New clutch or not?
Author
Discussion

millicent

Original Poster:

44 posts

214 months

Wednesday 8th December 2010
quotequote all
Hi there, how do I know when I need to replace my clutch?
I have a 52 plate Golf 1.8T GTI (150) and its sometimes hard to get it into first gear or reverse.
Any idea how much a new clutch and fitting would set me back?

Thanks,
Gemma.

Hub

7,179 posts

229 months

Thursday 9th December 2010
quotequote all
That probably isn't the clutch - it could be one of a number of things, from gearbox oil, gear linkages, clutch slave cylinder etc. Does it happen all the time, or when the car is cold for example?

Is it just first and reverse? Is the clutch any heavier than usual or bites right at the top?

millicent

Original Poster:

44 posts

214 months

Thursday 9th December 2010
quotequote all
No its quite a low bite actually. It doesn't do it all the time. Just occasionally and its only first and reverse. Sometimes at traffic lights. I've never found it a problem, but my Dad drove it last night and told me he thought it needed a new clutch. he said the gears were hard to engage and were only engaging right at the bottom of the travel. I haven't noticed but I drive it every day so could I just be used to it?

BlueProp

4,553 posts

199 months

Friday 10th December 2010
quotequote all
Sounds like the problem I had recently with my S3 - new clutch and fly wheel - OUCH!

sider

2,061 posts

252 months

Saturday 11th December 2010
quotequote all
What sort of mileage is it on?

My clutch started to slip at around 80k. I remember speaking to mates who said it should go to 100k or so without a new clutch required. But the guy who services my car and ended up doing the job, who i believe to be an honest bloke, said that it depends what kind of driving the car does and has done in the past with previous owners.

When you drive it, do you feel that you're over-revving it before the car seems to get in touch with the gear that it's in?

There's a rough test you can do - i remember seeing it online - but if youre clutch hasn't gone, the test will help it to do so i reckon. Something like engine off, engage 4th gear, engine on with clutch down, and then raise clutch. If car stalls in first 25% of pedal travel, then the clutch is fine, if it goes past the 25% mark, shows that clutch is or has going/gone. I tried it with mine and i managed to get my foot almost to the top of the pedal travel before the engine stalled. I could tell mine had gone though really given that the car over-revved and the revs seem to go faster than the car was.

sider

2,061 posts

252 months

Saturday 11th December 2010
quotequote all
Millicent - where are you based also? Know a couple of decent independent garages in the North West who could sort this for you.