Discussion
I've been looking for a new motor for a few weeks and being very indecisive. I've never owned an Audi or a BMW before and within my budget (£3.5k) there's plenty of decent (and not so decent) 5 series and A6s around mostly around 8-12+ years old. I'd been set on a E39 but there's a fair number of A6s out there too and seem like a decent bargain for what I need (only 10k miles a year max, quiet, comfy, decent waft factor, decent boot, Autobahn-proof). Have ruled out E-classes of that age since they're either too pricey or full of rust.
The E39 looks ideal on paper but the A6 also seems quite impressive. The only thing that terrifies me are the horror stories of the A6 auto gearbox. I'm trying to convince myself it shouldn't matter but I can't shake off the idea that I should ditch the A6 and just stick to looking at E39s. That said the A6s seem less prone to rust than the E39s.
Someone convince me why an A6 would be a better move!
The E39 looks ideal on paper but the A6 also seems quite impressive. The only thing that terrifies me are the horror stories of the A6 auto gearbox. I'm trying to convince myself it shouldn't matter but I can't shake off the idea that I should ditch the A6 and just stick to looking at E39s. That said the A6s seem less prone to rust than the E39s.
Someone convince me why an A6 would be a better move!
There is a lot of bad press about the multitronic boxes but in 117K miles I have never had a problem. As said above though the Quattro has the tiptronic box which has less issues.
Avoid the 2.5 TDi for the reasons above, the 130 1.9 Tdi is pretty good and doesn't have the same problems. The petrol V6 engines are good, although check them for oil leaks. There are a few common places they leak from, none of which are that expensive but use it to get money off.
The A6 should not have any rust on it at that age, run a mile from any that does.
The other thing to check is the suspension, the A6 has multi link suspension and the bushes are prone to wear. You will notice either squeeking or knocking over bumps. The parts aren't too expensive.
Avoid the 2.5 TDi for the reasons above, the 130 1.9 Tdi is pretty good and doesn't have the same problems. The petrol V6 engines are good, although check them for oil leaks. There are a few common places they leak from, none of which are that expensive but use it to get money off.
The A6 should not have any rust on it at that age, run a mile from any that does.
The other thing to check is the suspension, the A6 has multi link suspension and the bushes are prone to wear. You will notice either squeeking or knocking over bumps. The parts aren't too expensive.
BDZ said:
Someone convince me why an A6 would be a better move!
At £3500 its just isnt really.You could get a really nice, much newer volume brand car for that money, you have to get a much older potentially more troublesome example if you want an Audi or BMW.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2011...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2010...
just a few example, all very different. Do try an Omega if you like the way the E39 drives, it has the same steering system and if you get the 2.5 TD the same engine as that vintage BMW, just without the price tag.
That said if you really want an Audi the VAG 1.9tdi is a very robust engine, manual gearboxs go forever, tiptronics good for upto 120,000 miles many go on longer, but we do see one or two failures arround that milage so be aware if it needs a new box, it cost more that the car.
All the common A6/A4 faults are well documented on here, so faults can be identified quite simply.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


