Export sales VAT savvy legal advice needed
Discussion
Hi all, need some help.
We export several cars a year to dealers within the EC and it now appears our accountants have been zero rating margin scheme vehicles.
This is perfectly legal if certain criteria are met.
One of which is the agreement of the purchasing dealer that the car will be zero rated.
We have never asked our accountants to zero rate margin scheme cars, and we have never had agreement from the dealers that we are selling to that they are happy to do it this way.
Subsequently we're now in the position where the VAT man wants to look through all the cars we have exported for the last four years.
We are, not surprisingly, expecting to get a massive b
king from the VAT man with a bill to match.
My question is, how liable are our accountants?
We've never asked them to do the VAT on these deals in this way. They've never told us they were doing the VAT on these deals this way. They have never had agreement from the dealers that we are selling to that they are happy for the VAT to be treated this way.
We export several cars a year to dealers within the EC and it now appears our accountants have been zero rating margin scheme vehicles.
This is perfectly legal if certain criteria are met.
One of which is the agreement of the purchasing dealer that the car will be zero rated.
We have never asked our accountants to zero rate margin scheme cars, and we have never had agreement from the dealers that we are selling to that they are happy to do it this way.
Subsequently we're now in the position where the VAT man wants to look through all the cars we have exported for the last four years.
We are, not surprisingly, expecting to get a massive b
king from the VAT man with a bill to match.My question is, how liable are our accountants?
We've never asked them to do the VAT on these deals in this way. They've never told us they were doing the VAT on these deals this way. They have never had agreement from the dealers that we are selling to that they are happy for the VAT to be treated this way.
Hi Eric,
Many thanks for the reply. I was hoping you'd spot this.
As you know a vehicle is either VAT qualifying or margin scheme.
Until this week I (twenty years in the trade), my boss (the business owner with fifteen years in the trade) and my colleague with about ten years have never heard of zero rating a margin scheme car.
We were all assuming that the cars, as margin scheme, were having margin VAT charged against them.
Interestingly while trying to find out more info about this I cam across Notice 718 April 2011 which has a brief mention of this in section 7.3
Notice 718/1 Marxh 2011 has no mention of it.
I would have thought the notice with /1 would be the more up to date, but apparently not.
Many thanks for the reply. I was hoping you'd spot this.
Eric Mc said:
Did you ever discuss the VAT rules regarding export car sales with your accountant?
The only discussions over export of cars has always only ever been about VAT qualifying cars. In those cases we've always ensured we've got the relevant details to zero rate them at invoice point.Eric Mc said:
Were you aware, before the VAT man spotted the problem, that there might be an issue with the way you were handling the VAT on these cars?
No because it's not an area that we can alter on our stock records.As you know a vehicle is either VAT qualifying or margin scheme.
Until this week I (twenty years in the trade), my boss (the business owner with fifteen years in the trade) and my colleague with about ten years have never heard of zero rating a margin scheme car.
We were all assuming that the cars, as margin scheme, were having margin VAT charged against them.
Interestingly while trying to find out more info about this I cam across Notice 718 April 2011 which has a brief mention of this in section 7.3
Notice 718/1 Marxh 2011 has no mention of it.
I would have thought the notice with /1 would be the more up to date, but apparently not.
To be honest, I wouldn't pretend to be up to speed on the convoluted VAT rules surrounding the sale of cars to foreign customers.
I was more concerned with how much reliance you were putting on the accountant for advice on this area and how much checking you were doing of the accountant's VAT workings before approving the return for submission.
If you have a case against the accountant, it will very much depend on the formal agreement you had with him regarding the completion of the VAT returns. That means a careful examination of the Letter of Engagement you signed with the accountant and what it says regarding VAT returns.
I was more concerned with how much reliance you were putting on the accountant for advice on this area and how much checking you were doing of the accountant's VAT workings before approving the return for submission.
If you have a case against the accountant, it will very much depend on the formal agreement you had with him regarding the completion of the VAT returns. That means a careful examination of the Letter of Engagement you signed with the accountant and what it says regarding VAT returns.
It's possible, and legal, to zero rate a margin scheme car if selling to another dealer within the EC but outside of the UK.
The paperwork you need is a ballache and there doesn't appear to be any tangible benefit.
Our invoices are all raised using dragon 2000 stock book systems.
If it's a margin scheme car we have done nothing to the invoices that we wouldn't do for a UK sale except mark that the car went for export. We don't have the ability to change the amount of VAT on a margin car as the system self calculates.
If we're selling a qualifying car and zero rating it we make sure we have all the relevant documentation.
I've just looked at one of the cars on our system and this is what shows up.

It still shows as margin scheme and the VAT owed.
The problem is with how the accountants have then dealt with that. They've decided to zero rate as far as costs and sales are concerned on the VAT return.
The paperwork you need is a ballache and there doesn't appear to be any tangible benefit.
Our invoices are all raised using dragon 2000 stock book systems.
If it's a margin scheme car we have done nothing to the invoices that we wouldn't do for a UK sale except mark that the car went for export. We don't have the ability to change the amount of VAT on a margin car as the system self calculates.
If we're selling a qualifying car and zero rating it we make sure we have all the relevant documentation.
I've just looked at one of the cars on our system and this is what shows up.

It still shows as margin scheme and the VAT owed.
The problem is with how the accountants have then dealt with that. They've decided to zero rate as far as costs and sales are concerned on the VAT return.
Tricky one this.
My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
By the way, I have a car dealer using the margin scheme as a client - looking at your screen grab the margin is £3290 so surely the VAT due is 1/6 of this which is £548.33 but your figures say significantly lower - why?
David
My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
By the way, I have a car dealer using the margin scheme as a client - looking at your screen grab the margin is £3290 so surely the VAT due is 1/6 of this which is £548.33 but your figures say significantly lower - why?
David
Tricky one this.
My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
By the way, I have a car dealer using the margin scheme as a client - looking at your screen grab the margin is £3290 so surely the VAT due is 1/6 of this which is £548.33 but your figures say significantly lower - why?
David
My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
By the way, I have a car dealer using the margin scheme as a client - looking at your screen grab the margin is £3290 so surely the VAT due is 1/6 of this which is £548.33 but your figures say significantly lower - why?
David
sumo69 said:
Tricky one this.
My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
David
This was the sort of lines I was thinking.My thoughts are that the VAT you should have paid is not reclaimable as a PI claim as if the returns were correct you would have paid it in any case - what will be is any financial loss as a result of the alleged error in terms of interest, penalties, any bank fees if you need to borrow funds and an amount for compensation for the time to resolve the issue.
David
sumo69 said:
By the way, I have a car dealer using the margin scheme as a client - looking at your screen grab the margin is £3290 so surely the VAT due is 1/6 of this which is £548.33 but your figures say significantly lower - why?
David
The car came in part exchange and had an over allowance so it's SIV is not the actual amount given for the car which was higher, so I've already paid the increased VAT value on the car it came in against.David
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


