RS4 Tyre Choice
Author
Discussion

NorthernBoy

Original Poster:

12,642 posts

288 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
I'm about to get four Vredestein Ultrac Sessantas fitted to my B7 RS4, and am trying to decide between 255/35s and 275/30s, which I now that a lot of people ar choosing.

The wider tyre might stop me clouting my rims quite so often (I have no idea why I do this, I've never done it in any other car), but I suppose could also make the steering a bit heavier.

Has anyone else made the switch to the wider rubber, and could they let me know how it is (and why they did it, too?)

It was a common thing a year back, I think, but that was as likely as not down to the stock fit being hard to come by.

gmk666

1,679 posts

256 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
I was going to direct you towards rs246.com, but just noticed you've found your own way there.
A fair few of the guys on there have gone with non-standard sized tyres, not least to save a bit of cash, so have a search.

You're right about the need to protect the rims though. It's very easy to forget how bloody wide RS4s are.paperbag

NorthernBoy

Original Poster:

12,642 posts

288 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Yes, thanks, I've posted there too. The two sizes are now identically priced at my local fitter (a pretty reasonable £175 per corner), so I'm left wondering if people still fit the larger ones now that the price difference has gone.

I'd hate to find that I've compromised the handling, but hopefully someone over there will chip in with the facts.

It's interesting, the only time people are normally directed over there from here is when someone is determined to show that the B7 RS4 is a heap of junk with engine problems and made-up power claims. The consensus on that site, though, is that this really isn't the case.

gmk666

1,679 posts

256 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
NorthernBoy said:
It's interesting, the only time people are normally directed over there from here is when someone is determined to show that the B7 RS4 is a heap of junk with engine problems and made-up power claims. The consensus on that site, though, is that this really isn't the case.
Always the way, isn't it? The people with the problems shout the loudest. I wouldn't say the RS4 is without its issues (I had mine 2 years and it needed its DRC replacing, for example) but the power, poise and sheer presence of the thing more than made up for that.

NorthernBoy

Original Poster:

12,642 posts

288 months

Friday 12th November 2010
quotequote all
Absolutely. I'm not in favor of hiding genuine problems (and by the way, what were the symptoms of your failure, did you get a warning light, or did you just feel it?), but the "power issue" seems to be an invented problem. People are putting the cars on a rolling road dyno, getting figures entirely consistent with 414ps and quattro drive train losses, and complaining that it's less than the quoted crank figure.

Similarly with "coking up". It's all "a guy I know had a mate who heard about this happening".

The car isn't perfect, but it is extremely good, and is also, I'd say, a real bargain when you can get immaculate examples well below 30k.

gmk666

1,679 posts

256 months

Friday 12th November 2010
quotequote all
NorthernBoy said:
What were the symptoms of your failure, did you get a warning light, or did you just feel it?)
The symptoms of the DRC were a knocking sound over speedbumps and leaking around the shocks. No warning lights.
Supposedly some moisture is acceptable, but the car was in for a service anyway and it was still under warranty, so the dealer replaced all four corners.

NorthernBoy

Original Poster:

12,642 posts

288 months

Friday 12th November 2010
quotequote all
Thanks. No symptoms of that on mine yet.

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
NorthernBoy said:
Absolutely. I'm not in favor of hiding genuine problems (and by the way, what were the symptoms of your failure, did you get a warning light, or did you just feel it?), but the "power issue" seems to be an invented problem. People are putting the cars on a rolling road dyno, getting figures entirely consistent with 414ps and quattro drive train losses, and complaining that it's less than the quoted crank figure.

Similarly with "coking up". It's all "a guy I know had a mate who heard about this happening".

The car isn't perfect, but it is extremely good, and is also, I'd say, a real bargain when you can get immaculate examples well below 30k.
OK, I'll take the bait....

84K on my B7 RS4, 74K of those miles added by me in 3 years. My car suffers coaking, I've had it cleaned twice. My car has been on a rolling road twice, it showed 366bhp first time, 378bhp second time after decoaking. I can't speak about transmission losses but I can say that it's as quick as an E46 M3 in a straight line, which is not what I would expect of 414bhp transmission losses or not!

So this "it's a guy I know" is utter bks, I'm one of them and I know many others. Having said this as a day to day car it is great, flawed yes but the fact I am still pounding up and down the motorway in it tells you I am happy to put up with those flaws, but don't be foolish enough to thing the concerns OWNERS share are based on pixies dust and fairy tales. The coaking issue is real, I've seen it and paid once and had Audi pay once to have it cleaned, they even paid for my warranty renew after 3 years due to my issues....

