Amazon Marketplace Seller Account Suspended - Funds Frozen
Amazon Marketplace Seller Account Suspended - Funds Frozen
Author
Discussion

_Nathan_

Original Poster:

506 posts

279 months

Friday 22nd February 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

I dropship some electrical items on Amazon Marketplace and have just had my account and funds frozen due to a complaint from a sales director of the brand in question that I am infringing their intellectual copyright.

They complained in January - I contacted them to see what the problem is and they never replied so I carried on selling. I still don't know what the problem is, and how on earth am I infringing IP if 30+ other sellers are selling the same item !!

What worries me is that Amazon have £1300 of my money and might not pay out.

Also I don't fancy having to take this to court to resolve:

Amazon cannot comment on the validity, availability, or appropriateness of any legal rights you may have, nor provide legal advice. However, if you believe the complaint is unjustified, you may consider pursuing a legal remedy to prevent the submitter from issuing future unjustified intellectual property complaints against your offers

Any advise would be gladly appreciated !

Thanks

_Nathan_

Original Poster:

506 posts

279 months

Friday 22nd February 2013
quotequote all
Oh, and I've just emailed the director who lodged the complained

Out of Office - away on annual leave

Bahh!


timskipper

1,306 posts

297 months

Friday 22nd February 2013
quotequote all
Are you using their brand name in such a way as to confuse or potentially confuse anyone viewing your listing that you are actually the brand, and not _Nathan_ Honest Trading, Inc.

Either that or using their images is my guess.

Call them on Monday and ask for their legal dept maybe?

Isonbusa

1,304 posts

264 months

Friday 22nd February 2013
quotequote all
Amazon, If 30+ sellers are selling the same item that's one listing/advert that gives buyers the option of choosing which one of the 30+ to purchase It from ?


Simpo Two

93,109 posts

296 months

Saturday 23rd February 2013
quotequote all
Amazon can't keep £1300 that doesn't belong to them indefinitely. They would have to send it either to you or, scary thought, to the moaning director, no?

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Saturday 23rd February 2013
quotequote all
Companies often use copyright and trademarks to stop the sale of grey imports - they can't stop you selling it but if you can't use a picture and the products name you won't get many buyers.

Talk to you dropship supplier, they should be buying through the correct channels and have permission to resell/dropship - if they do then it may just be an error and the manufacturer can't find any reference to you in their distributor records.

If the dropshipper doesn't have permission for trade sales then you may need a new supplier, or a new product.

And the other 30 sellers, they may be either a) going through the same thing, or b) have permission

_Nathan_

Original Poster:

506 posts

279 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
UPDATE Thanks for all of your advice. In the end they were accusing me of selling grey imports and were proved wrong.

Two weeks ago my account was reinstated and the funds were paid out.


But today my account was suspended again, the accusation (without evidence) was that I am selling grey imports.

The complaint refers to an item I list for sale, but have never sold.

How exactly can I evidence that I am not selling grey imports of an item I have never sold ?

Basically, I can only assume they are trying to wipe out the small resellers of their products

"XXXX has reason to believe that the products you are offering have been sourced from outside of the EU, either from USA or Asia. XXXX products are protected by trademark and sales of products not intended for sale within the EU is prohibited.

If you believe that the products you are offering are intended for sale within the EU and you have purchased them from within the EU (or Norway or Switzerland) please supply evidence of this, such as:-

1) A copy of your original purchase invoice (please block out any prices on the invoice as we do not need or want his information)
2) A photograph of the side of the product box of at least 3 separate XXXX products (to include the bar-code stickers)
3) The product name and the serial no. on the product itself

We will investigate the proof provided and in the event that the products you are selling are intended for sale within the EU then we will inform Amazon that you have provided this evidence and retract our Notice."


Edited by _Nathan_ on Monday 11th March 17:20

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
How do you plan to supply the item if you currently do not have any stock?

Do you have an account with a distributor or dropshipper thst stocks the item? If so explaining you haven't supplied any yest but will get them from XYZ (see attached proof of trade account) should be sufficient.

Is this the same company as before? Perhaps they have a process you can go through to register with them so they know you are not selling grey imports?

_Nathan_

Original Poster:

506 posts

279 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
Yes, I drop ship.

Thanks for your suggestion.

The complaint is from the original complainee.


Cheers

_Nathan_

Original Poster:

506 posts

279 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
Now that I have rebuffed their complaint that I have never sold this particular item, they are now complaining that I have violated Amazaons rules on advertising items 'In Stock' when I am in fact drop shipping.

