Premium rate phone line fraud - legal advice sought!
Premium rate phone line fraud - legal advice sought!
Author
Discussion

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Our PABX was compromised for a few hours on a Sunday which led to a large monetary value of outbound calls being made to premium rate and international numbers.

I really don't want to be saddled with the costs for this and the police aren't interested. Does anyone have any knowledge or experience of who is liable here?

Is it:
- us
- telecoms provider
- PABX provider (dealer)
- PABX manufacturer

Is this likely to be covered by our commercial insurance?

Thanks!

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
How was your PABX 'compromised'?

Do you mean some sort of 'hacking' and a number of calls were made, or do you mean someone was in the offices and made the calls?

Not sure what you mean? If a criminal offence has been committed then the police have to be involved, surely?

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
You are liable for the telecoms provider's costs I'm afraid. They should be able to beat the price down a bit, but ultimately they'll be getting a bill from their upstream provider and the benefiting provider will be in a different country and won't give a st.

If you have a company that is contracted to maintain the system then there may be a case against them - and they should be covered by their PI.

What kind of system is it, out of interest? As IT and telecoms have converged, there are a worrying number of VoIP capable systems not being properly secured.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
How was your PABX 'compromised'?

Do you mean some sort of 'hacking' and a number of calls were made, or do you mean someone was in the offices and made the calls?

Not sure what you mean? If a criminal offence has been committed then the police have to be involved, surely?
Some common attack vectors are:
- externally accessible voicemail systems allowing ongoing calls or call forwarding to be set
- SIP (VoIP) ports made available to the outside world, either by mis-design or inadequate security, and weak username/passwords allowing unauthorised extension registrations

Once compromised, somebody in a far away country will use your system to make lots of calls to international premium rate numbers, which they own or get a kickback from. The telecoms providers will all have bilateral agreements to pay each other for calls (otherwise the international system falls apart...) so the bill finds it's way back to you.

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
How was your PABX 'compromised'?

Do you mean some sort of 'hacking' and a number of calls were made, or do you mean someone was in the offices and made the calls?

Not sure what you mean? If a criminal offence has been committed then the police have to be involved, surely?
They managed to get in via an inbound line and then get an outbound line.

The police got me to register the crime with these people www.actionfraud.police.uk and all I have from them is a standard response "It is not possible for the police to investigate every report they receive and you will only hear from them now if they are able to progress the investigation further. You should keep safe any evidence which you feel may be of interest."

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
What kind of system is it, out of interest?
It's from NEC.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Blimey! Every day is a school day.

Seems to me that unfortunately you will be liable, but your insurance may cover you as it is technically a theft - even if you appear to have left the door open for them. Worth a try for a claim, what's the worst that can happen? A no.

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
Once compromised, somebody in a far away country will use your system to make lots of calls to international premium rate numbers, which they own or get a kickback from. The telecoms providers will all have bilateral agreements to pay each other for calls (otherwise the international system falls apart...) so the bill finds it's way back to you.
This is what I thought. Doesn't that make our telecoms provider an accessory to fraud by taking money off us and giving it to them? Is it money laundering?

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
RossP said:
joewilliams said:
What kind of system is it, out of interest?
It's from NEC.
Quite an old system perhaps?

Sounds like a DISA vunerability (Direct Inward System Access, designed to allow roaming users to dial into your system then use it to make outgoing calls) - unless you needed this functionality and made use of it, it should have been disabled. What has the system maintainer said?

Office_Monkey

1,969 posts

240 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
You might be able to negotiate a reduction in cost with the provider. I know that some will only charge the wholesale costs, which may help. I don't see how they are an accessory to the fraud (unless it was carried out by their employees?), and this scenario is usually covered in the contracts.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Office_Monkey said:
You might be able to negotiate a reduction in cost with the provider. I know that some will only charge the wholesale costs, which may help. I don't see how they are an accessory to the fraud (unless it was carried out by their employees?), and this scenario is usually covered in the contracts.
Yes, they'll be well covered by their terms of business I'm afraid.

The provider I use promise to remove their profit from the equation in this kind of scenario, but they will still have ongoing costs that they'll expect you to meet.

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
Quite an old system perhaps?
We've had it a couple of years and it is still sold.

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Office_Monkey said:
I don't see how they are an accessory to the fraud (unless it was carried out by their employees?), and this scenario is usually covered in the contracts.
Maybe I am being naive but I see them as an accessory as they are the conduit for the money. They are taking it off us and (indirectly) passing it to the fraudsters.

Mr Overheads

2,637 posts

207 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
You may be covered if you have "fraud protection" or similar charge on your phone bill.

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Mr Overheads said:
You may be covered if you have "fraud protection" or similar charge on your phone bill.
There isn't anything like that on our bill and our telecoms provider's current stance is that they want full payment.

Mr Overheads

2,637 posts

207 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
Who is the provider? And how much are we talking about?

RossP

Original Poster:

2,609 posts

314 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
I'd rather not say at this stage and it's a few grand.

I have found out its not covered on our commercial insurance.

Mr Overheads

2,637 posts

207 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
RossP said:
I'd rather not say at this stage and it's a few grand.

I have found out its not covered on our commercial insurance.
Pm me privately the company name and I'll help if I can.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
RossP said:
Maybe I am being naive but I see them as an accessory as they are the conduit for the money. They are taking it off us and (indirectly) passing it to the fraudsters.
The trouble is, they will have commercial agreements in place with their upstream providers promising to honour the cost of any calls coming from their network.

By the time the money reaches the beneficiary, it will have gone through a number of providers, each of which will be claiming the cost of the call from the next in the chain.

You know it's fraudulent, we know it's fraudulent, but Happy Go Lucky Telecom on the other side of the world aren't going to give a stuff.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 24th September 2013
quotequote all
RossP said:
joewilliams said:
Quite an old system perhaps?
We've had it a couple of years and it is still sold.
I'm not familiar with them, but I'd be amazed if the functionality that has been compromised cannot be disabled by the installer if not required. It should have been.

I assume that some action has been taken to stop further compromises - do you know what? Has your installer/maintainer looked at the system?