Edited by Housey on Monday 29th November 16:41

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
84K and NO DRC issues mind, so mine is a special one, last check was Friday too!

NorthernBoy

Original Poster:

12,642 posts

288 months

Monday 29th November 2010
quotequote all
So, Housey, yours produces pretty respectable figures, well in line with 414bhp at the crank, and both numbers are close enough to be consistent with each other, and this is evidence of a problem?

Colour me far from convinced, I'm afraid.

chrissyr32

736 posts

214 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
Housey said:
NorthernBoy said:
Absolutely. I'm not in favor of hiding genuine problems (and by the way, what were the symptoms of your failure, did you get a warning light, or did you just feel it?), but the "power issue" seems to be an invented problem. People are putting the cars on a rolling road dyno, getting figures entirely consistent with 414ps and quattro drive train losses, and complaining that it's less than the quoted crank figure.

Similarly with "coking up". It's all "a guy I know had a mate who heard about this happening".

The car isn't perfect, but it is extremely good, and is also, I'd say, a real bargain when you can get immaculate examples well below 30k.
OK, I'll take the bait....

84K on my B7 RS4, 74K of those miles added by me in 3 years. My car suffers coaking, I've had it cleaned twice. My car has been on a rolling road twice, it showed 366bhp first time, 378bhp second time after decoaking. I can't speak about transmission losses but I can say that it's as quick as an E46 M3 in a straight line, which is not what I would expect of 414bhp transmission losses or not!

So this "it's a guy I know" is utter bks, I'm one of them and I know many others. Having said this as a day to day car it is great, flawed yes but the fact I am still pounding up and down the motorway in it tells you I am happy to put up with those flaws, but don't be foolish enough to thing the concerns OWNERS share are based on pixies dust and fairy tales. The coaking issue is real, I've seen it and paid once and had Audi pay once to have it cleaned, they even paid for my warranty renew after 3 years due to my issues....

Edited by Housey on Monday 29th November 16:41
How did you get Audi to pay for the decoking????

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
chrissyr32 said:
Housey said:
NorthernBoy said:
Absolutely. I'm not in favor of hiding genuine problems (and by the way, what were the symptoms of your failure, did you get a warning light, or did you just feel it?), but the "power issue" seems to be an invented problem. People are putting the cars on a rolling road dyno, getting figures entirely consistent with 414ps and quattro drive train losses, and complaining that it's less than the quoted crank figure.

Similarly with "coking up". It's all "a guy I know had a mate who heard about this happening".

The car isn't perfect, but it is extremely good, and is also, I'd say, a real bargain when you can get immaculate examples well below 30k.
OK, I'll take the bait....

84K on my B7 RS4, 74K of those miles added by me in 3 years. My car suffers coaking, I've had it cleaned twice. My car has been on a rolling road twice, it showed 366bhp first time, 378bhp second time after decoaking. I can't speak about transmission losses but I can say that it's as quick as an E46 M3 in a straight line, which is not what I would expect of 414bhp transmission losses or not!

So this "it's a guy I know" is utter bks, I'm one of them and I know many others. Having said this as a day to day car it is great, flawed yes but the fact I am still pounding up and down the motorway in it tells you I am happy to put up with those flaws, but don't be foolish enough to thing the concerns OWNERS share are based on pixies dust and fairy tales. The coaking issue is real, I've seen it and paid once and had Audi pay once to have it cleaned, they even paid for my warranty renew after 3 years due to my issues....

Edited by Housey on Monday 29th November 16:41
How did you get Audi to pay for the decoking????
Because the car had been in 6 or 7 times for emissions issues, where the engine management light kept coming on. Because the car had been in 2 times for 'breathing' issues and off the road of nearly 10 weeks in 1 year. Because I've bought a few Audi's from new, because I had 2 on my drive at the time and because I was beyond pissed off and very annoyed at 'the brand'. My dealer felt this warranted them funding a new warranty and an engine clean. The coaking issues was new to them and they were working with Audi on an ECU mod too.

brisel

981 posts

239 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
Getting back on topic, and slightly hijacking the thread:

I'm in the process of choosing tyres for my B5 RS4 (255/35/ZR18) and am trying to find a reason NOT to put a set of Michelin Pilot Sport 3s on for circa £203 each.

