Sold business, buyer owes money for stock - sue!?
Sold business, buyer owes money for stock - sue!?
Author
Discussion

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
So I sold my business earlier this year, and the buyer was given 4 months to pay for the stock (as goodwill to help their cashflow). Those 4 months have been and gone, and it seems they're playing hardball to try and get out of it! Its near enough £50k so its not an insignificant sum to me!

My solicitor who handled the sale wants to charge me for her time, understandable I guess, but she already took £30k off me for the sale in the first place - from an initial quote of £5k max! So I'm a bit peeved and worried that costs could escalate.

My question to everyone is, what's the best and most cost-efficient way to go about this that will produce the required result?

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
So I sold my business earlier this year, and the buyer was given 4 months to pay for the stock (as goodwill to help their cashflow). Those 4 months have been and gone, and it seems they're playing hardball to try and get out of it! Its near enough £50k so its not an insignificant sum to me!

My solicitor who handled the sale wants to charge me for her time, understandable I guess, but she already took £30k off me for the sale in the first place - from an initial quote of £5k max! So I'm a bit peeved and worried that costs could escalate.

My question to everyone is, what's the best and most cost-efficient way to go about this that will produce the required result?

Terminator X

21,017 posts

235 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Is it in the contract? If so just enforce it. If not, hmmm ...

TX.

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Do you need a solicitor to sue at this level?

(Re solicitor quoting £5K and charging £30K - do they not know the difference between a quote and an estimate? Presumably the task was 6x harder than at first envisaged?)

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Do you need a solicitor to sue at this level?

(Re solicitor quoting £5K and charging £30K - do they not know the difference between a quote and an estimate? Presumably the task was 6x harder than at first envisaged?)
I think the OP does very probably. Unless the contract is binding on specific performance with regard to the payment of the money loaned (effectively), then I suspect that the buyers are hard faced enough to seek to avoid by obfuscation and delay. Solicitors letter should clarify the position. Up to the OP then depending on the outcome of such a letter, I would sue but solicitors are undoubtedly the best litigators for most businessmen. Necessary evils in business!

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Find a new solicitor.

It is possible to diy - but for that amount I'd get a pro to handle it. You should get costs.

Any idea why they are not paying? There should be a no set-off clause in the agreement (I would hope so for £30k), but even so they may try to bring a counterclaim for breach of warranty or the like.

Did they buy as a ltd co, or individual(s). If they don't have the cash, then doesn't matter what you spend.

Best advice is always to talk to them.

IATM

3,948 posts

178 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
If you have that agreement on paper somewhere just get baliffs on to it. you are allowed to use them, not sure if they can apply to court for the action or if its you (sorry if it sounds dumb to everyone else) Just thinking out loud.

Well thats what I would look into ASAP.

If it means going to court to have the action enforced then get a new solicitor and ask them to action it ASAP and leave the hard work to the heavy guys.


Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
(Re solicitor quoting £5K and charging £30K - do they not know the difference between a quote and an estimate? Presumably the task was 6x harder than at first envisaged?)
That is shocking and why you should always use a specialist when selling a business. Solicitors cause so many issues with company sales if they have no experience in such activities. Unfortunately many think they can manage a sale when in reality they can't.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
Simpo Two said:
(Re solicitor quoting £5K and charging £30K - do they not know the difference between a quote and an estimate? Presumably the task was 6x harder than at first envisaged?)
That is shocking and why you should always use a specialist when selling a business. Solicitors cause so many issues with company sales if they have no experience in such activities. Unfortunately many think they can manage a sale when in reality they can't.
Not 6x harder - 6x more time consuming.

To be fair, it's often the case that the deal is a lot more complicated and time-consuming than you are told when preparing the quote (I expect this is true of most service industries). Most clients think that their deal is straightforward and not too difficult. The real differential is in how the solicitor explains why the initial quote is wrong and how it is dealt with. As long as people know where they stand things tend to work well - it's unexpected bills that create unhappy clients.


Mods - Any chance we could combine the two threads?

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
Not 6x harder - 6x more time consuming.

To be fair, it's often the case that the deal is a lot more complicated and time-consuming than you are told when preparing the quote (I expect this is true of most service industries). Most clients think that their deal is straightforward and not too difficult. The real differential is in how the solicitor explains why the initial quote is wrong and how it is dealt with. As long as people know where they stand things tend to work well - it's unexpected bills that create unhappy clients.


Mods - Any chance we could combine the two threads?
Yes that's the jist of the original situation. They hadn't handled a sale in my specific sector previously, and totally misunderstood the issues involved. I think what also didn't help was that my solicitor and the buyer's solicitor did not see eye to eye at all...the cynic in me wonders if they 'argue' on purpose to both increase their fees??

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
Is it in the contract? If so just enforce it. If not, hmmm ...

TX.
How do you 'just enforce' a contract? We've stated that it requires payment, but they're delaying with excuses.

The sale was the shares in the ltd company.

