Audi S3 facelift queries...
Discussion
Hi
Apologies for the considerable blurb, but please be patient and read below!
My current black 3 dr A3 2.0 petrol sport FSI is about to traded in next month (due to work). Its old (53 plate), done some 83,000 miles, 4 owners, umpteen faults with it and has enough war scars to prove it!
Therefore I have been looking/researching long and hard to what my new motor would be: VW GTI, VW R32, Audi 2.0 turbo, Audi S3. I have now test driven all of them and it comes as no surprise to read the R32 put the biggest grin on my face with that growling V6 orchestra to enjoy! However the road tax and insurance quotes soon removed it (my car will be insured in London - £1,500 pa, ouch!) Therefore I looked at the S3 - very similar performance (4WD, 18" rims, xenons as standard, 265 ps, 0-6mph in approx 6 sec etc). Oh and my budget needs to be under £20,000.
Having owned an Audi (and actually several Golfs before) I can honestly definitely feel the difference and quality in the Audi. It is a lovely cabin to be in. Therefore I have decided to look at getting a 2-3 yr old S3 with under 30,000 miles in black or in dark grey. Ideally I want the 'face lifted' model - which came out post Sept 2008. The main reason is this includes the eye turning day time running lights! However sorry to ramble but here is my question - the cup holder has been forgotten about?! I test drove a 60 plate £30,000 S3 2 days ago and guess what - no cup holders!!!! There was one actually but it was underneath the arm rest - come on Audi! In the older S3 (pre 2008) the cup holder is below the Sat Nav.
My question is this:
Is it worth getting the new face lifted model just for the DRL? I prefer the older S3 wheels and the layout inside (buttons below the DVD Sat Nav device). The S3 I want must have the DVD Sat Nav and the multi function steering wheel! These two extra's are key I think! Sunroof is a nice bonus!
I feel the R32 will just be too expensive to run/insure etc and the S3 is a nicer car overall and is a little cheaper to run. The only thing the S3 lacks is the noise, but I guess Miltek could change that with a remap?
If anyone can help me on advising me above on these points I would be really grateful.
Thank you in advance.
Henry
Apologies for the considerable blurb, but please be patient and read below!
My current black 3 dr A3 2.0 petrol sport FSI is about to traded in next month (due to work). Its old (53 plate), done some 83,000 miles, 4 owners, umpteen faults with it and has enough war scars to prove it!
Therefore I have been looking/researching long and hard to what my new motor would be: VW GTI, VW R32, Audi 2.0 turbo, Audi S3. I have now test driven all of them and it comes as no surprise to read the R32 put the biggest grin on my face with that growling V6 orchestra to enjoy! However the road tax and insurance quotes soon removed it (my car will be insured in London - £1,500 pa, ouch!) Therefore I looked at the S3 - very similar performance (4WD, 18" rims, xenons as standard, 265 ps, 0-6mph in approx 6 sec etc). Oh and my budget needs to be under £20,000.
Having owned an Audi (and actually several Golfs before) I can honestly definitely feel the difference and quality in the Audi. It is a lovely cabin to be in. Therefore I have decided to look at getting a 2-3 yr old S3 with under 30,000 miles in black or in dark grey. Ideally I want the 'face lifted' model - which came out post Sept 2008. The main reason is this includes the eye turning day time running lights! However sorry to ramble but here is my question - the cup holder has been forgotten about?! I test drove a 60 plate £30,000 S3 2 days ago and guess what - no cup holders!!!! There was one actually but it was underneath the arm rest - come on Audi! In the older S3 (pre 2008) the cup holder is below the Sat Nav.
My question is this:
Is it worth getting the new face lifted model just for the DRL? I prefer the older S3 wheels and the layout inside (buttons below the DVD Sat Nav device). The S3 I want must have the DVD Sat Nav and the multi function steering wheel! These two extra's are key I think! Sunroof is a nice bonus!
