a nice hayabusa-engined mini for £14k too. wink

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Lefty said:
Soovy said:
Lefty said:
Early 996?
Been there.

Bravery needed.
rofl

I daresay. Maybe we need some more specifics on what, exactly, the OP is looking for in his new motor!

I saw a nice hayabusa-engined mini for £14k too. wink
I had a list



6 or 8 Cylinder
4WD
Nice noise
Good pace
Space
Comfort
Safety
Manufacturer warranty



So Audi S4 or R32.

S4s at that money were five years old, so R32 it was.


I love it.


Edited by Soovy on Monday 8th November 11:41