Letting somebody go
Discussion
So we are a small company who have just been on a recruitment drive in the last few months, we've gone from 4 people to 8, so a big increase. However, one of the young guys we took on, who was waiting for us for ages to appoint him hasn't turned out how we would like. He's only a month in and is so far behind where we would expected him to be and where he suggested he was in terms of skills that he's more hassle than anything else at the moment.
We are just about to start delivery on a new contract in the next couple of weeks and we can't find a role for this guy that we are happy with. He's also rubbing the other members of the team up the wrong way by not being in any way self sufficient at the moment.
This might change, but we are too small to carry people and we have about 20 similar applicants (who we found after we offered him the contract) who I would now pick over him.
I've never had to let anybody go before, and I think I'm a little too tied up in the emotive side of it at the moment as he's young, it's his first job and he's been looking for work for ages. It doesn't sit right with me that we are letting a fundamentally good guy go as he's not up to the task and shows no signs of coming good in the next couple of weeks.
We are just about to start delivery on a new contract in the next couple of weeks and we can't find a role for this guy that we are happy with. He's also rubbing the other members of the team up the wrong way by not being in any way self sufficient at the moment.
This might change, but we are too small to carry people and we have about 20 similar applicants (who we found after we offered him the contract) who I would now pick over him.
I've never had to let anybody go before, and I think I'm a little too tied up in the emotive side of it at the moment as he's young, it's his first job and he's been looking for work for ages. It doesn't sit right with me that we are letting a fundamentally good guy go as he's not up to the task and shows no signs of coming good in the next couple of weeks.
Just do it.
I was let go from a job when I was 18 or 19 and it hurt at the time. Looking back the job was totally wrong for me and there was no chance of getting anywhere within the company. Best thing that ever happened to me.
At that age you are just trying things for size, this role doesnt fit (doubt he will have seen that though!).
I was let go from a job when I was 18 or 19 and it hurt at the time. Looking back the job was totally wrong for me and there was no chance of getting anywhere within the company. Best thing that ever happened to me.
At that age you are just trying things for size, this role doesnt fit (doubt he will have seen that though!).
Never a nice thing to have to do, but sometimes a necessity. In some ways it is easier if its for disciplinary reasons as you are already angry with them (although emotions should not play a part - we are all human afterall).
I had to let a young girl go late last year, who was 2-months into her probationary period. I did not go into detailed specifics (not wanting it to appear personal), but had a frank conversation about what was best for the business, not performing as well as we expected, etc... stated that I would totally understand if she wanted to go immediately, but she would be paid until the end of the week and that was that.
Have to say though - be prepared for Mummy or Daddy to phone and call you a nasty, nasty man. The father phoned me every day for a week, but regardless of his questioning always got the same "it is nothing personal, she is a lovely girl but just not right for our business and you will appreciate we have to put business before personal feelings..."
The sooner you do it, the less time you will be worrying about it!
I had to let a young girl go late last year, who was 2-months into her probationary period. I did not go into detailed specifics (not wanting it to appear personal), but had a frank conversation about what was best for the business, not performing as well as we expected, etc... stated that I would totally understand if she wanted to go immediately, but she would be paid until the end of the week and that was that.
Have to say though - be prepared for Mummy or Daddy to phone and call you a nasty, nasty man. The father phoned me every day for a week, but regardless of his questioning always got the same "it is nothing personal, she is a lovely girl but just not right for our business and you will appreciate we have to put business before personal feelings..."
The sooner you do it, the less time you will be worrying about it!
You have no option unless you want to continue to carry his cost.
Just say to him that, sadly, it isn't working out and that, much as you like him, you have to let him go.
If you feel so bad and can afford it, maybe give him an extra week or two's wages to possibly help him look for something else.
Either way, as a business, you really cannot afford to keep him on.
Just say to him that, sadly, it isn't working out and that, much as you like him, you have to let him go.
If you feel so bad and can afford it, maybe give him an extra week or two's wages to possibly help him look for something else.
Either way, as a business, you really cannot afford to keep him on.
- 1st, have him in, ask him how he thinks its going and then set out your concerns. Tell him that your concerns are serious but that you are not rushing to any conclusions and have not decided on a course of action. Explain carefully and in detail your concerns and what you want to be different. Ask him if he is up for working with you to address your points. If so, work up a two week improvement plan detailing specific things that you want to see him do differently and the measurable outcomes that you expect. Review it with him at the end of the 1st week.
