So we turned Adwords off for the first time
So we turned Adwords off for the first time
Author
Discussion

DSLiverpool

Original Poster:

16,577 posts

233 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
Does it become a comfort blanket, do you over analyse it ? Does the fear of turning it off fill you with dread?

Well we must have used Adwords for over 9 years and spent (gulp) over £750k, in the beginning (pre amazon) it obviously made a huge difference to sales and spending £450+ a day was cost effective but gradually for my sector of electronics I felt it was a Busted flush but like I said above its a comfort blanket and analysis said it paid off but I felt I knew best.

At 9am on the 1/2 we turned it off completely, our spend these days is far far less than the top years but nevertheless it's a new C63 (base spec) every year from nett profit.

How did we do? Ill update at month end as we get a fair few last minute orders in, I will be comparing feb 2012 with feb 2013 only differentiator is we added a second website in December but that's not a main contributor just yet (but its getting there)

Anyone else gone Adwords cold turkey after major use for years?

Frimley111R

19,428 posts

265 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
That'll be interesting to see.

sagarich

1,302 posts

180 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
Bookmarked.

I'm very interested to see how this turns out as I've been questioning our own PPC spend vs organic SEO work.

johnbear

1,568 posts

266 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
As a Adwords Mentor I see a fair few companies try turning off Adwords - Doesn't usually go well, often an indication that greater issues exist in the business sector with price points and a highly competitive market - not that I am saying this is your case.

It's unlikely that you will see a dramatic drop off in sales in the next few days as you may still have an ongoing sales pipeline. Some advertisers may even get a month or two before they experience a huge drop in sales.

If you examine the multi channel conversions in Analytics you may get an idea of how much crossover exists between Adwords, SEO, Email, Affiliates and Social. You may find out that may of your customers after 9 years are regular repeating customers who just got a little lazy and click your ads.

If your hoping to coast on SEO, it needs to be pretty impressive. 83% of the pixels above the fold on a Google with high commercial intent are now paid - the door on SEO has been closing for some years now.

A real danger facing you is that you may not easily be able to establish your dominance on Adwords if you need to return. As your retailing telecomms I might just keep the Product Listing Ads going after all their very effective and low cost.

Don't take this the wrong way, but many early Adwords advertiser believe have seen it all and there little that they don't know - strategies are moving incredibly fast on Adwords these days as Google are struggle to regain the 37% of new searches for products that go Amazon as their first stop. It might be worth re examining your approach.

If you want chat call me at ---------------- always willing to help.

Mod edit, no seo improvement techniques on the forums please.





Edited by johnbear on Monday 25th February 22:49


Edited by slinky on Tuesday 26th February 06:59

DSLiverpool

Original Poster:

16,577 posts

233 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
Johnbear all you say is true for a company not in electronics and if amazon didn't exist (no offence and i accept i have only my view of this) for consumer electronics amazon is the new google as people are fed up with poor quality drop shipping / wrong content website adverts for stockless faceless etailers and look for reviews and reputation with a name they trust.

People will find the item and price on amazon and often call to see if you answer the phone (5rings max) and if they trust you they will order then or via amazon. (eBay)

We have Zopim visit tracking on both sites so I can compare dwell, unique and revisits to he hour.

Ecommerce is evolving so fast our Adwords managers (multi google award winning) tell me things I could suss a while back however for Llangollen caravan park Adwords is the daddy for a company with 5000 skus it's not. Generic keywords - no thanks, comparison sites? Amazon pay to do this for you,

We're not giving up Adwords totally but I may start again in April, I've had an idea how to reuse Adwords in a totally new way that I will obviously not share but I expect real quality clicks for 20% of our current spend.

VEX

5,259 posts

277 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
johnbear said:
As a Adwords Mentor I see a fair few companies try turning off Adwords - Doesn't usually go well, often an indication that greater issues exist in the business sector with price points and a highly competitive market - not that I am saying this is your case.

It's unlikely that you will see a dramatic drop off in sales in the next few days as you may still have an ongoing sales pipeline. Some advertisers may even get a month or two before they experience a huge drop in sales.

