A4 2.0 TFSI - will I be happy coming from a V6?
A4 2.0 TFSI - will I be happy coming from a V6?
Author
Discussion

BigMonk

Original Poster:

205 posts

205 months

Sunday 19th December 2010
quotequote all
in the market for a new car, currently have an st220 and fancy a change, however living in mountainous wales theres only so much winter tyres and 2wd can do. i'm starting to think an A4 quattro is the way to go, and no this isn't a knee jerk reaction to the recent snow!

i like the looks, interior and everything else. however there is not one 3.2 V6 A4 B8 for sale and im really begruding moving to a 4 pot.

regardless of power or economy etc, i like the v6 for its sound, balancing, flexibility and refinement. however at the moment it looks like id have to settle for the 210ps 4 pot.

has anyone driven the two? care to share your opinions?

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Sunday 19th December 2010
quotequote all
The 211 PS B8 is superb and better than the V6; slap a map on there and you're laughing.

Better than the V6 at everything except making noise.

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Sunday 19th December 2010
quotequote all
Not quite but I have come from a 3.2 quattro A4 B7 Cabriolet and gone to an A5 2.0T Cab and seriously regret it (not least for the lack of 4wd). The 2.0T is a great engine but its just soulless and sounds like a diesel at the best of times. I cant understand Audi to be honest, the old 3.2 put out 256g of co2 in the B7, they reworked the engine with variable valve timing for the B8 to get it below the 225g threshold and then proceeded to never make any, not even seen a demonstartor up for sale. I've seen one or two 3.2 A5 coupes but thats it. Its a nice engine if its anything like the old B7 one, very tractable and sounds great with the addition of a Milltek.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Monday 20th December 2010
quotequote all
Just being 'below 225' isn't enough for emissions; I never really liked the 3.2 much anyway. 2.0T is a better prospect for a daily drive, not a lot slower and significantly better on fuel. If you want the extra go the S4 is there (which outsold the 3.2 also).

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Monday 20th December 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Just being 'below 225' isn't enough for emissions;
Its keeps you out of the £425 a year band though... The 3.2 just seemed to suit my old A4 cab really well...

Not got any nice quattros in stock have you? Sick of getting stuck at home with my current 2wd A5 cab.

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
I cant understand Audi to be honest, the old 3.2 put out 256g of co2 in the B7, they reworked the engine with variable valve timing for the B8 to get it below the 225g threshold and then proceeded to never make any, not even seen a demonstartor up for sale.
Drove one on training for the B8 model launch in Munich area in Dec 2007.

Rework considered, it's still a dinosaur of an engine, with the smaller capacity forced induction motors giving way more performance but still getting past the emissions test/mpg test. Handling wise I'd far rather have the lighter front end on the car that the 4 cyl gives too.

Audi have dropped the 3.2 from the A3 and TT range as no one bought it.

In my job I've only come across a 3.2 quattro A4 S-line once, and it was worth so little for the age it was laughable. I felt sorry for the people who bought it (from a different dealer i must add!). In other words the UK market doesn't really go for that model engine in the Audi range. We are a bit more "educated" than that and buy the 2.0T, or the TDi cars.

S / RS models aside I think we need to understand Audi very well remember that they must show themselves to be more competitive on emissions across the range to attract customers and still give great performance, while still giving the "brain out" RS models the really nuts engines in low volume production models that don't impact too heavily their total range CO2 average..

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
Dr G said:
Just being 'below 225' isn't enough for emissions;
Its keeps you out of the £425 a year band though... The 3.2 just seemed to suit my old A4 cab really well...

Not got any nice quattros in stock have you? Sick of getting stuck at home with my current 2wd A5 cab.
A5 cabs? Not had any through yet, no. Probably won't until the Spring, lots of money to tie up in something we could well have on stock for 3 months.

Got a couple of 3.0 TDI coupes and we're well stocked on A4 and A6 quattro.

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
There's no replacement for displacement imo. If it's not >225g/km it's not worth buying imo!

BigMonk

Original Poster:

205 posts

205 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
I see there is a difference in opinion. The way I look at it is there are two types of people, those who want lighter, efficentier engines regardless of smoothness or flexibility - and theres those who appreciate the silky drive or a V6 engine, regardless of its paper credintials.