- Conduct the week 1 review and record the outcome. If no real improvement, say so, if an improved effort but no progress on outcomes, say so, if improved outcomes but not everything delivered, look at why & what needs to change in week 2.
- At the end of week 2 review. if you are seeing real improvement & you think he'll make it, put him on a 1 month plan and repeat. if he's not making it, you have all the data that you need for a very rational conversation about wwhy it would be best for everyone if he left.
That just sounds like death by a thousand cuts as opposed to firing squad. I know which way I'd rather go and lets face it from what you've said you have already decided and made your mind up. Just be frank and honest and say "Sorry it's not working out and I'm going to have to let you go" bang, job done, everyone can then move on with their lives and you'll stop waking up in the early hours thinking about.
mel said:
That just sounds like death by a thousand cuts as opposed to firing squad. I know which way I'd rather go and lets face it from what you've said you have already decided and made your mind up. Just be frank and honest and say "Sorry it's not working out and I'm going to have to let you go" bang, job done, everyone can then move on with their lives and you'll stop waking up in the early hours thinking about.
It really depends on how much support he has had but if it is as much as the OP infers then I'd probably agree to just get rid.Edited by Frimley111R on Friday 2nd August 12:35
mel said:
That just sounds like death by a thousand cuts as opposed to firing squad. I know which way I'd rather go and lets face it from what you've said you have already decided and made your mind up. Just be frank and honest and say "Sorry it's not working out and I'm going to have to let you go" bang, job done, everyone can then move on with their lives and you'll stop waking up in the early hours thinking about.
Providing there is some feedback as to "why" as well - then I agree. But just being fired with no reason gives him no chance to improve. Let him go, give him regular pay and something extra on top.Work out what went wrong in your hiring process that gave you such a miss. Do you need some extra tests as part of the process? 2 interviews? etc
If it's not working out and you've made the effort to help him then you should just speak with him about it and get it over and done with.
But if he's not performing and you've not told him that - then you're not giving him any guidance on how to behave or improve what he's doing.
Very few people start their first job and are perfect from day one. Part of taking on someone with that level of experience is knowing that you'll have to invest in them to get the most back out.
But if he's just a bit rubbish and not responding despite guidance then it maybe that he's in the wrong job anyway.
But if he's not performing and you've not told him that - then you're not giving him any guidance on how to behave or improve what he's doing.
Very few people start their first job and are perfect from day one. Part of taking on someone with that level of experience is knowing that you'll have to invest in them to get the most back out.
But if he's just a bit rubbish and not responding despite guidance then it maybe that he's in the wrong job anyway.
If there is any chance of a time-consuming & expensive claim of bullying or harassment from him, do everything that ClaphamGT3 said, including extending his probation period to cover the duration of the exercise if necessary.
If its possible that he's immature and needs steering to get the best out of, this may help you both to get better performance from him.
If not, have a chat with him at the end of this afternoon and send him away for the weekend with whatever is owed to him. Enjoy your weekend and use it as an opportunity to remind everyone else to keep standards up on Monday morning.
If its possible that he's immature and needs steering to get the best out of, this may help you both to get better performance from him.
If not, have a chat with him at the end of this afternoon and send him away for the weekend with whatever is owed to him. Enjoy your weekend and use it as an opportunity to remind everyone else to keep standards up on Monday morning.
ClaphamGT3 said:
* 1st, have him in, ask him how he thinks its going and then set out your concerns. Tell him that your concerns are serious but that you are not rushing to any conclusions and have not decided on a course of action. Explain carefully and in detail your concerns and what you want to be different. Ask him if he is up for working with you to address your points. If so, work up a two week improvement plan detailing specific things that you want to see him do differently and the measurable outcomes that you expect. Review it with him at the end of the 1st week.
I think this is the best approach, it feels right with me. I spoke to him yesterday and whilst I didn't directly say his job was under threat I explained that he's full-time with us and not a freelancer as we wanted him to contribute elsewhere in the company, and if he can't I have lots of people who I know can. - Conduct the week 1 review and record the outcome. If no real improvement, say so, if an improved effort but no progress on outcomes, say so, if improved outcomes but not everything delivered, look at why & what needs to change in week 2.