Also, can someone clarify - the business was sold for £x with £40k retention (for stock). The stock came to £35k, so do they owe me £40k or £35k? I thought it was £35k until my solicitor said otherwise.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
Is it in the contract? If so just enforce it. If not, hmmm ...

TX.
How do you 'just enforce' a contract? We've stated that it requires payment, but they're delaying with excuses.

The sale was the shares in the ltd company.

Also, can someone clarify - the business was sold for £x with £40k retention (for stock). The stock came to £35k, so do they owe me £40k or £35k? I thought it was £35k until my solicitor said otherwise.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
Find a new solicitor.

It is possible to diy - but for that amount I'd get a pro to handle it. You should get costs.

Any idea why they are not paying? There should be a no set-off clause in the agreement (I would hope so for £30k), but even so they may try to bring a counterclaim for breach of warranty or the like.

Did they buy as a ltd co, or individual(s). If they don't have the cash, then doesn't matter what you spend.

Best advice is always to talk to them.
What's a set-off clause?

They certainly have the money, I know what the business makes and its unlikely they'd have run it to death that quickly!

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
PM sent - give me a call. Probably easier for me to answer any questions over the phone.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Friday 27th September 2013
quotequote all
Seany88 said:
Terminator X said:
Is it in the contract? If so just enforce it. If not, hmmm ...

TX.
/
How do you 'just enforce' a contract? We've stated that it requires payment, but they're delaying with excuses.

The sale was the shares in the ltd company.

Also, can someone clarify - the business was sold for £x with £40k retention (for stock). The stock came to £35k, so do they owe me £40k or £35k? I thought it was £35k until my solicitor said otherwise.
You need a specialist litigation lawyer. What safeguards did you lawyer build in for just this situation?? If the answer is none get a more competent lawyer. You should have a means of enforcing the contract where you are effectively lending money.

StevieBee

15,515 posts

286 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Regardless of the contract issue, you need to try to determine if they can pay or they are just delaying payment or trying to avoid it.

If they have no cash, you could easily rack up more legal fees and still not get any money.

I assume that as the stock has not been paid for, you still technically own it so can get it back if needed?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
StevieBee said:
Regardless of the contract issue, you need to try to determine if they can pay or they are just delaying payment or trying to avoid it.

If they have no cash, you could easily rack up more legal fees and still not get any money.

I assume that as the stock has not been paid for, you still technically own it so can get it back if needed?
Quite right about the borassic debtor being a poor target for litigation if that is the case. The suggestion of seizing the stock was reflected in my earlier "you should be protected by the conract" commet. To expand that slightly if you have a lien on this stock through the contract arrange bailiffs and collect your goods. If title passed to the buyers without a lien in place get rid of your solicitor and pursue them via the Law Soceiry for fundamentally bad advice.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Sorry for the delay on this, I'm in the process of instructing another solicitor and also lodging a complaint to the Legal Ombudsman for the previous solicitor.

In the SPA, the clause states:

Any payments due under Claust 1.5 will be made by electronic funds transfer to the bank account of the payee (who will supply details on request) or such other method as may be agreed between the parties. Any payments due to the Seller under clause 1.5 shall become due and payable within 4 months of the date that the value of the Stock is agreed or determined (as the case may be).

So there is no lien in place, but does this make things more straight forward? I'm going to speak with the new solicitor about this, but can I simply appoint a debt collector to enforce this clause? As although the buyer has other issues, he should not be legally allowed to just withhold the stock value against his other disputes, but that if he has a separate problem he should sue me for them? Is that right?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Seany88 said:
Sorry for the delay on this, I'm in the process of instructing another solicitor and also lodging a complaint to the Legal Ombudsman for the previous solicitor.

In the SPA, the clause states:

Any payments due under Claust 1.5 will be made by electronic funds transfer to the bank account of the payee (who will supply details on request) or such other method as may be agreed between the parties. Any payments due to the Seller under clause 1.5 shall become due and payable within 4 months of the date that the value of the Stock is agreed or determined (as the case may be).

So there is no lien in place, but does this make things more straight forward? I'm going to speak with the new solicitor about this, but can I simply appoint a debt collector to enforce this clause? As although the buyer has other issues, he should not be legally allowed to just withhold the stock value against his other disputes, but that if he has a separate problem he should sue me for them? Is that right?
You need direct advice from an experienced litigation lawyer. Unless a lien is specifically held over the stock in the original sale I do not think you can seize any goods per se. You would need to follow the CC procedures to obtain a judgement and then pursue that if a judgement is obtained. As others have said if the buyer is practiced at this you may find he is a man of straw. In which case litigation may be satisfying in proving you right but not to you pecuniary advantage. I wish you well with your case against the original lawyers, I do hope you receive some recompense but again there are no guarantees. Your original instructions will be of critical importance. Did you actually ask for such protections to be included?

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
No I didn't, but I went in to their office openly as someone who does not know much about clauses and law etc so surely it would have been in my best interests to suggest a clause such as that?