Buying Leasehold - Why?
Buying Leasehold - Why?
Author
Discussion

northwest monkey

Original Poster:

6,370 posts

220 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
Not sure which section this should go in, but I'm a Landlord and it's a question about a freehold on one of the properties we rent out so business it is!

One of our rentals is a ground floor garden flat in a purpose built maisonette. It basically looks like a pair of semis but is 4 flats, 2 up and 2 down. Maintenance is shared between the 4 leaseholders (me and 3 other LLs). They are relatively new-build (1985) standard construction. They are currently leasehold at £25 per year on the balance of a 999-year lease from 1985 (so about 970 years to go).

We've just had a letter from a company telling us of our freeholders "desire to dispose of their interest in the building and to provide us with the right of first refusal under the Act."

They are offering me and the other 3 landlords the "opportunity" to buy the freehold at a cost of £2,000 plus £480 fees. I'm not sure if for £2.5k I would get the freehold of the whole building or just my flat - it doesn't make that clear.

My question is this - what's the point? Seriously I don't get it. I would have to own the flat for 100 years to even break even on this deal so why are they even bothering offering it to me, and why would anyone actually consider buying the freehold with so long remaining on it?

I could understand owning a freehold with a load of short leases on a nice building in e.g Fulham, but over 900 years to go on some little flats in Manchester? Surely the value must be comparable to "owning" a plot of land on the moon?

I have seen freeholds sell at auction before now & have often wondered why people buy them so now I'm asking - educate mesmile

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
Well firstly thats their asking price, you can always put in a lower offer.

Secondly there is a perception that a freehold property is more valuable, whilst it is true that it makes little difference on such a long lease but people do perceive that it's not so good as freehold and so pay less for it.

98elise

32,902 posts

192 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
Owning the freehold gives you control over maintenance charges.

I owned a flat (in a block of 100) where the freeholder tried to screw us over on the maintenance charges. There was some work that needed doing, but they over estimated everything.

For example, there were a few lintels that needed replacing in the block. They costed for every lintel being replaced and the cost given was twice that of a normal lintel replacement. This went on with pages and pages of repairs at inflated rates.

The entire cost of estimated the repairs per flat, was greater than the cost of my flat!

To answer your question about why people buy just the freeholds at auction, its the yearly ground rent for a basic return, but the real value is in lease renewals, or screwing you leaseholders with excessive maintenance costs smile

Edited by 98elise on Sunday 1st September 08:23

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
You would need to renew your lease much sooner then the 100 year expiry date to maintain its value. Some lenders start to get nervous at 75 years remaining.

To renew means throwing some cash, at least if you buy the freehold you will only be doing it the once....

northwest monkey

Original Poster:

6,370 posts

220 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
98elise said:
Owning the freehold gives you control over maintenance charges.
Well that's the thing that's odd. The lease of £25 per year is purely for ground rent as such & not a maintenance type agreement. The lease specifies the freeholder isn't responsible for any maintenance - the 4 leaseholders are. I've got flats in other blocks where I pay a service charge for maintenance, cleaning etc but this little unit doesn't.

northwest monkey

Original Poster:

6,370 posts

220 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
You would need to renew your lease much sooner then the 100 year expiry date to maintain its value. Some lenders start to get nervous at 75 years remaining.

To renew means throwing some cash, at least if you buy the freehold you will only be doing it the once....
Completely agree with that, but this has over 970 years to go so it's not exactly making any mortgage company nervous!

On the flip side as to why I should bother buying it, why would the freeholder bother selling it?

Jobbo

13,921 posts

295 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
Why would the freeholder want to keep it? If he can get £2,500 for it, he'll be far better to sell rather than just enjoying £100 a year in ground rent. Seems expensive, anyway - I'd say £1400+fees would be more like market value, but still not really worth buying. Is the ground rent due to increase exponentially or anything silly?

It'll be the whole freehold being offered, anyway, to all four of you to buy. So just over £600 each if you accepted the initial offer.

costsmonkey

195 posts

187 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
If the freeholder wants to sell, then, subject to certain qualifying criteria, under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 as amended by the Housing Act 1996, they are obliged to give the tenants right of first refusal before it can be placed on the open market.