I feel the R32 will just be too expensive to run/insure etc and the S3 is a nicer car overall and is a little cheaper to run. The only thing the S3 lacks is the noise, but I guess Miltek could change that with a remap?
If anyone can help me on advising me above on these points I would be really grateful.
Thank you in advance.
Henry
I would get the R32 just because we won't see a 3.2 V6 in a hatchback again but then again I'm biased.
The S3 is a lvely car although I wouldn't rule out a pre-facelift one just because it doesn't have DRLs. If it were me I would have a look around and get the best one you can get for your budget whether it be facelifted or not.
The S3 is a lvely car although I wouldn't rule out a pre-facelift one just because it doesn't have DRLs. If it were me I would have a look around and get the best one you can get for your budget whether it be facelifted or not.
Yes, I did consider the S3 when I was deciding but I already had a 4 pot Turbo and I loved the smothness and linear power delivery of the V6 .
Personally I also preferred the look of the R32 and I think it may have been cheaper but maybe not as my R32 is specced up with Recaro buckets
I ordered my car towards the end of 2005 before road tax took a big. IIRC it was £190 when I ordered but is now £425. This along with the mid 20s fuel economy is the downside of the R32.
Personally I also preferred the look of the R32 and I think it may have been cheaper but maybe not as my R32 is specced up with Recaro buckets
I ordered my car towards the end of 2005 before road tax took a big. IIRC it was £190 when I ordered but is now £425. This along with the mid 20s fuel economy is the downside of the R32.
Hi
Ok well 300 miles to a tank is not too bad I guess. It must be very hard to avoid putting your foot down though!
The tempting thing with the R32 is it is slightly cheaper than the S3. I do want a good spec though in a R32 - full leather, Nav, multi function wheel, low mileage ideally under 30,000 miles. My current Audi has had SO many problems with it, hence why I would rather have a lower mileage to avoid this happening again!
Ok well 300 miles to a tank is not too bad I guess. It must be very hard to avoid putting your foot down though!
The tempting thing with the R32 is it is slightly cheaper than the S3. I do want a good spec though in a R32 - full leather, Nav, multi function wheel, low mileage ideally under 30,000 miles. My current Audi has had SO many problems with it, hence why I would rather have a lower mileage to avoid this happening again!
I agree with you going for S3 over R32 - for me the V6 doesn't have the grunt to match the growl; the novelty of the noise wears of and the nagging doubt that it needs more performance sinks in. It's expensive to get from the 3.2 also. The A3 3.2 whilst mechanically near identical I thought was a better car as it's a proper wolf in sheeps clothing, not available post-facelift sadly.
I don't like the front end styling on the A3/S3; I think the headlights look aftermarket but the dash is much improved from what was starting to look quite dated in the older car, it hadn't changed much from 2003.
The cupholder is deleted on any cars with the double din head unit (Concert II, Symphony or RNS-E Nav).
If you're out hunting in an ideal world you want nav, upgraded leather (the standard perforated vinyl alike stuff is gross) and Bose. Everything else is a bonus but if you're being fussy any of the option wheels are nicer looking than the standard items.
I don't like the front end styling on the A3/S3; I think the headlights look aftermarket but the dash is much improved from what was starting to look quite dated in the older car, it hadn't changed much from 2003.
The cupholder is deleted on any cars with the double din head unit (Concert II, Symphony or RNS-E Nav).
If you're out hunting in an ideal world you want nav, upgraded leather (the standard perforated vinyl alike stuff is gross) and Bose. Everything else is a bonus but if you're being fussy any of the option wheels are nicer looking than the standard items.
ugene425 said:
...VW GTI, VW R32, Audi 2.0 T, Audi S3...
^^ I don't think paying a £5k+ premium for an S3 over another VAG 2.0T is actually worth it. I looked at swapping my GTI for an S3, it it was almost double the cost for pretty much the same car.Ok, the S3 has more power and 4WD, but it doesn't really feel 'special' enough to justify the extra cost, whereas when I looked at an R32 it did feel special, especially the MKIV. The MKV is a far more subtle affair than the MKIV version.
