Member-get-member loyalty scheme dilemma
Member-get-member loyalty scheme dilemma
Author
Discussion

-DeaDLocK-

Original Poster:

3,368 posts

282 months

Tuesday 27th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys,

My brains are a bit tired and I need the PH collective. The situation:

I run a website which sells gift boxes. We sell only one gift box at a time (we have a new one every month or so). The cost of the box is the same month-to-month. Over half of our customers are repeat - they come back every month to buy the box for themselves every time we have a new one available.

We want to implement a member-get-member loyalty/referral programme. How it works is this: each member gets issued a unique tracking link. If someone creates a new account using that link and orders a box, the originating member gets issued 30 points as a reward. This only happens on the FIRST order made by the new account. Subsequent orders on the new accounts get no rewards whatsoever.

Once you accrue 100 points, you can redeem a free box. So essentially every new purchasing member you bring earns you a 30% discount.

This is simple enough to implement, but I just thought of a way to "game" the system:

Assuming I am a repeat customer, I could create a ton of dummy accounts using my own referral link, and order each box on a different one. Each time, I earn 30 points. Eventually, I have enough to get a free box.

The whole idea of the programme is to get new members (who will hopefully end up being repeat buyers themselves). We have no problems "paying" for this. However, using the above hack, we are "paying" for nothing.

Any thoughts on how I can mitigate/eliminate this? We don't mind tweaking the programme if it means eliminating the problem.

We already have a few thousand account holders, so it's important it's done right from the start so we don't have to deal with a messy issue later on.

Thanks chaps!

V-spec

779 posts

282 months

Tuesday 27th August 2013
quotequote all
Simple check for duplicate delivery addresses?

On an aside, it would annoy me if you gave me 30 points for a referral but I need 100 for a free box. That's not 3 referrals needed, it's effectively 4.

-DeaDLocK-

Original Poster:

3,368 posts

282 months

Tuesday 27th August 2013
quotequote all
V-spec said:
Simple check for duplicate delivery addresses?
Thanks. Yes, we could issue a "catch-all" clause that says we reserve the right to bla bla bla, and then run background checks to catch the cheaters. But ideally the system would be designed to stop or disincentivise cheating in the first place. Just wondering if there is a way.

V-spec said:
On an aside, it would annoy me if you gave me 30 points for a referral but I need 100 for a free box. That's not 3 referrals needed, it's effectively 4.
Point noted, thanks. We have other ways you can earn points, and in the grand scheme of things, this is a non-issue with the site at the moment.

Frimley111R

19,439 posts

265 months

Tuesday 27th August 2013
quotequote all
Why are you considering this? They will refer you if your boxes are good anyway, there's no need to incentivise them. Finding 4 people to buy a box and use your link is more hassle than most people can be bothered with. The people who may do this are probably already multiple repeat customers anyway. It could also be a real headache to administer.

Why not give everyone, when they order their 5th, 10th, whatever a free box? They order one and your site says 'Thanks for your custom. We appreciate you using us so much we want you to have this box free.' That would create a far great 'smile per pound' than any referral scheme IMO. What other company does that?!