Ongoing electrical gremlin (53 plate defender) - HELP
Ongoing electrical gremlin (53 plate defender) - HELP
Author
Discussion

tomw2000

Original Poster:

2,508 posts

219 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Hey all, possibly going over old ground (as I've mentioned before) - but I have an ongoing electrical gremlin with my TD5 53 plate 90.

First problem: sometimes and it doesn't matter if the whether is hot or cold, wet or dry (or engine hot or cold), I try and start the vehicle, I turn the key - and (for whatever reason) the orange engine light and squiggly coil light do not come on - and when this happens the car won't start. It does turn over.
I return the key to normal position and wait a few secs and then it's always started fine. Maybe takes a couple of goes. But as soon as the orange engine managment and squiggly coil lights come on she starts fine.

This happened this morning. But got the car going and off I pootled to Grantham station. BUT: less than a mile from home there's an exposed lane (yes, that lane - where I flipped the car over last Dec...) which gets frost/ice/black ice on it...so i crawl along there....car running fine. I get to the end of the lane...and pull onto the A52...this road gets gritted, so I get my foot down and the car cuts out. All the dash lights light up. I am fairly sure (maybe imagined it) that the Traction Control light came on first (which I'd not seen happen before)...so I eventually get the car re-started after a few attempts and limp onto the verge.

I wonder if wet/damp does cause an issue? I do have the 'they all do that' leak of water into the driver side footwell. And wondered if that might affect electrics?

Car is being recovered -my local wrench. Good guy. But not Defender specialist. And am sure they'll plug her in and look for faults. And I'll update the thread. I know the info above is vague but anyone got any ideas?

In October the car had ace service at JE Engineering (I have stage 1 and 2 remap of theirs and a few other bits) and had been driving brilliantly, like a new car since. She'd not demonstrated this problem for an age before she went in so I didn't mentioned it to them. I just need her working reliably.
Or will the only 'fix' be to get a newer one? frown

bogtrotter

160 posts

241 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Hi there...had a similar prob with a td 5 ..have you checked the mult pin plug where it connects with the ecu ? oil can migrate from the loom inside the engine and down as far as the ecu causing all sorts of problems...if this has happened you will see traces of oil inside the plug..a good clean usually sorts it out..if not I don't think a replacement loom section is too expensive..best of luck Steve w.

tomw2000

Original Poster:

2,508 posts

219 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Thanks BoggyT smile.

I have just spoken to my wrench and he'd thought of oil ingress issue and checked. All good in there oil-wise currently.

But did say they'd noticed, when she didn't start, with the lights acting as I described above - they also saw the temp guage shoots up. So quick call to his mate and they now think it's the 'ignition relay'. £30 part. so worth a try. It arrives tomorrow.

I'll update when I have more news.

I hope it cures her. I just want her working reliably. frown

cpas

1,661 posts

264 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Probably something really simple but it's just finding it. Ignition relay sounds most promising, or a dirty connection somewhere or poor connection to earth.

tomw2000

Original Poster:

2,508 posts

219 months

Monday 12th December 2011
quotequote all
Yeah, thanks. Hopefully smile

The guys on defenders2.net (I'm also on fullfatrr.com) have kindly made some decent sounding suggestions too which I've passed onto my mechanic mate. So fingers crossed smile

tomw2000

Original Poster:

2,508 posts

219 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Update: collected car last night. Started and ran fine. Will feedback if same issue appears.
To clarify, for now only 'ignition relay' has been replaced

By a process of elimination I reckon it'll be cured eventually :|