Have looked at Goodyear F1 asymmetrics, Conti Sport Maxx and Pirelli P Zero Rossos too. Vredesteins seem to do well in Which? reviews but I can't find a local supplier.

Any thoughts?

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
NorthernBoy said:
So, Housey, yours produces pretty respectable figures, well in line with 414bhp at the crank, and both numbers are close enough to be consistent with each other, and this is evidence of a problem?

Colour me far from convinced, I'm afraid.
Sorry, you seem to have already made your mind up and feel the need to defend your purchase, I am more open minded. You are debating opinion, mine is based on perhaps a bit more than your interpretation of what Audi's transmission losses are, but if you're good with that I'll sleep tight rest assured. I've had plenty of track runs (VMax for example) where I have run my 414bhp car against much less well endowed cars and struggled to pull a gap, cars that performance stats suggest shouldn't be close. Now far from scientific that might be I do believe it shows a deficiency. I've had all sorts of people jumping on the "you were in the wrong gear" or "transmission losses are wrong" bandwagon but none seem able to provide qualified proof of THEIR view.

I'm not seeking to convince anyone, I never suggested it caused me a personal issue...I just took issue with you suggesting coaking was rubbish and hear say for THAT is utter bks and my proof on that is empirical, I've seen it AND had Audi admit to it!

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
brisel said:
Getting back on topic, and slightly hijacking the thread:

I'm in the process of choosing tyres for my B5 RS4 (255/35/ZR18) and am trying to find a reason NOT to put a set of Michelin Pilot Sport 3s on for circa £203 each.

Have looked at Goodyear F1 asymmetrics, Conti Sport Maxx and Pirelli P Zero Rossos too. Vredesteins seem to do well in Which? reviews but I can't find a local supplier.

Any thoughts?
Not that this helps but I am about to put 4 onto my B7. I have run P Zero and F1's and for me the P Zero was the better tyre on THAT car. The asymms give the impression of being 'wobbly' not least on track and also suffer pushon at slow speeds when on full lock. Again not scientific just my take.

Mermaid

21,492 posts

202 months

Tuesday 30th November 2010
quotequote all
Housey said:
NorthernBoy said:
So, Housey, yours produces pretty respectable figures, well in line with 414bhp at the crank, and both numbers are close enough to be consistent with each other, and this is evidence of a problem?

Colour me far from convinced, I'm afraid.
Sorry, you seem to have already made your mind up and feel the need to defend your purchase, I am more open minded. You are debating opinion, mine is based on perhaps a bit more than your interpretation of what Audi's transmission losses are, but if you're good with that I'll sleep tight rest assured. I've had plenty of track runs (VMax for example) where I have run my 414bhp car against much less well endowed cars and struggled to pull a gap, cars that performance stats suggest shouldn't be close. Now far from scientific that might be I do believe it shows a deficiency. I've had all sorts of people jumping on the "you were in the wrong gear" or "transmission losses are wrong" bandwagon but none seem able to provide qualified proof of THEIR view.

I'm not seeking to convince anyone, I never suggested it caused me a personal issue...I just took issue with you suggesting coaking was rubbish and hear say for THAT is utter bks and my proof on that is empirical, I've seen it AND had Audi admit to it!
That's fair.thumbup

oNeGuy

1 posts

191 months

Monday 6th December 2010
quotequote all
I know it might probably not mean much, but thought I'd give some useless input anyway. wink

Gone through two sets of Pirelli P Zero on my B7. Currently running on a set of Conti Sport. My impression is that the P Zeros are the better tires if you're looking for that solid racing feeling. The Conti Sport feels slightly less solid around the corners. The Conti does a great job of gripping on the "POWER" straights though.

Have not looked at Goodyear F1 yet, as they had no stock when I needed tires. I have also not tried Michelin yet, but out of own preference.

My next set of tires will probably be P Zero again. biggrin

DMS1979

81 posts

256 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Housey said:
My car has been on a rolling road twice, it showed 366bhp first time, 378bhp second time after decoaking.
Talking about rolling road you seen this ...
http://biertijd.com/mediaplayer/?itemid=24531

Housey

2,079 posts

258 months

Saturday 18th December 2010
quotequote all


Just had these fitted today, back to PZero's and a better bet than the Goodyears I've been running. Much more suited to the car.