VW Golf GTI Edition 30 DSG (07) - Exhaust system fault...
Discussion
Hi all,
picked up a Volkswagen Golf GTI Edition 30 (2007) on Thursday 4th November. It only has 24500 miles on the clock. All was good and well until I took it a roundtrip run through to Edinburgh. On the way back the 'Exhaust system fault' / 'Exhaust gas warning lamp' illuminated in the rev counter. It initially flashed and then remained on.
The car was shuddering / vibrating when held at a constant speed and became more pronounced when I gently accelerated. I was on the motorway doing 50mph-60mph. I pulled to the side of the motorway, turned the engine off and on again and it was quite noticeable when in park or neutral.
No idea what suddenly brought this on. It has been perfect up until now.
When I first collected the car I put in a full tank of BP Ultimate unleaded. So decent quality fuel.
Any views.
Its going into the garage where I bought it from first thing tomorrow morning.
I spoke to the guy at the dealership and he advised, being an ex mechanic, that as long as the warning lamp is not red then it should be ok and that a plug or something has come loose. And that the engine is out of synchronicity for some reason.
Is this common? Is this an easy fix?
picked up a Volkswagen Golf GTI Edition 30 (2007) on Thursday 4th November. It only has 24500 miles on the clock. All was good and well until I took it a roundtrip run through to Edinburgh. On the way back the 'Exhaust system fault' / 'Exhaust gas warning lamp' illuminated in the rev counter. It initially flashed and then remained on.
The car was shuddering / vibrating when held at a constant speed and became more pronounced when I gently accelerated. I was on the motorway doing 50mph-60mph. I pulled to the side of the motorway, turned the engine off and on again and it was quite noticeable when in park or neutral.
No idea what suddenly brought this on. It has been perfect up until now.
When I first collected the car I put in a full tank of BP Ultimate unleaded. So decent quality fuel.
Any views.
Its going into the garage where I bought it from first thing tomorrow morning.
I spoke to the guy at the dealership and he advised, being an ex mechanic, that as long as the warning lamp is not red then it should be ok and that a plug or something has come loose. And that the engine is out of synchronicity for some reason.
Is this common? Is this an easy fix?
gordonhunter said:
FamilyDub said:
Sounds like a coil pack causing a misfire
Can you elaborate, is this an easy fix? Why did it suddenly start happening?I need to drive it 25 miles to the garage, will this harm the engine / exhaust?
Get the garage to scan it, you'd usually then see what cylinder(s) are misfiring.
A coil pack is about £30 and a sparkie £10.
The book does mention damaging the cat, but if you're gentle 25 miles will be fine.
The most likely cause is a coilpack as said above, very common and a reltively easy fix. The reason the lamp lights up is that because one of the plugs is not firing, unburnt fuel is being dumped through the exhaust and being picked up by the lambda probe.
Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
cuprabob said:
The most likely cause is a coilpack as said above, very common and a reltively easy fix. The reason the lamp lights up is that because one of the plugs is not firing, unburnt fuel is being dumped through the exhaust and being picked up by the lambda probe.
Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
Hi all,Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
turns out it was not a coil pack. I was advised of this by the garage...
' ... nothing serious just a few fixing grommets and clips for the engine cover which were missing or loose. And since the air hoses are connected to the air supply that’s what’s brought the engine light on and experienced the juddering. The parts are very cheap but unfortunately not in stock ... '
So can someone please enlighten me as to why the car was juddering. I just dont get how an engine cover can be responsible for this?
gordonhunter said:
cuprabob said:
The most likely cause is a coilpack as said above, very common and a reltively easy fix. The reason the lamp lights up is that because one of the plugs is not firing, unburnt fuel is being dumped through the exhaust and being picked up by the lambda probe.
Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
Hi all,Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
turns out it was not a coil pack. I was advised of this by the garage...
' ... nothing serious just a few fixing grommets and clips for the engine cover which were missing or loose. And since the air hoses are connected to the air supply that’s what’s brought the engine light on and experienced the juddering. The parts are very cheap but unfortunately not in stock ... '
So can someone please enlighten me as to why the car was juddering. I just dont get how an engine cover can be responsible for this?
