Original quote to be renegotiated. work complete.
Original quote to be renegotiated. work complete.
Author
Discussion

Oscarmac

Original Poster:

354 posts

200 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
I have an area of my building renovated recently. This involved removing a suspended ceiling and repainting the roof and rafters and upgrading the electrics.

Quotes were invited for all aspects of the job but I have a problem with one.

The decorator that we eventually employed has massively underestimated the job. He has a good reputation locally and has been on the radar for several jobs that we have had done recently and so we believed that he was low in price in order to get a foot in the door.

His price for the job excluding the hire of a scaffold was £690 + vat. This was 1K cheaper than the next quote we invited.

On starting he mentioned his concerns and I invited him to come up with a solution. This involved working through the week on top of the Bank holiday weekend which has resulted in a lot of disruption to normal trade and loss of earnings.

He has now come back with a revised price of 2.1k. I am confident that the contractor with the next price up would have brought it in within the price and so part of the problem is maybe that I have suffered from "if its too good to be true" syndrome.

I am prepared to move on the price because the bloke has done the work but would you pay the new asking price, the price of the nearest rival quote, or ask him to honour his original quote?

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Was it a quote or an estimate?

Oscarmac

Original Poster:

354 posts

200 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
it was a formal quote. All potential providers were aware of this.

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Hell of an increase.

If he was reasonable and did a good job I would pay an increased rate but unlikely the full 2.1.

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Oscarmac said:
it was a formal quote.
Unless it was qualified in any way, if I were in your position, I'd be asking him exactly why he thinks I should be on the hook for his pricing decision...?


NorthDave

2,542 posts

263 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
I'd probably meet him in the middle of your original quote and his new price. I would consider that to be very charitable though.

Currently sat on a job after three and a half weeks which was estimated, and priced for, two weeks. Not a snowballs chance in hell of being able to ask for more cash. I would feel stupid even hinting.

Oscarmac

Original Poster:

354 posts

200 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
There is a large part of me that thinks everybody makes mistakes and the shouldn't be hung out to dry for an honest one. I reckon his labour costs excluding himself must be in the £1500 region with paint and scaffolding on top.

He is a one man band, hiring in labour as required and I certainly don't want to make him suffer/struggle with mortgage payments etc.

My own feeling was to cover his costs but minimize/remove the profit element. As said I have lost trade as well.

Now how to get an honest answer?

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
So, he quoted £700.
Next quote was £1700.
He now wants £2100.

Correct?

I'd be having a fairly open conversation with him, explaining why he thinks you should pay more and asking what his costs to do the job are. Work out how much to pay from there, but it should definitely not be more than £1700.


Oli.

Pazuzu

482 posts

267 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
I'd be tempted to offer him the same as the next highest quote although, as has been said, when I've underpriced work or even fallen foul of others mistakes I've never been able to revise my quote and had to swallow the difference.

Cheers,

Phil

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Pay him what he quoted, hes gonna have to suck it up.

Unless you have requested any variations or any work has been completed that wasnt quoted for ie a problem was found and needed to be addressed that required more labour/materials.

I cant see how he can get his quote so far wrong, a 10-20% variation I could understand but going from £600 to £2000 is a bit of a stretch.

Also do you think that if he had quoted you £2000 and it only cost him £600 you would see the difference in the invoice?

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Maybe he uses this approach for all his business?

RicksAlfas

14,610 posts

275 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
If you feel you are taking advantage, and you want to use him again in the future, offer to split the difference.

If you think he's trying it on as this is his way of getting new work, pay the original quote and tell him never to darken your door again.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Would you use him again??

Personally, unless there was a very good reason for getting the price wrong, and it was something that no-one could know at the time of quoting, or I didn't disclose, I'd be very reluctant to pay more. Nothing personal, but if you screw up in business, its your fault, no-one else's.

Oscarmac

Original Poster:

354 posts

200 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
I've spoken to other people who have used him in the past and genuinely think this is an honest mistake due to a rushed quote. Don't think it was a reflection of his business practice.

When he has quoted for work before he has always been at the top end.

Quality of the work is good and certainly not bodged in order to cut corners and save on costs.

LooneyTunes

9,541 posts

189 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
In that case, if you want to pay him a bit more, then why not consider splitting the difference between his quote and the next most attractive - but making it clear you're doing this as a goodwill gesture.

A common lawyer

319 posts

159 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
He sounds like he's pricing like a lawyer: "Erm, about 40k, but we can't say for sure. It's 450 an hour".

Unless there's a very, very good reason for his quote being so far off (unforeseeable site conditions, like an unusual paint that needed treating or whatever, I'd say he's on the hook for the price.

southendpier

6,244 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Maybe he uses this approach for all his business?
This

12v3pot

5,135 posts

166 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
When he made clear his concerns, presumably due to issues unseen by him when quoting, what did you say?

If you didn't then say "No, we'll stick to the original figure", I think you should negotiate. The £1700 figure sounds like the right compromise.


Oscarmac

Original Poster:

354 posts

200 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
I didn't say stick to the original figure. I said that he was to find a solution. £1700 seems an acceptable compromise to me.

The work has been done to a good standard and I suppose " if you screw them on the way up ........"

m3jappa

6,950 posts

249 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
The decent human being in us should ensure the bloke doesn't suffer, however what I will say is I have got quotes wrong before, same as a lot of us I reckon and I'm fairly confident that if I asked for anymore I wouldn't get it. I've had to swallow it!

I do know however that some people do operate like this so the decision is yours if he's genuine, there's some slippery people out there Unfortunately.