A3 Quattro opinions
Author
Discussion

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Monday 6th December 2010
quotequote all
Come the new year, I'm on the look out for a new daily driver. Budget of up to 10k(ish) for a comfortable, smart, practical and reliable all-rounder. Fuel consumption is not a primary concern, but I'd like to be able to achieve 30mpg on a run.

I'd like a newer (and less niggle-prone) version of my old Golf 4Motion, and wondered what the A3 Quattros are like?

I don't want an R32 - I want something more understated that can be parked out on the street or used for business without attracting too much attention. But 4x4 (even the Haldex version) appeals for year-round competance.

The 2.0T fsi and the 3.2 V6 A3 Quattros have both caught my eye. The 2.0 appeals with its lower tax and slightly better mpg.

So anyone got any experience of these? Anything in particular to look out for? Does the Golf Gti engine go well with the Haldex 4wd system? Any big bills to be aware of?

I haven't started test-driving yet, but (as always) would welcome the wisdom of the PH collective.

Cheers

Gruber.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Only drove a 170 tdi quattro s-line - it was lumpen and generally awful

unless you need 4wd dont bother, the 2wd is the sweeter of the two

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
Only drove a 170 tdi quattro s-line - it was lumpen and generally awful

unless you need 4wd dont bother, the 2wd is the sweeter of the two
I found that the non-quattro could barely go in a straight line under reasonable throttle.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Odd, not a problem in mine

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Wife has a 2.0T quattro A3, had it 5 years from new. Nice car - solid, reliable and shifts although the engine does run out of steam a bit above 5k rpm. Not the most agile thing on the planet but I doubt many would expect that.

Mid 30s mpg and pretty low running costs, have had very little go wrong with it.

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Thanks chaps - helpful stuff. An interesting mix of views!

Gren: that sounds positive! As you say, I'm not expecting it to be an Elise challenger - just a good everyday hack with a sufficient turn of speed to stop me getting too bored.

SleepEnvy: what was so bad about it?

Any other views?

I'd also welcome suggestions for alternatives...

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
don't think the 2.0 has enough power to warrant it, you're just pulling extra weight around with you and an a3 needs all the help it can get in terms of dynamics

as I said, if you need it then it's a different story

I live in centralish London so couldn't see the point in paying more, using more fuel, more serviceable items, etc, etc

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
baz1985 said:
sleep envy said:
Only drove a 170 tdi quattro s-line - it was lumpen and generally awful

unless you need 4wd dont bother, the 2wd is the sweeter of the two
I found that the non-quattro could barely go in a straight line under reasonable throttle.
It was broken, then laugh

2.0T quattro is a nice thing although so is the 2wd model; do you need four driven wheels or plan to tune it? Can't say I've missed it (have gone A4 quattro > MKV Golf GTI) other than in snowy car parks. I spend most of my time in and around London and haven't yet found a road that careful driving couldn't traverse.

heightswitch

6,322 posts

281 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
baz1985 said:
sleep envy said:
Only drove a 170 tdi quattro s-line - it was lumpen and generally awful

unless you need 4wd dont bother, the 2wd is the sweeter of the two
I found that the non-quattro could barely go in a straight line under reasonable throttle.
It was broken, then laugh

2.0T quattro is a nice thing although so is the 2wd model; do you need four driven wheels or plan to tune it? Can't say I've missed it (have gone A4 quattro > MKV Golf GTI) other than in snowy car parks. I spend most of my time in and around London and haven't yet found a road that careful driving couldn't traverse.
A4 2.0T FSI Quattro everytime. The A3 - A4 are like chalk and chese regards ride, handling, cabin noise, booming and general feel. The A4 also has a proper 4 wheel drive system not just a haldex. Pay the 2-3k premium it is worth every penny. The A3 is noisy, harsh and unrefined compared to the A4, On paper it shouldn't be but believe me it is.

if you search on here you will find a previous post about the merits of various Audis.

Here is a post I posted a couple of months back.... Unlike some I have owned the cars all back to back...

"
Its all down to what you want.

In the past 5 years I have owned a 2.7 S4 avant, a 2.0 TDi A4 a 2.0 TDi A3 Quattro Sport and then an SE Ltd edition 2.0T Quattro A4.

as someone who puts lots of miles on cars I would comment as follows.

The S4 was the best car I ever owned i put 60k miles on in 18 months and traded it in for a TVR griffith at 100k miles. I still miss the grunt. It always felt faster than the first generation V8 S4 which didn't have the kick in the back the twin turbo had and as a result I never felt the need to spend a load of money to change the car.