Soovy said:
gordonhunter said:
cuprabob said:
The most likely cause is a coilpack as said above, very common and a reltively easy fix. The reason the lamp lights up is that because one of the plugs is not firing, unburnt fuel is being dumped through the exhaust and being picked up by the lambda probe.
Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
Hi all,Coilpacks don't give any warning and just fail. I'm sure the garage will take care of it for you but for future reference they cost about £30 each.
turns out it was not a coil pack. I was advised of this by the garage...
' ... nothing serious just a few fixing grommets and clips for the engine cover which were missing or loose. And since the air hoses are connected to the air supply that’s what’s brought the engine light on and experienced the juddering. The parts are very cheap but unfortunately not in stock ... '
So can someone please enlighten me as to why the car was juddering. I just dont get how an engine cover can be responsible for this?
gordonhunter said:
And since the air hoses are connected to the air supply that’s what’s brought the engine light on and experienced the juddering.
^^^ That's the key sentence. Air supply issues could be either failed MAF or PCV.If I were you, I'd ask them *exactly* what the issue is, not the layman's explanation.
Hi all,
apologies for not replying sooner. Trying to sort this new car I have bought on 4th November (and regretting). Initially it had absolutely no problems and I was loving every minute. However I now have a gut feeling I have bought into a problem. Lets hope it’s resolved quickly!
The car has been into the garage. They ran it on the diagnostic machine and it registered a fault code that relates to too much air getting into the system. They advised of checking all air hoses etc in case of a collapsed pipe etc. However the mechanic discovered the loose engine cover, which has built in air pipes. So they fixed / secured the cover with ordered parts, cleared the fault memory and ran the car to see if it solved the problem. It didn’t. I have received it back yesterday and it still has the same issue i.e. ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ illuminates. It repeated the same issue on the drive home after being apparently fixed. The distance is only 25 miles on back roads, motorway and a short distance through town – at which point the warning lamp illuminated. They took it around their test route and the warning lamp did not illuminate. Funny that!
Therefore I do not think its a few fixing grommets and clips holding down the engine cover that is the issue. I was advised that the engine cover is not simply a cover but does having pipes / ducting and that because it was loose then air was getting into the system. Now that it has apparently been fixed has still not resolved my issue. So onto the next thing…
Sequence of events (1st time):
1. Travelled from Glasgow to Penicuik. Distance 52 miles. No problem.
2. Travelled back from Penicuik to Glasgow. Whilst on motorway I felt the car shudder and it got more pronounced when accelerating and eased off when maintaining a steady speed.
3. Pulled over and switchen engine off and on. The car has an lumpy idle and was noticeably shuddering. I drove on to get it home.
4. ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ was still on the following morning and I drove it to the dealership 25 miles away with no dramas.
Sequence of events (2nd time):
1. Collected the car and drove it on back roads, motorway and finally town centre for approx 25 miles. About a mile from home the ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ in the rev counter came on.
2. Park up outside the house and went inside for lunch.
3. Started the car up and there was no warning lamp.
4. Drove to the airport, via motorway for a distance of 11 miles, and about half way of that distance the ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ illuminated again!
5. The light remained on and it was driven straight back to dealership.
Its almost as if when the car gets a chance to rest it can recuperate, at which point when started up again will either show no previous symptoms of juddering / labouring and the warning lamp goes off or the warning lamp stays on but the juddering / labouring goes until the car is driven for a while and after an indeterminate amount of time something builds up to a point whereby it causes the vehicle to have lumpy idling and acceleration.
So shuddering under acceleration and idling, could it be:
1. Coil pack
2. Lambda sensor
3. Turbo faulty valve
4. Temperature sensor
5. Mass Air Flow sensor
6. Coolant temperature sensor
I am at a loss and it needs a very thorough diagnosis and pro-longed test-drive.
Came across these
http://www.ehow.co.uk/list_6005864_symptoms-faulty...
http://www.ehow.com/list_5794328_signs-mass-air-fl...
http://www.ehow.co.uk/facts_7190339_symptoms-bad-p...