If you can get your head round the lower mpg and higher VED on the R32, i'd go for that, PLUS R32 registered before 23/03/2006 will be the 'older' VED scheme and be £235, not the later £435.
A MKV GTI Edition 30, with a remap will give ~265-275hp and probably be quicker than an R32... nice compromise?
ugene425 said:
R32 is basically double in road tax to the S3.
^^ I've already answered thatugene425 said:
R32 is more expensive to insure than the S3
^^ For me the S3 was about £175 cheaper than an R32, but would I be happy to pay an extra £15 per month to have that noise in my life - yes.ugene425 said:
R32 is more thirsty than the S3
^^
No arguments there! ugene425 said:
S3 is quicker!
^^ Sometimes the 0-62, 1/4 mile, etc is a poor judgement for a car. Who actually cares? ugene425 said:
The R32 does sound better
^^ 2.0T sounds okay, but really it is no R32...Edited by FamilyDub on Monday 10th January 19:22
Guys - LOVING all your opinions, thank you and please keep them coming!
Hmmm well sadly I think there are too many VW Golfs on the rd! I think the Edition 30 would be an excellent runner, but then again it is just a golf! I am not 23 any more/or studying at Uni and would quite like the S3 (smart, lovely inside, quick, subtle) or the R32 (awsome power/noise, not quite as nice inside as the S3, VERY thirsty to run/insure - and yes its still a golf!).
I know what you mean that the R32 was a 'special' car to drive as that V6 is awesome. I completely agree. Its a different feeling when you step inside the S3 cabin. More grown up, performance extremely similar to R32, just missing the noise. However like I mentioned one would get use to the grunt of the R32 and then perhaps not really notice it... The S3 interior IS a nicer space (BOSE speakers are awesome) to be in I think! One must get the flat bottomed steering wheel, full leather and DVD Nav otherwise it would look identical to my current Audi (2.0 FSI)!!!
Sat Nav on both cars are average, my 2 yr old Tom Tom does a better job and one can enter a full postcode. On both R32 & S3 one can only enter 6 digits for postcode. I blame the Germans on that one!
Its a good point with the R32 to look for one pre 03/2006 but i want a low mileage (under 30,000 miles) with all the trimmings.
I have already owned 2 Golfs and one Audi. I think getting another Audi (bigger engine and better looking overall) is a step forward. Getting another golf might be a step backwards...
Hmmm well sadly I think there are too many VW Golfs on the rd! I think the Edition 30 would be an excellent runner, but then again it is just a golf! I am not 23 any more/or studying at Uni and would quite like the S3 (smart, lovely inside, quick, subtle) or the R32 (awsome power/noise, not quite as nice inside as the S3, VERY thirsty to run/insure - and yes its still a golf!).
I know what you mean that the R32 was a 'special' car to drive as that V6 is awesome. I completely agree. Its a different feeling when you step inside the S3 cabin. More grown up, performance extremely similar to R32, just missing the noise. However like I mentioned one would get use to the grunt of the R32 and then perhaps not really notice it... The S3 interior IS a nicer space (BOSE speakers are awesome) to be in I think! One must get the flat bottomed steering wheel, full leather and DVD Nav otherwise it would look identical to my current Audi (2.0 FSI)!!!
Sat Nav on both cars are average, my 2 yr old Tom Tom does a better job and one can enter a full postcode. On both R32 & S3 one can only enter 6 digits for postcode. I blame the Germans on that one!
Its a good point with the R32 to look for one pre 03/2006 but i want a low mileage (under 30,000 miles) with all the trimmings.
I have already owned 2 Golfs and one Audi. I think getting another Audi (bigger engine and better looking overall) is a step forward. Getting another golf might be a step backwards...
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