I appreciate the latest 210PS 4 pot may be economical, reliable, tunable and lighter than the V6. But for me an engine with character can make a mudane journey ineresting. In comparison, 4 pot turbos are souless, and yes, they do sound like diesels.

even so, I dont even think the 6 pot is any worse off in the real world economy figures.

I'm trying my best to come over to the 4 pot side of the world, but watching this has just depressed me!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgxRci_zOaw

i think ill wait till the new year and see if any 3.2's crop up.

baz1985

3,685 posts

276 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
^^^^ Way to go...

If you thrash the na 3.2 and the 2.0T FSI- there'll be little difference in fuel economy- and you won't be looking for a new DMF as often.

drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
BigMonk said:
I see there is a difference in opinion. The way I look at it is there are two types of people, those who want lighter, efficentier engines regardless of smoothness or flexibility - and theres those who appreciate the silky drive or a V6 engine, regardless of its paper credintials.

I appreciate the latest 210PS 4 pot may be economical, reliable, tunable and lighter than the V6. But for me an engine with character can make a mudane journey ineresting. In comparison, 4 pot turbos are souless, and yes, they do sound like diesels.

even so, I dont even think the 6 pot is any worse off in the real world economy figures.

I'm trying my best to come over to the 4 pot side of the world, but watching this has just depressed me!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgxRci_zOaw

i think ill wait till the new year and see if any 3.2's crop up.
0 - 60 in 7-8 secs? Please read on...

This is an odd spec car... If it's a B8 2.0TFSi then in the UK we only have sold SE and above specs. SE and above ALL have a full colour DIS... This car must surely be an odd spec to still be running a red/black DIS with an MPH graded speedo...)

So I think it's a 1.8T Multitronic

It doesn't look like he launched it very well... and I believe due to my piece of detective work above this car is NOT a 2.0T quattro, but instead I think it's a 1.8T FWD Multitronic, hence the low performance and odd power delivery.

Even if it was a 2.0T to get CO2 of only 175g/km (£250 to tax in year one, and £180 per year thereafter) and 37.7 combined this is well worth sticking to the 2.0T over the 3.2 equivalent new B8 quattro which has to make do with the old sluggish tiptronic, with 215g/km CO2 (£550 to road tax in year 1 and £245 thereafter).

Just to compare the performance: the 2.0T does 0 - 62 in 6.5 secs, 3.2 is 6.4secs. So nothing in it. However the 2.0T is 211ps, compared to the 3.2 at 265ps!

Just to compare prices: The 2.0T quattro is £3620 less expensive than the 3.2 quattro at the time of writing! £3600!!

This tells me the 2.0T is far more performance per £ spent.

Getting back on topic, bottom line is the 2.0T is newer and better tech.

otolith

69,815 posts

235 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
In other words the UK market doesn't really go for that model engine in the Audi range. We are a bit more "educated" than that and buy the 2.0T, or the TDi cars.
For "educated", read "coerced by taxation".

BigMonk

Original Poster:

205 posts

205 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
BigMonk said:
I see there is a difference in opinion. The way I look at it is there are two types of people, those who want lighter, efficentier engines regardless of smoothness or flexibility - and theres those who appreciate the silky drive or a V6 engine, regardless of its paper credintials.

I appreciate the latest 210PS 4 pot may be economical, reliable, tunable and lighter than the V6. But for me an engine with character can make a mudane journey ineresting. In comparison, 4 pot turbos are souless, and yes, they do sound like diesels.

even so, I dont even think the 6 pot is any worse off in the real world economy figures.

I'm trying my best to come over to the 4 pot side of the world, but watching this has just depressed me!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgxRci_zOaw

i think ill wait till the new year and see if any 3.2's crop up.
0 - 60 in 7-8 secs? Please read on...

This is an odd spec car... If it's a B8 2.0TFSi then in the UK we only have sold SE and above specs. SE and above ALL have a full colour DIS... This car must surely be an odd spec to still be running a red/black DIS with an MPH graded speedo...)

So I think it's a 1.8T Multitronic

It doesn't look like he launched it very well... and I believe due to my piece of detective work above this car is NOT a 2.0T quattro, but instead I think it's a 1.8T FWD Multitronic, hence the low performance and odd power delivery.