Freehold ground rents are popular with investors since they are seen as providing a very secure long term income. The returns are also better than a lot of other investments, particularly given the degree of security.

In your case, the current ground rent for all four flats totals £100 per annum. At £2,000 for the freehold (that almost certainly relates to the freehold for all four flats), that equates to a yeild of 5% per annum, which is not bad in the current climate particularly given the degree of security.

Freeholders often made additional money out of service charges, commission on insurance premiums and lease extensions but I see that is not likely to apply in your case. However, depending upon the terms of your lease, you may still require their consent to make alterations and, if so, many freeholders will make additional money by charging administrations fees for that.

Many leases also provide for ground rent to increase at a specified date in the future (many double after 25 years or so) which also increases the long term return.

Each to their own, but with a sucure 5% return in the short term, possibily a better return in the longer term, and the additional freedom of not having a third party freeholder, I would buy it. The price is pretty much in line with what is currently being paid in the auctions and prices are unlikely to fall. Aside from the income, you would therefore also have an asset that you could sell in order to recoveryour capital or possibly make a profit in the future, if you wish.



northwest monkey

Original Poster:

6,370 posts

220 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
costsmonkey said:
If the freeholder wants to sell, then, subject to certain qualifying criteria, under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 as amended by the Housing Act 1996, they are obliged to give the tenants right of first refusal before it can be placed on the open market.
In a nutshell, that's exactly what the letter says.

costsmonkey said:
Freehold ground rents are popular with investors since they are seen as providing a very secure long term income. The returns are also better than a lot of other investments, particularly given the degree of security.

In your case, the current ground rent for all four flats totals £100 per annum. At £2,000 for the freehold (that almost certainly relates to the freehold for all four flats), that equates to a yeild of 5% per annum, which is not bad in the current climate particularly given the degree of security.

Freeholders often made additional money out of service charges, commission on insurance premiums and lease extensions but I see that is not likely to apply in your case. However, depending upon the terms of your lease, you may still require their consent to make alterations and, if so, many freeholders will make additional money by charging administrations fees for that.
Yep - in the documents we got when we purchased the flat, the previous owner had been charged £100 for permission to replace a window with a patio door.

costsmonkey said:
Many leases also provide for ground rent to increase at a specified date in the future (many double after 25 years or so) which also increases the long term return.

Each to their own, but with a sucure 5% return in the short term, possibily a better return in the longer term, and the additional freedom of not having a third party freeholder, I would buy it. The price is pretty much in line with what is currently being paid in the auctions and prices are unlikely to fall. Aside from the income, you would therefore also have an asset that you could sell in order to recoveryour capital or possibly make a profit in the future, if you wish.
Thanks to everyone for the information - it's one of those things I'd always wanted to know & it's actually quite interesting!

For now, I'm going to leave it - knowing the other leaseholders, the idea of chasing them for £25 every year is too much like hasslelaugh

The Moose

23,710 posts

240 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
Could you all buy the leasehold and therefore no one is having to chase anyone for payment and that'd then take it to nearer £600 before haggling?

northwest monkey

Original Poster:

6,370 posts

220 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
The Moose said:
Could you all buy the leasehold and therefore no one is having to chase anyone for payment and that'd then take it to nearer £600 before haggling?
Having read the letter, in theory, then yes we could. In practice, I've got more chance of sprouting wings than getting everyone to agree on something.

Wings

5,984 posts

246 months

Sunday 1st September 2013
quotequote all
northwest monkey said:
Having read the letter, in theory, then yes we could. In practice, I've got more chance of sprouting wings than getting everyone to agree on something.
I have several leasehold flats, one of which i have just taken on the freehold and management of the same, block of four (4) flats. One example of savings I have achieved is on the block's building insurance, last year through an agent £1300.00, this year £707.00. Another example £120.00 to change a light bulb, me changing the bulb £1.

OP you have to buy the freehold, it is a must, good telephone legal advice on link below

http://www.lease-advice.org/