Because I and the wife do lots of miles we put our sensible shoes on and went to a 2.0 Tdi A4 avant and I immediately regretted not buying the quattro version. after a winter of not getting out of the drive I bought a 2.0 Tdi quattro A3.

owning both back to back I can honestly say that the haldex equipped A3 car is a totally different experience to any A4. It is noisier, harsher,has more wind roar and road noise and even though the running gear is the same is a vastly different ride to any A4. The missus hated the A3 compared to the A4, so much so that we swapped it for an A4 2.0T SE Quattro Limited edition with 220hp.

Now yes the S4 was faster, but in the real world at rolling speed the 2.0t handles better, is much more balanced than the bigger engined car and unless you are pulling away from standing starts or on a circuit is no faster point to point.

The S4 gave me a best average of about 26 / 27 MPG if driving sensibly
The A4 2wd Tdi returned about 52 MPG. the best I got out of the A3 Quattro was 46 MPG.

The missus came back from crewe the other day to Northumberland Via Penrith and Hartside in a 220hp Quattro and returned 42.8 to the gallon.

Now as someone who thought I would never go back to a petrol after a diesel The argument for buying an Oil burner is pretty minimal.

With 220hp, 0-60 in 6.5 seconds and such mega fuel economy. the argument for buying a V8 for the noise is really something only reserved for persons living in the middle east. Ultimate performance figures are something for top trumps cards. Real world between 50 - 90mph is where you make a decision.

The residuals also speak for themselves.

N



Edited by heightswitch on Tuesday 7th December 18:15

Basil Hume

1,389 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
I have a fully loaded 2.0T Quattro S-Line. I wrote about my initial impressions in my "garage" section of my profile some time ago.

Although it's not a track day car, I certainly wouldn't be worried about performance with a 2.0T. The engine is the same as the Golf GTi and standard 0-60 is well under 7 secs with the 4WD option. Theoretcially, you're knocking on the door of S3 performance once you've added a simple map (as I have).

I'm usually a bit more of a "Pistonhead" in my choice of car, but realistically this is as about as good as a car gets in terms of being something good to own and live with.

"Thinking man's Golf GTI". smile


FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
I thought I'd chime in....

If you need the kudos, MKV GTI = WIN
If you want the subtlety, A3 2.0 T = WIN

IMO, buying the A3 2.0T Quattro would necessitate a re-map to be pushing S3 levels of pace. thumbup A3 2.0T FWD will be fine on it's own.

Some of these consumption figures seem bonkers for a 2.0T ^^^ to me. I'd say 30 mpg combined is fairly easy to achieve...

However, personally, I'm too impatient to be worried about fuel consumption and besides, I've never understood why folk buy a fast car to sit at 56mpm on motorways... buy a diesel if you need mpg figures in the 40's+.

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
My B7 A4 2.0T Quattro Tiptronic MPG rarely gets above 30 on a run, 28 is the average.

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
PH is brilliant, isn't it?! Thanks for all the responses. Quite a lot to take in.

Blueprop - thanks for the warning: I was planning to go manual rather than auto if I go down the A3 / A4 route.

FamilyDub - I haven't written off the idea of a MkV GTi, but I really do want something relatively under-stated. What's the collective's view on manual v DSG on the GTi? And how re-mappable is the 2.0T lump?

Basil Hume - your profile review makes interesting reading and it's reassuring that you're still happy with it after almost 18 months. From what you and Gren said, it looks as if the A3 Q TFsi is perhaps just what I'm looking for.

Heightswitch - some interesting comparisons there. I'd considered something 2.7T powered but was scared off by the risk of big bills given they're all getting rather long in the tooth. I hadn't really considered an A4, partly because "herself" will not want to drive a car that feels too big, but it's certainly worth a look.

Sleep Envy / Dr G - nope, you're right - I don't really need 4x4. But then I don't really need a 1986 635csi. But this is PH and we all have our peculiarities. I'm not a great fan of FWD, on the whole, and really liked the added surety that the Haldex system brought to my 4mot and R32. I appreciate it has it's downsides, but to my mind it is worth the sacrifices.

Sorry for the long reply, but I'm grateful for all your responses.

I feel I'm still a long way from a decision and, obviously, I need to do some test-driving. And other contenders include another 4Mot (with a fighting fund for the inevitable bills), a Subaru Legacy, a MkV GTi and perhaps a 1-series BMW coupe with a diesel engine. But I'm a big fan of VAG (as it were... ahem...) and so Audi and Golf are the obvious starting points.