Even if it was a 2.0T to get CO2 of only 175g/km (£250 to tax in year one, and £180 per year thereafter) and 37.7 combined this is well worth sticking to the 2.0T over the 3.2 equivalent new B8 quattro which has to make do with the old sluggish tiptronic, with 215g/km CO2 (£550 to road tax in year 1 and £245 thereafter).

Just to compare the performance: the 2.0T does 0 - 62 in 6.5 secs, 3.2 is 6.4secs. So nothing in it. However the 2.0T is 211ps, compared to the 3.2 at 265ps!

Just to compare prices: The 2.0T quattro is £3620 less expensive than the 3.2 quattro at the time of writing! £3600!!

This tells me the 2.0T is far more performance per £ spent.

Getting back on topic, bottom line is the 2.0T is newer and better tech.
I do not doubt your post on the identification of the car, however regardless of its cubic capacity, it seemed strangled, souless and struggled to rev. I cant see the 2.0 being any better if its effectively the same engine.

fuel consumption is of no consideration to me, nor is tax, all my cars are "bad on juice" but you get what you pay for imo.

i do not believe the performance figures audi quote, if you compare them across the engine range they do not add up. with the 3.0 diesel being the fastest to 60. call me cynical, but thats my honest opinion.


drybeer

962 posts

256 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
Not same engine.

The 2.0T has valvelift, and is not souless.

Ultimately you need to drive one. However if you can't keep your mind open to how good an engine it is then you'll do yourself no favours.

Have you compared how close 3.2 models are in price to S4s? I'm sure there would be no argument that the S4 would be the better choice at that price range.

BigMonk

Original Poster:

205 posts

205 months

Tuesday 21st December 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
Not same engine.

The 2.0T has valvelift, and is not souless.

Ultimately you need to drive one. However if you can't keep your mind open to how good an engine it is then you'll do yourself no favours.

Have you compared how close 3.2 models are in price to S4s? I'm sure there would be no argument that the S4 would be the better choice at that price range.
I think I will go drive a 2.0TFSI Quattro.

I havent seen any 3.2's for sale so cant compare them to a S4, but the S4's are going for money I'd rather not part with.

Now, whats the chances me finding an A4 with a sports differential??

Gren

2,030 posts

283 months

Wednesday 22nd December 2010
quotequote all
drybeer said:
Not same engine.

The 2.0T has valvelift, and is not souless.
If its the old 1.8T then the 2.0T has miles more character. Having just gone from a 225 bhp 1.8T to a 270bhp 2.0T there's a huge difference in the flexibility as well as the sound even though still a 4 pot. If its the newer 1.8T (fitted to A3s, dunno about the A4s)then thats just an awful gutless engine.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Wednesday 22nd December 2010
quotequote all
I'm also struggling to identify the car in the video laugh

The ESP light flashing suggests it's a Multitronic, quattro cars will take full beans and just go even in the wet confused

1.8 TFSI 120 needs more poke but the 160 is alright (still not a patch on a 211 2.0T).

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 22nd December 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
The 211 PS B8 is... better than the V6 at everything except making noise.
^^ yes

drybeer said:
This tells me the 2.0T is far more performance per £ spent... Getting back on topic, bottom line is the 2.0T is newer and better tech.
^^ I can't comment on the older 1.8T, but the 2.0T is a crackin' engine, even more so in the updated 210PS tune and I would agree with both of these sentiments.

It just simply can't compete for aural pleasure/character against the 3.2 - it's simply glorious. Why do you think R32 owners just live their lives in tunnels...? wink

I have ran a 2.0T for just over two years, so I will share my observations:-

a) The FSI direct injection makes a horrible diesel-like rattle at idle. Not a good look in a car with 'sporty' pretensions,
b) The waves of low-rev torque makes it a very flexible engine, plus there is the occasional over-run pop and growl at low-revs to raise a smile, so it's not totally devoid of character...
c) It is waaay more tuneable £ for £ compared to the 3.2.. it is a turbo, after all.
d) For some, 3-4 less mpg and an extra ~17quid in VED each month is worth it to hear that VR6... Come next year, I'll be one of them.
e) A 2.0T Quattro with a simple remap & Miltek will tune to ~265hp, which is a nice solution, compared to the 3.2...

otolith said:
For "educated", read "coerced by taxation".
^^ yes

Edited by FamilyDub on Wednesday 22 December 12:06