Another What Car thread.
Author
Discussion

F i F

Original Poster:

49,061 posts

282 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
So it is what is called new "management car" time, as opposed to proper working vehicle time.

Need this like a hole in the head frankly, rather have the money but not an option in our outfit. frown

I don't want a car,
but you're entitled to one,
but I don't want one,
suit yourself then but you don't get the money,
but I'll even take less than the lease cost,
nope not even a quid,
gimme the censored car then.

I digress.

So I'm posting this in here rather than GG because want to eliminate all the usual you'd be better off with an MX5 malarkey when I'm after a diesel estate wafter. Please Note!!

Volvo, which have been pretty good to me over a lot of years are being elbowed for a whole host of reasons. V70 too expensive, V60 just rubbish apart from chassis, V50 getting too small for my needs, but apart from this V50 D3 Geartronic still a very strong contender to be honest.

So having got rid of the Ford, Audi, Beemer and Volvo options, we end up with

Octavia Kombi 2.0Tdi L&K DSG (with possibility/budget to add quite a few options, suggestions on that?)
Superb Kombi Elegance DSG 2.0Tdi (not much needed to be added but some possibilities / allowances)
Passat Estate 2.0 TDi DSG Bluemotion Technology Sport


Listed above in order of preference, though first two are probably equal first tbh, Passat currently in very poor third place.

So waddya fink?

I have no issue with badge, even own a Skoda as family car. VRs alternative on the Octavia? As said need it for wafting, have other stuff for play, and get enough charging about at warp 9 elsewhere.

Anything outside that list, however valid or intersting, eg Subaru Legacy can't be considered unfortunately.

So over to them that know and aren't so indecisive. hehe

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Superb wagon IMO, fabulous car, and so much class in wagon form, unlike the notch.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Balmoral Green said:
Superb wagon IMO, fabulous car, and so much class in wagon form, unlike the notch.
This but without the added Yeehah wink

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
I concur,

Superb Wagon, then Octavia then Passat out of your three.

The lead times on new Skodas is very long though isn`t it? I think factory orders for some of their stuff is in excess of six months, have you got the ability to wait that long?

I`ve only seen pictures of the new Passat so far but it certainly looks bland to my eyes.

I saw a V60 on the M27 the other day, I thought it looked very very nice indeed.

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Come on, just look at it. Old money or what?


Chris_VRS

2,475 posts

224 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Another vote for the Superb Estate here.

Basically what a fabulous all rounder!

Agree with the other poster regarding the new passat looking bland *yawn*

john_r

8,354 posts

302 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Went to look at a Superb estate a few weeks ago - fabulous car, loads of kit and looks great. AND it was very good to drive too!

F i F

Original Poster:

49,061 posts

282 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Gentlemen, I think you can safely say that your work in here is done. Thank you.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 21st January 2011
quotequote all
Superb is a good call, but I wouldn't discount the Passat.

The new model has literally just come out, so you would be driving the very very latest, and the 2.0 TDI 140 Bluemotion Technologies offers better MPG than the Superb and 119g/ km CO2 which means cheap tax.

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Saturday 22nd January 2011
quotequote all
My Polo was at Heritage VW in Salisbury today for a service (they were only £1.85 more expensive than the independent guy on the same trading estate for a 10,000 mile service.....) so I had look round the new Passat in the showroom.

It`s just a re-skin isn`t it? The dashboard and seats all look exactly like the old one. Some of the figures quoted on the adjacent information board were impressive but it`s no ground-breaker.

I`d certainly pick a Superb over a Passat to be honest.

Off Topic here. I also had a look round a Tiguan they had in the showroom. Very nice but it was over £30,000!

F i F

Original Poster:

49,061 posts

282 months

Saturday 22nd January 2011
quotequote all
For me the accusation of the Passat being bland doesn't really matter, in my trade bland = anonymous = thumbup

It's also true that VW deliberately hold back technology from Skoda, for example they don't get access to the latest engines, but at least the engines are all CR now and not a mixture of CR and PD.

But with the new Passat VW are playing catch up with such as Volvo in some of the nanny safety electronics, and it's this stuff in particular which spoilt the car and the V60 for me.

Plus there are a number of minor things on the Passat which I really don't like and don't want on the car, but not possible to despecify aiui, and a number of things missing that would need to be added whereas standard on Skoda.