Weird (& unwanted) pops and bangs from the engine
Weird (& unwanted) pops and bangs from the engine
Author
Discussion

Yellow Griff

Original Poster:

75 posts

313 months

Saturday 3rd September 2005
quotequote all
Hi folks,

as the topic says I'm getting some weird pops and bangs that sound to be coming from the engine/exhaust/manifolds on my 97 Griff.

It only occurs under hard acceleration with the engine under load, e.g. 3rd gear overtakes once you reach about 4000 rpm. I then get fairly loud bangs every 1/2 sec or so until I change gear and the revs drop. Happens all the time so can be easily repeated.

Doesn't occur under "normal" acceleration and doesn't occur in the drive or on a ramp.

Have taken it to a local specialist who are now scratching their heads. They say it doesn't sound terminal (they're confident its safe to drive) and it doesn't sound like a normal misfire, pinking or detonation problem. We put it on a rolling road so we could re-create the problem with the car static and are still none the wiser. They've throughly checked over the car and are confident that nothing is loose or broken externally.

Its going back in again after BNG for a couple of days so they can have a good look and fiddle with a few things. Any pointers?

Thanks,

Simon

stesrg

1,578 posts

267 months

Saturday 3rd September 2005
quotequote all
Yellow Griff said:
Hi folks,

as the topic says I'm getting some weird pops and bangs that sound to be coming from the engine/exhaust/manifolds on my 97 Griff.

It only occurs under hard acceleration with the engine under load, e.g. 3rd gear overtakes once you reach about 4000 rpm. I then get fairly loud bangs every 1/2 sec or so until I change gear and the revs drop. Happens all the time so can be easily repeated.

Doesn't occur under "normal" acceleration and doesn't occur in the drive or on a ramp.



Have taken it to a local specialist who are now scratching their heads. They say it doesn't sound terminal (they're confident its safe to drive) and it doesn't sound like a normal misfire, pinking or detonation problem. We put it on a rolling road so we could re-create the problem with the car static and are still none the wiser. They've throughly checked over the car and are confident that nothing is loose or broken externally.

Its going back in again after BNG for a couple of days so they can have a good look and fiddle with a few things. Any pointers?

Thanks,

Simon

Hmm I was getting pops and bangs and nice flames comming out the back of the exhausts, was a knakered manifold sucking in a little air to aid combustion was good though
Ste.. edited because twas wrong doh..

>> Edited by stesrg on Saturday 3rd September 21:38

schueymcfee

1,577 posts

294 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
I had similar when I had my vacuum advance pipe connected. Disconnected it and all was fine.

daxtojeiro

743 posts

275 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
could be a weak spark, poor plugs / plug or coil. it could even be a poorly set plug gap, but sounds as if its not buring the fuel totally in the cylinder and when it opens the exhaust valve its letting unburnt fuel out, this hits the hot exhaust and goes POP,
Phil

Hughesie2

12,790 posts

311 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
Just enjoy them, i've spent a fortune recently getting mine to pop and bang

v8 racing

2,064 posts

280 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
rotor arm!!

Yellow Griff

Original Poster:

75 posts

313 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
Thanks for the ideas so far - will pass them on and see what happens.

We were going to check all the electrical side of things, but everything got a bit too warm to play with on Saturday having been on the rollers. I was thinking of changing plug leads, etc in the near future anyway - just wasn't sure which order to do things in for best effect (plug leads, induction hose, tornado chip ...)

I'll also get them to check the manifolds again. We had a look over them on the ramp and there was no obvious sign of anything wrong - could be the gaskets giving way?

I'm quite happy to have some pops and bangs - have already had the exhaust modified - just want to know that they are happening for the right reasons

Simon

seasider

12,728 posts

278 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
v8 racing said:
What happened Saturday? Was hoping to see you...

GreenV8S

31,017 posts

313 months

Monday 5th September 2005
quotequote all
The two obvious candidates are a misfire, and an air leak in the exhaust (sucking in air and allowing excess fuel to ignite). A leak in the exhaust would have more effect at light throttle especally on a trailing throttle and doesn't fit these symptoms. Sounds to me more like you have a misfire at high revs/full throttle. This is the sort of thing a weak spark could cause so a check of the ignition system would be in order.

SteveGRF

259 posts

276 months

Thursday 8th September 2005
quotequote all
Yellow

This happened to a Chevy Engine I used to run, turned out to be a droped cam follower. Worth removing the rockers just to have a quick check for damaged followers etc.

Steve

Yellow Griff

Original Poster:

75 posts

313 months

Friday 9th September 2005
quotequote all
Thanks all,

off to BNG now and then take it in to be checked on Wednesday.

Simon

Yellow Griff

Original Poster:

75 posts

313 months

Wednesday 21st September 2005
quotequote all
OK All,

here's an update on the problem.

Firstly one of the exhaust manifold gaskets was just starting to blow - not massively but enough to let some air in.

Secondly the distributor cap and rotor arm were just showing signs of wear and starting to break down.

Individually not a problem but collectively certainly not helping. After fixing those the popping and banging was still there, but now with a different note/tone.

Further investigation suggests that there is a problem with the inlet valve on no.4 cylinder. They reckon its not too major and is probably just sticking, but until the head comes off we won't know for sure. [Need a "fingers crossed" smiley]

Anyway, whilst the heads are off is there anything else I ought to get checked out and/or upgraded?

Thanks,

Simon

red griff 500

280 posts

271 months

Thursday 22nd September 2005
quotequote all
Hey stevegrf, how do you check cam followers by removing rockers?

SteveGRF

259 posts

276 months

Friday 23rd September 2005
quotequote all
Oops

I meant remove the rocker covers & visual check the rockers for signs of damage, excessive wear etc

Steve