Hmmm...
apologies for not replying sooner. Trying to sort this new car I have bought on 4th November (and regretting). Initially it had absolutely no problems and I was loving every minute. However I now have a gut feeling I have bought into a problem. Lets hope it’s resolved quickly!
The car has been into the garage. They ran it on the diagnostic machine and it registered a fault code that relates to too much air getting into the system. They advised of checking all air hoses etc in case of a collapsed pipe etc. However the mechanic discovered the loose engine cover, which has built in air pipes. So they fixed / secured the cover with ordered parts, cleared the fault memory and ran the car to see if it solved the problem. It didn’t. I have received it back yesterday and it still has the same issue i.e. ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ illuminates. It repeated the same issue on the drive home after being apparently fixed. The distance is only 25 miles on back roads, motorway and a short distance through town – at which point the warning lamp illuminated. They took it around their test route and the warning lamp did not illuminate. Funny that!
Therefore I do not think its a few fixing grommets and clips holding down the engine cover that is the issue. I was advised that the engine cover is not simply a cover but does having pipes / ducting and that because it was loose then air was getting into the system. Now that it has apparently been fixed has still not resolved my issue. So onto the next thing…
Sequence of events (1st time):
1. Travelled from Glasgow to Penicuik. Distance 52 miles. No problem.
2. Travelled back from Penicuik to Glasgow. Whilst on motorway I felt the car shudder and it got more pronounced when accelerating and eased off when maintaining a steady speed.
3. Pulled over and switchen engine off and on. The car has an lumpy idle and was noticeably shuddering. I drove on to get it home.
4. ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ was still on the following morning and I drove it to the dealership 25 miles away with no dramas.
Sequence of events (2nd time):
1. Collected the car and drove it on back roads, motorway and finally town centre for approx 25 miles. About a mile from home the ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ in the rev counter came on.
2. Park up outside the house and went inside for lunch.
3. Started the car up and there was no warning lamp.
4. Drove to the airport, via motorway for a distance of 11 miles, and about half way of that distance the ‘Exhaust gas warning lamp’ illuminated again!
5. The light remained on and it was driven straight back to dealership.
Its almost as if when the car gets a chance to rest it can recuperate, at which point when started up again will either show no previous symptoms of juddering / labouring and the warning lamp goes off or the warning lamp stays on but the juddering / labouring goes until the car is driven for a while and after an indeterminate amount of time something builds up to a point whereby it causes the vehicle to have lumpy idling and acceleration.
So shuddering under acceleration and idling, could it be:
1. Coil pack
2. Lambda sensor
3. Turbo faulty valve
4. Temperature sensor
5. Mass Air Flow sensor
6. Coolant temperature sensor
I am at a loss and it needs a very thorough diagnosis and pro-longed test-drive.
Came across these
http://www.ehow.co.uk/list_6005864_symptoms-faulty...
http://www.ehow.com/list_5794328_signs-mass-air-fl...
http://www.ehow.co.uk/facts_7190339_symptoms-bad-p...
Hmmm...
Probably worth getting the fault code reader and checking yourself. They are pretty cheap off ebay and useful for the future.
I know they have said no to coilpacks but VW have a history with these breaking down. I have had to replace all 5 on my Mk4 over the past few years. It is a known problem. When they break down it gives a similar symptom to what you have described.
I know they have said no to coilpacks but VW have a history with these breaking down. I have had to replace all 5 on my Mk4 over the past few years. It is a known problem. When they break down it gives a similar symptom to what you have described.
^^^ thank you for re-iterating what I said about 8 posts ago...
When I had my first (of many) exhaust warning issues the *exact* wording the garage used was 'system drawing air'.
This was - as the photographer says, repeating what I said - a fault with the positive crankcase ventilation, aka PCV.
The part is about £30, or it was when I had mine replaced.
When I had my first (of many) exhaust warning issues the *exact* wording the garage used was 'system drawing air'.
This was - as the photographer says, repeating what I said - a fault with the positive crankcase ventilation, aka PCV.
The part is about £30, or it was when I had mine replaced.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


