Golf GTI or A3 2.0T
Author
Discussion

graham22

Original Poster:

3,328 posts

236 months

Wednesday 10th November 2010
quotequote all
Have been looking at MkV Golf GTIs but have noticed A3s with the same 2.0T motor for similar, if not better money.

Does anyone have any direct comparisoms between the two? Is the Audi better spec'd than the Golf (leather, 6 CD etc).

A nice spec A3 S-line Quattro has taken my attention. Not really bothered about the 4WD but does this add signficantly to running costs - have heard stories about replacing all 4 tyres at a time etc? Little difference in tax but what about fuel.

I have tried to steer away from Audis as my father seems to be having no end of niggles with his '03 A4 but guessing the Golf & Audi are basically the same.

Am aware of coilpack, MAF issues from owning an Ibiza Cupra in the past.

Looking to spend £8-9k on a 05/06 car. Ideal spec would be 3dr GTI with 18" Monzas and Xenons or 3dr S-line.

The outside alterrnative would be a E46 330d BMW M-sport but the coupes are still a little out of my price range - is it worth waiting/saving?

Edited by graham22 on Wednesday 10th November 23:02

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
The wife has an A2 2.0T quattro. Rock solid car and fairly nimble - small turbo spools up nicely. Engine in great up to around 5k revs then it seems to run out of steam a bit. Have no doubt the extra few kilos of the quattro dulls performance a little but 200bhp in a smallish car goes a long way.

Never had any real problems with it. Goes around 13k between services and gets around mid 30s to the gallon (she has a rather gentle right foot). That same gentle right foot means she gets around 25k miles out of a set of tyres. No problem changing 2 of these at once either.

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Agree that tyres can last 20k, but should be kept within 1mm on each axle and 2mm front to rear iirc. Please correct me if I'm wrong!

I'm running a A4 avant 2.0T Q and an 8L S3.

Dr G

16,016 posts

273 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
You don't need to be *that* precise with tyres on a quattro, you wouldn't want 2mm and 8mm on the same axle but you wouldn't want that on any car. Be reasonably sensible and you'll be fine.

Now, as for Golf vs A3 I have a MK5 GTI and drive A3s every day in various versions. The A3 has a better interior (but worse seats), a better dash, is more refined and tends to come with a better spec.

BUT...

Buy the Golf, dynamically it is significantly better. It rides and steers in a way that the A3 doesn't, despite their similarities. It is significantly more fun, the A3 is a junior Audi and everything that goes with that whereas the GTI is genuinely very good fun to hustle.

^ just my two penneth wink

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
You don't need to be *that* precise with tyres on a quattro, you wouldn't want 2mm and 8mm on the same axle but you wouldn't want that on any car. Be reasonably sensible and you'll be fine.
Thanks for your advice - I wont hijack the thread anymore

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
BlueProp said:
Agree that tyres can last 20k, but should be kept within 1mm on each axle and 2mm front to rear iirc. Please correct me if I'm wrong!

I'm running a A4 avant 2.0T Q and an 8L S3.
A3 uses haldex so you don't need to worry about front to rear relative tyre depths. It's not true 4wd it's AWD as it's FWD until the front slip then the drive trnsfers to the rear wheels.

It's cars with Torsen such as the larger audis that you need to be concerned about changing all 4 tyres at the same tread depths.

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
BlueProp said:
Agree that tyres can last 20k, but should be kept within 1mm on each axle and 2mm front to rear iirc. Please correct me if I'm wrong!

I'm running a A4 avant 2.0T Q and an 8L S3.
A3 uses haldex so you don't need to worry about front to rear relative tyre depths. It's not true 4wd it's AWD as it's FWD until the front slip then the drive trnsfers to the rear wheels.

It's cars with Torsen such as the larger audis that you need to be concerned about changing all 4 tyres at the same tread depths.
Thanks again. Only recently bought the S3. Good to know.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Thursday 11th November 2010
quotequote all
A wee 2.0 T quattro A3 with a wee cheeky remap would be a nice Q-car.

graham22

Original Poster:

3,328 posts

236 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

Have just put a deposit down on a late 2005 A3 2.0T S-Line Quattro. Dark Green, full leather, Bose, 59k miles with full main dealer history - 6 months tax left on the car, 12 months MoT and cambelt was changed at last service in March (car not 5 yrs old until Dec!).

Just have sort my funds for that re-map.

Did try a 330D but just didn't like the typical diesel power delivery.

Dr G

16,016 posts

273 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all
Deep green? Rare colour that, right up my street and really suits the A3.

Share some pictures once you've taken delivery smile

graham22

Original Poster:

3,328 posts

236 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all



Pics from dealer's website, so dark a green it's nearly black.

He also has a very tidy original 2000 S3 with 54k on it which had me thinking.

Dr G

16,016 posts

273 months

Friday 19th November 2010
quotequote all
I'd have taken your A3 over an old S3, as nice as they were back in the day they're starting to feel quite dated and can be expensive to maintain.

If you plan to play with/upgrade yours you have a great many options open for both toys and performance too.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Saturday 20th November 2010
quotequote all
That's a nice tidy motor, chap.

Cheeky remap and that'll be discreet, safe, performance car. thumbup

Dr G

16,016 posts

273 months

Monday 22nd November 2010
quotequote all
Agreed, will go like stink and properly take advantage of quattro. Do the diverter valve at the same time, at 54k if yours is original it probably won't take too much punishment.