Seat Leon FR TDi 170 or VW Golf GT TDi 170??
Seat Leon FR TDi 170 or VW Golf GT TDi 170??
Author
Discussion

Lippyx

Original Poster:

52 posts

190 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Hi all!!

I am new, so HELLO! biggrin

I have just sold my Scooby, and now on the market for something different (and more wallet friendly!!)
I am quite interested in the Seat Leon and VW Golf, but wondered if anyone can help me decide?

I have viewed a Leon (although not driven one yet) and I loved what you get, such as iPod connection, multi func. steering wheel etc, plus the sporty seats and looks. I have not viewed a Golf yet, but from the adverts I've seen, I'll be lucky if I find one with leather, and the ones I've seen don't look as sporty as the Leon.

I know they are pretty much the same car, but wondered what you would choose and why? Also any common faults either suffer with? I know all car's have their bad points, but its all about how much they cost to fix!!

Thanks for your help peeps!!

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
The older PD 170 engine needs to be used on long trips regularly, they are unsuitable for town driving or short trips.

Not a fan of the Leon styling personally, dashboard looks cheap too. Damn sight cheaper than the equivalent Golf, however.

cuprabob

19,972 posts

245 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Even although I'm a fan of Seats and have owned many in the past I would say go for the Golf. IMO the interior of the Leon is poor compared o the Golf.

They both suffer from the same issues such as DPF problems if used pottering about the town plus the piezo injectors seem to fail and are very expensive to fix, so warranty is key.

adycav

7,615 posts

248 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Skoda Octavia vRS with the same engine.

Nicer looking than both and better value imo.

Lippyx

Original Poster:

52 posts

190 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Cuprabob - You mention the DPF and Piezo Injectors. Having never owning a diesel before, I am a little unsure what this means costs wise to repair?
Are most diesel cars prone to these issues?

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
adycav said:
Skoda Octavia vRS with the same engine.
^^ yes then the VW over the SEAT.

cuprabob

19,972 posts

245 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Lippyx said:
Cuprabob - You mention the DPF and Piezo Injectors. Having never owning a diesel before, I am a little unsure what this means costs wise to repair?
Are most diesel cars prone to these issues?
As I understand it DPF issues are pretty common on cars that are used about town and do't get regular long runs. I don't think it's just a VAG issue but I've read a lot of VAG owners having issues. There are exclusions in the warranty for DPF and can cost circa £1,500 for a new one.

With regards to the injectors, on the 170bhp engine they use a specific piezi technology that's not used on the 140bhp and I've heard of them failing regularly and at a cost of circa. £400 each, and there is 4 of them, you can see why I say warranty is important. Good news is that after 3yrs/60k miles the vw warranty can be extended at a "reasonable cost"

Go over onto seatcupra.net and have a look around as there are a lot of Leon FR owners on there who can give ou more info.

If you frequent any car forum you won't buy any car because normally all you read about are the problems.



Edited by cuprabob on Tuesday 11th January 14:35

Lippyx

Original Poster:

52 posts

190 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Cuprabob - Yes I know what you mean! After being part of a Scooby forum for almost 5 years, all you would read about is blown engines, worn out turbos etc!!

I have gone on to the Seat forum you suggested, and alot of them say the same regarding the diesel versions etc. Not sure if I should go for the petrol now??

DickSkruttock

4,553 posts

199 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Lippyx said:
Cuprabob - Yes I know what you mean! After being part of a Scooby forum for almost 5 years, all you would read about is blown engines, worn out turbos etc!!

I have gone on to the Seat forum you suggested, and alot of them say the same regarding the diesel versions etc. Not sure if I should go for the petrol now??
2.0T with a remap = 250BHP ish

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Main issue with that engine will be the DPF

I'd personally choose the Golf, the pre-2008 Leon interiors feel a bit cheap and plasticy compared to the Golf

Octavia VRS a good shout, probably worth considering if your looking at the Golf and Leon

Audi A3 also very good if any within budget, but you do pay a premium for the badge.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Tuesday 11th January 2011
quotequote all
Lippyx said:
Not sure if I should go for the petrol now??
Try the Golf GT TSI if you'd consider a petrol. Same 170bhp as the diesel, but it gets it from a turbocharged & supercharged 1.4 unit. Bit cheaper to buy than the diesel alternative and still reasonably good on fuel.