If you examine the multi channel conversions in Analytics you may get an idea of how much crossover exists between Adwords, SEO, Email, Affiliates and Social. You may find out that may of your customers after 9 years are regular repeating customers who just got a little lazy and click your ads.

If your hoping to coast on SEO, it needs to be pretty impressive. 83% of the pixels above the fold on a Google with high commercial intent are now paid - the door on SEO has been closing for some years now.

A real danger facing you is that you may not easily be able to establish your dominance on Adwords if you need to return. As your retailing telecomms I might just keep the Product Listing Ads going after all their very effective and low cost.

Don't take this the wrong way, but many early Adwords advertiser believe have seen it all and there little that they don't know - strategies are moving incredibly fast on Adwords these days as Google are struggle to regain the 37% of new searches for products that go Amazon as their first stop. It might be worth re examining your approach.

If you want chat call me at ---- always willing to help.





Edited by johnbear on Monday 25th February 22:49
Could someone translate that for me?

I hope your not in sales jb as that has just totally lost me and turned me off, lol, and it was something I was I retested in as a technology / marketing tool (not that I want or need to use it)

V.


Edited by slinky on Tuesday 26th February 07:00

johnbear

1,568 posts

266 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
Ebay is a little problematic for many retailers in respect of competitive pricing, but Amazon is making real in roads into Google's market. Amazon's pricing whilst a little complex at times is often very competitive.

You don't appear to be running remarketing - this might be worth another inspection. It's particularly useful for re targeting non Adwords channels.

I am was nearing the end of my first book on Adwords & the Merchant Center, but I am having to rewrite several chapters due to recent changes. I'll send you the ebook when it's finished.

johnbear

1,568 posts

266 months

Monday 25th February 2013
quotequote all
VEX said:
Could someone translate that for me?

I hope your not in sales jb as that has just totally lost me and turned me off, lol.

V.
Sorry, it's just a little complex these days - it's was simple once - honest

bosshog

1,801 posts

307 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
Adwords is the most evil marketing platform ever produced in history. Its extremely clever and squeezing as much as possible out of advertisers taking the lions share in any competitive vertical.

Evil.

Frimley111R

19,428 posts

265 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
VEX said:
Could someone translate that for me?

I hope your not in sales jb as that has just totally lost me and turned me off, lol, and it was something I was I retested in as a technology / marketing tool (not that I want or need to use it)
V.
Edited by slinky on Tuesday 26th February 07:00
This probably won’t go well. If it doesn't he might not be able to simply return to doing it and generate the same levels of success.

Simpo Two

93,090 posts

296 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
bosshog said:
Adwords is the most evil marketing platform ever produced in history. Its extremely clever and squeezing as much as possible out of advertisers taking the lions share in any competitive vertical.

Evil.
My thought as I read Johnbear's posts was that it will increasingly suck all profit from companies as each one struggles to out-do the other. They do the work while Google grows fat.

DSLiverpool

Original Poster:

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
VEX said:
Could someone translate that for me?

I hope your not in sales jb as that has just totally lost me and turned me off, lol, and it was something I was I retested in as a technology / marketing tool (not that I want or need to use it)
V.
Edited by slinky on Tuesday 26th February 07:00
This probably won’t go well. If it doesn't he might not be able to simply return to doing it and generate the same levels of success.
And thats what our (Multi google award winning) adword managment company said as well BUT they did agree that adwords was now "not suited" to all types of business. They (as many others) cannot understand how electronic retailing has changed since Amazon and i wouldnt expect them to.

We have spread into more export, more trade, more repeat marketing or accessory marketing to compensate but the thought of £45k (after a modest £15k new adwords campaign) on the bottom line (in my bottom pocket) p/a is mighty tempting.

Can I just add our fledgling new site on the NOP platform SEO`s like a Ferrari - amazing, and it tells me what a dinosaur our bespoke 5 year old site is.


SlimJ

401 posts

260 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
Have you considered optimising your adwords rather than turning them off completely?