- At the end of week 2 review. if you are seeing real improvement & you think he'll make it, put him on a 1 month plan and repeat. if he's not making it, you have all the data that you need for a very rational conversation about wwhy it would be best for everyone if he left.
I will get my project leads to push him hard this week and see how he responds.
Thanks for all the feedback, it's my first time in this situation and it's good to hear the experience of others. I spoke to my CEO, he's very blunt, his thoughts are get him out now as my feelings won't change.
theboyfold said:
I spoke to my CEO, he's very blunt, his thoughts are get him out now as my feelings won't change.
This would be my gut reaction. If its not working out, then let him go now.You could go through an 'improvement plan' over the course of weeks or months only for the situation not to improve or revert back once the pressures off.
ClaphamGT3 said:
* 1st, have him in, ask him how he thinks its going and then set out your concerns. Tell him that your concerns are serious but that you are not rushing to any conclusions and have not decided on a course of action. Explain carefully and in detail your concerns and what you want to be different. Ask him if he is up for working with you to address your points. If so, work up a two week improvement plan detailing specific things that you want to see him do differently and the measurable outcomes that you expect. Review it with him at the end of the 1st week.
This is the best approach so far in my opinion if you are a quality employer who values their staff and your reputation. Remember the other staff will be watching how you handle this too and your actions/or inactions, could affect their view of the company and its management and leadrship values and thus their outputs and morale.- Conduct the week 1 review and record the outcome. If no real improvement, say so, if an improved effort but no progress on outcomes, say so, if improved outcomes but not everything delivered, look at why & what needs to change in week 2.
- At the end of week 2 review. if you are seeing real improvement & you think he'll make it, put him on a 1 month plan and repeat. if he's not making it, you have all the data that you need for a very rational conversation about wwhy it would be best for everyone if he left.
What has not been mentioned so far is that you hired him. Your advert, your job description and your person specification, your CV sift and your interview process and any other assessment you had in place told you that this guy was for you. Therefore us employers carry some of the blame if we get it wrong and so the above approach I would say is the best. And I say this too as your recruitment and selection process must have seen something in this chap. So with the above approach you may just be able to reignite his capabilities and save you the hassle of recruting the wrong person again. Why not also appoint him a mentor? Good luck!
Sorry, forgot to mention; I would carry out a short review to find out why I had got this one wrong if you do indeed have to let him go. What part of the selection process failed me in this instance is what I would wish to identify.
Edited by rog007 on Saturday 3rd August 05:34
POORCARDEALER said:
The decent person in me says try and talk and give guidance and help, after all he's very young....the realist tells me these situations usually cause the employers loads if grief.
This is what I'm struggling with, but we live in a very cut throat industry where he will have contact with the key decision makers. If he was just in a place where he has to tick boxes, that's more manageable, but that's not what we are involved with...theboyfold said:
my project leads
theboyfold said:
my CEO
Slightly O/T...but there's you, a CEO, and project leads (plural), and matey new boy who is not working out....in a company with a headcount of 8???Is it the sort of company where everyone is a manager or a "head of" or a "senior" or has some sort of job title that makes it sound like they run a large department when infact it's just them on their own?
If so, have you just gone too junior with this hire and don't have the bandwidth to support them?
mattdaniels said:
theboyfold said:
my project leads
theboyfold said:
my CEO
Slightly O/T...but there's you, a CEO, and project leads (plural), and matey new boy who is not working out....in a company with a headcount of 8???Is it the sort of company where everyone is a manager or a "head of" or a "senior" or has some sort of job title that makes it sound like they run a large department when infact it's just them on their own?
If so, have you just gone too junior with this hire and don't have the bandwidth to support them?
We are 8 in the UK and 250 globally. My CEO was based in our old HQ in Sweden, but has just moved to NYC after a recent merger. He recruited me, so we still talk about a lot of stuff and this came up in conversation. It's 8 full-time and maybe 40 odd with the freelance teams. Granted we aren't the NHS in terms of scale, but that's O/T anyway.
Anyway, yes, maybe we did go too junior with this guy, I'll happily admit that, but we have another full-time guy at the same age as him and he's been brilliant. We took a punt on him and it's not worked out. We do have the bandwidth to support and train him, but it's those times where you leave him alone to do something and he does a half arsed job, doesn't finish it and ends up just gawking at Sky Sports all day long.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