Decisions, decisions, decisions...

Cheers!

Gruber.



Edited by Gruber on Tuesday 7th December 22:48

catso

16,584 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Gruber said:
Fuel consumption is not a primary concern, but I'd like to be able to achieve 30mpg on a run.

The 2.0T fsi and the 3.2 V6 A3 Quattros have both caught my eye. The 2.0 appeals with its lower tax and slightly better mpg.
Not driven the 2L, I have the 3.2L quattro DSG - it may not have the 'proper' 4wd but it still drives all 4 wheels and goes very well under all road conditions and definitely better than anything FWD, even in this heavy snow/ice that we have at the moment.

I have driven a diesel FWD version and the torque steer was dreadful, none of that with the quattro.

I've had mine for 6 years and would normally have changed it a couple of years ago ago but because it does everything I need from it so well I've hung on to it. The only downside is that the fuel consumption is not great but not really too bad considering the performance, however I have never managed 30mpg even on a run and it averages around 23mpg and it certainly is a 'sleeper'.

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
catso said:
Gruber said:
Fuel consumption is not a primary concern, but I'd like to be able to achieve 30mpg on a run.

The 2.0T fsi and the 3.2 V6 A3 Quattros have both caught my eye. The 2.0 appeals with its lower tax and slightly better mpg.
Not driven the 2L, I have the 3.2L quattro DSG - it may not have the 'proper' 4wd but it still drives all 4 wheels and goes very well under all road conditions and definitely better than anything FWD, even in this heavy snow/ice that we have at the moment.

I have driven a diesel FWD version and the torque steer was dreadful, none of that with the quattro.

I've had mine for 6 years and would normally have changed it a couple of years ago ago but because it does everything I need from it so well I've hung on to it. The only downside is that the fuel consumption is not great but not really too bad considering the performance, however I have never managed 30mpg even on a run and it averages around 23mpg and it certainly is a 'sleeper'.
Catso - thanks! Just as I was thinking 2 litres and f.i. was the way to go, you pipe up and remind me that there's no replacement for displacement.

How do you find the DSG? I know very little about it - is it a semi-auto box like BMW's SMG or is it a straight auto with manual over-ride? And does it suit the V6?

catso

16,584 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
Gruber said:
How do you find the DSG? I know very little about it - is it a semi-auto box like BMW's SMG or is it a straight auto with manual over-ride? And does it suit the V6?
DSG is a twin-clutch mechanical box with electromechanical selection and can run as an auto or sequential manual, IMHO better than SMG (at least the one I tried in an M3).

The 2 clutch setup means it selects the next gear before changing up so that there is virtually no 'gap' in the shift and on downshifts it blips the throttle to sync engine speed to road speed for quick/smooth shift, some people don't get on with it as it is a bit 'playstation' and you do need to learn how to use but it works very well and shifts much faster/smoother than you can do manually and yet is an auto when you want it to be - best of both worlds IMO, which is exactly what I wanted.

It suits the power delivery of the V6 very well.

Oh, and there really is no replacement for displacement - but you already knew that... wink

Edited by catso on Tuesday 7th December 23:13

Gruber

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

245 months

Tuesday 7th December 2010
quotequote all
catso said:
Oh, and there really is no replacement for displacement - but you already knew that... wink
Hmmmm. We know how this is going to end, don't we.... driving

Maybe I'll be in with a chance of a prize for highest average "cc". 3.5 is the 6er, 3.0 in the Merc and 3.2 in the Audi. Happy days!

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 8th December 2010
quotequote all
Gruber said:
FamilyDub - I haven't written off the idea of a MkV GTi, but I really do want something relatively under-stated. What's the collective's view on manual v DSG on the GTi? And how re-mappable is the 2.0T lump?
^^^ From your other posts, I'm thinking A3 3.2 is the one you really want. hehe

For what it's worth, DSG comes highly recommended by all those that have it. I rarely exceed 8k miles a year, so I couldn't justify the DSG to myself - on a 2.0 T, anyway.

The V6 would be excellent with DSG/S-Tronic, though...

kentmotorcompany

2,471 posts

241 months

Wednesday 8th December 2010
quotequote all
I've had both, and personally I would take the Quattro. The 2WD is a good car, but with the more powerful engines I think the Quattro is better.

The 3.2 A3 is a great car, and a perfect alternative to the R32 if you prefer the more understated look.

If it is registered before 23 March 2006 it not be in the highest Road tax band either.