We have an outside agency manage our account and in the past 6 months our sales have more than doubled yet traffic and the cost of PPC has been cut in half (effectively increasing our conversion rate). We're now targetting foreign markets based on the optimisations we have done for the UK and expect to see similar results.

However, SEO still brings in the most visitors and revenue, although the conversion rate from that traffic is much lower than the PPC traffic.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
It will be an interesting comparison

It will also be interesting to hear what, if any, response you trigger from google. Will they notice that a ~£5k a month account has been turned off?

Clearly it also depends on the natural search position of your website(s)

Another aspect that I have been looking at recently is the cpc on keywords which seems to continuously drift upwards (as one might expect)

In some cases some keywords (not the ones that drive most sales as far as our sites are concerned) have become silly money (i.e gone from 35p a couple of years ago to over £3 in one case - this on a £5.99 item!)

Optimisation has to be the way forward. Anyone can buy clicks, but not everyone can buy clicks from people that buy quickly.

bigweb

833 posts

259 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
I will be very interested in your findings. I work for the largest PPC agency around and would be good to hear from a savvy business owner on their experiences with this.

DSLiverpool

Original Poster:

16,577 posts

233 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
[quote=SlimJ]Have you considered optimising your adwords rather than turning them off completely?

quote]

2 Inches above your post I wrote this - "And thats what our (Multi google award winning) adword managment company said" they win awards all the time BUT I have a feeling Google make so many Niche awards that every one is a winner ;o) They are good but markets change and an adword optimiser is NOT a small business owner in your sector, I have already said for Cleethorpes holiday park adwords is a no brainer but this is not that field, Amazon is the new Google but I dont expect any / many to agree.

bigweb

833 posts

259 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
DSLiverpool]limJ said:
Have you considered optimising your adwords rather than turning them off completely?

quote]

2 Inches above your post I wrote this - "And thats what our (Multi google award winning) adword managment company said" they win awards all the time BUT I have a feeling Google make so many Niche awards that every one is a winner ;o) They are good but markets change and an adword optimiser is NOT a small business owner in your sector, I have already said for Cleethorpes holiday park adwords is a no brainer but this is not that field, Amazon is the new Google but I dont expect any / many to agree.
Just as an aside. Who are the company?

digikal

2,202 posts

180 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
SlimJ said:
Have you considered optimising your adwords rather than turning them off completely?

We have an outside agency manage our account and in the past 6 months our sales have more than doubled yet traffic and the cost of PPC has been cut in half (effectively increasing our conversion rate). We're now targetting foreign markets based on the optimisations we have done for the UK and expect to see similar results.

However, SEO still brings in the most visitors and revenue, although the conversion rate from that traffic is much lower than the PPC traffic.
can you share the company?

Stevanos

700 posts

168 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
Does it become a comfort blanket, do you over analyse it ? Does the fear of turning it off fill you with dread?

Well we must have used Adwords for over 9 years and spent (gulp) over £750k, in the beginning (pre amazon) it obviously made a huge difference to sales and spending £450+ a day was cost effective but gradually for my sector of electronics I felt it was a Busted flush but like I said above its a comfort blanket and analysis said it paid off but I felt I knew best.

At 9am on the 1/2 we turned it off completely, our spend these days is far far less than the top years but nevertheless it's a new C63 (base spec) every year from nett profit.

How did we do? Ill update at month end as we get a fair few last minute orders in, I will be comparing feb 2012 with feb 2013 only differentiator is we added a second website in December but that's not a main contributor just yet (but its getting there)

Anyone else gone Adwords cold turkey after major use for years?
The fact that you have to turn off Adwords to me says that you are not tracking your campaigns properly, it should be perfectly possible to track and attribute spending against conversions.



Dick Dastardly

8,326 posts

294 months

Tuesday 26th February 2013
quotequote all
When you were judging the value of AdWords conversions, were you just looking at the main conversion data in AdWords, or the assisted conversion data within Analytics? For many ecommerce clients, the PPC ads assist in creating other conversions almost as much as they generate as a last-click attribution (which is how AdWords data measures it).