I am fairly sure, this only applies if orders are advertised as 'PRIME' or are fulfilled by Amazon ?

Simpo Two

93,109 posts

296 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
Sounds like he's out to get you on any technicality he can. 'Infringement of IP' is not 'grey imports'.

I wonder if you can spot any infringements that HE might be making?

If you're in the right, keep fighting.

Some Gump

13,018 posts

217 months

Monday 11th March 2013
quotequote all
OP,

What is the brand?

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
_Nathan_ said:
Now that I have rebuffed their complaint that I have never sold this particular item, they are now complaining that I have violated Amazaons rules on advertising items 'In Stock' when I am in fact drop shipping.

I am fairly sure, this only applies if orders are advertised as 'PRIME' or are fulfilled by Amazon ?
Dropshippng on Amazon marketplace is a bit of a grey area. I don't think there's anything in the terms of business that expressly forbids it but Amazon do frown on it, their concern seems to be if you're advertising items as in stock when there's no guarantee your supplier will have stock and/or will ship within the required timeframe. Whether another seller complaining about this is enough to get your account suspended or terminated is another matter.


maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
Dropshippng on Amazon marketplace is a bit of a grey area. I don't think there's anything in the terms of business that expressly forbids it but Amazon do frown on it, their concern seems to be if you're advertising items as in stock when there's no guarantee your supplier will have stock and/or will ship within the required timeframe. Whether another seller complaining about this is enough to get your account suspended or terminated is another matter.
I don't think it another seller, rather the company that manufactures the product.

_Nathan_ said:
Now that I have rebuffed their complaint that I have never sold this particular item, they are now complaining that I have violated Amazaons rules on advertising items 'In Stock' when I am in fact drop shipping.
If your drop shipper provides stock info and you update your products to reflect this then it may not be an issue.


It sounds like they want to protect their supply chain and don't want what they perceive as low end / dubious box shifters damaging their brands or hurting price control. I would either give up or see if you can work with the manufacturer to comply with their requirements, this might be things like having your own website or an 'unofficial' agreement not to discount beyond a certain level.

Many brands don't want Amazon/ebay sellers as it can lead to a race to the bottom price wise, which then kills wholesale pricing and their supply chain. If you can't work with them they can make life difficult enough that even selling your other ranges is affected, so either come to an agreement, stop selling the brand in question or use a separate company to sell that brand so they can only cause problems for that seller account.

Given you say you haven't actually sold any of these yet I would just dump them.

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
_Nathan_ said:
Now that I have rebuffed their complaint that I have never sold this particular item, they are now complaining that I have violated Amazaons rules on advertising items 'In Stock' when I am in fact drop shipping.

I am fairly sure, this only applies if orders are advertised as 'PRIME' or are fulfilled by Amazon ?
Utter utter rubbish ALL of the electrical goods sold by small office supplies companies are drop shipped, I have competitors selling phones that sell hello kitty tea sets, shredders, Jml type products etc.
At the start of a day I can tell where they are drop shipping from depending on the amount of stock they say they have, on occasion if its just me and a dropshipper selling an item I wait till they upload the amount (from a feed) of stock then buy it all and raise my price so they get all the sales - petty but every little helps.

onesickpuppy

2,672 posts

188 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
Utter utter rubbish ALL of the electrical goods sold by small office supplies companies are drop shipped, I have competitors selling phones that sell hello kitty tea sets, shredders, Jml type products etc.
At the start of a day I can tell where they are drop shipping from depending on the amount of stock they say they have, on occasion if its just me and a dropshipper selling an item I wait till they upload the amount (from a feed) of stock then buy it all and raise my price so they get all the sales - petty but every little helps.
Come again?

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
Drop shipping is common on amazon, hence the broad spectrum of products sold by tiny companies in tiny offices.

In office supplies drop shipping is the main way of life, most put 5% on not realising they pay more than this in commission

HTH

onesickpuppy

2,672 posts

188 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
Drop shipping is common on amazon, hence the broad spectrum of products sold by tiny companies in tiny offices.

In office supplies drop shipping is the main way of life, most put 5% on not realising they pay more than this in commission

HTH
It was the bit about you buying everything and them getting all the sales that confused me.

DSLiverpool

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
You have to do all you can at times to protect your market..

marcosgt

11,506 posts

207 months

Tuesday 12th March 2013
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
You have to do all you can at times to protect your market..
By ensuring the Drop shipper gets all the sales? Which presumably they can't satisfy...????

No, I'm confused too...

M.