Turnover and VAT
Discussion
I've tried to offer my mate advice but am not 100% on the legalities.
If he supplies materials and labour obviously it all counts to the turnover threshold for vat.
If he needs materials he would get them via his credit account and charge the customer the total amount so both labour and materials count towards the turnover.
If the customer buys the materials direct form say B&Q then he only charges for labour and thus cuts down on the overall turnover.
What is the position on turnover if the customer uses my mates account for the materials to get the discount but pays the wholesaler direct? obviously my mate will get an invoice/receipt for the goods but will not of handed over any money, or took any for the materials. Doing it this way he can still get the credit terms without asking for money up front.
Someone told him he could do this but I'm a bit dubious. He is only small time really and the vat could make all the difference.
Whats the difference between doing this and setting up a different company that handles the materials.
If he supplies materials and labour obviously it all counts to the turnover threshold for vat.
If he needs materials he would get them via his credit account and charge the customer the total amount so both labour and materials count towards the turnover.
If the customer buys the materials direct form say B&Q then he only charges for labour and thus cuts down on the overall turnover.
What is the position on turnover if the customer uses my mates account for the materials to get the discount but pays the wholesaler direct? obviously my mate will get an invoice/receipt for the goods but will not of handed over any money, or took any for the materials. Doing it this way he can still get the credit terms without asking for money up front.
Someone told him he could do this but I'm a bit dubious. He is only small time really and the vat could make all the difference.
Whats the difference between doing this and setting up a different company that handles the materials.
NH1 said:
What is the position on turnover if the customer uses my mates account for the materials to get the discount but pays the wholesaler direct? obviously my mate will get an invoice/receipt for the goods but will not of handed over any money, or took any for the materials. Doing it this way he can still get the credit terms without asking for money up front.
Look at it from a practical standpoint.Your mate is going to ask his customers to buy goods on his credit account on the basis that they (the customer) will pay for them later in the job?
If so, the obvious question (VAT aside for the time being) is, what he's going to do when a customer doesn't pay. It's HIS credit account, yet he (in theory) is having nothing to do with the supply of materials...
Wouldn't it be cleaner if he agreed to send his jobs in the direction to wholesaler who'll give him trade pricing for all of them, but with each customer paying at time of order?
If he asks the customer to buy and pay for the materials he intends to use in a job he is intending top do, then it is totally legitimate for him to bill for labour only and keep his turnover lower and below the VAT threshold.
If, on the other hand, he allows the customer to buy goods from a supplier USING HIS SUPPLIER ACCOUNT, there is a good chance that HMRC would view that HE is contracting for the purchase of those good and should be including the value of those goods when generating his sales invoices - EVEN IF THE CUSTOMER PAYS THE SUPPLIER DIRECTLY.
If, on the other hand, he allows the customer to buy goods from a supplier USING HIS SUPPLIER ACCOUNT, there is a good chance that HMRC would view that HE is contracting for the purchase of those good and should be including the value of those goods when generating his sales invoices - EVEN IF THE CUSTOMER PAYS THE SUPPLIER DIRECTLY.
I gave a builder 7 cheques for materials and services from other people, (which had VAT on), to the tune of about £8K. I also paid him £8k in 3 cheques, at various agreed milestones, because he did not want to be Vat registered.
A £16K loft conversion, would have cost £17600 if he'd been Vat registered, but we still paid £1600 Vat on the materials.
I thought this a reasonable and legal arrangement, plus I knew that the materials had been paid for, so a reasonable way of managing stage payments and ensuring that there were no nasty surprises.
His wife was an accountant.
A £16K loft conversion, would have cost £17600 if he'd been Vat registered, but we still paid £1600 Vat on the materials.
I thought this a reasonable and legal arrangement, plus I knew that the materials had been paid for, so a reasonable way of managing stage payments and ensuring that there were no nasty surprises.
His wife was an accountant.
Eric Mc said:
If, on the other hand, he allows the customer to buy goods from a supplier USING HIS SUPPLIER ACCOUNT, there is a good chance that HMRC would view that HE is contracting for the purchase of those good and should be including the value of those goods when generating his sales invoices - EVEN IF THE CUSTOMER PAYS THE SUPPLIER DIRECTLY.
That was my thinking too, Eric. Not from an informed accountancy perspective, but more from following a "looks like a duck, quacks like a duck..." train of thought. More so if there's a credit facility involved.I went to a HMRC open day a few years ago and there was a workshop about VAT, one of the things that the speaker raised was about this. He said that any disbursement on an invoice could be left out of the total turnover as long as the invoice was given to the client and there was no profiteering at all on the supply of the goods.
Whether this works practically though is anyones guess, but the theory made sense at the time.
Whether this works practically though is anyones guess, but the theory made sense at the time.
NH1 said:
What is the position on turnover if the customer uses my mates account for the materials to get the discount but pays the wholesaler direct? obviously my mate will get an invoice/receipt for the goods but will not of handed over any money, or took any for the materials. Doing it this way he can still get the credit terms without asking for money up front.
Could your mate not get an agreement with his supplier that (for example) instead of getting his 15% discount on their goods through his account, that any customers saying "Jim sent" me gets 10% discount, and he gets an extra 5% off his purchases. That way there is no direct contract between the customer and 'Jim' and his account to potentially complicate matters.
groucho said:
I would NEVER let a customer use my credit account, a recipe for disaster. I couldn't cope with the hassle, that's why I went Vat registered. It actually makes you more competitive on new builds.
I guess that there is an assumption that if you are Vat registered you are not related to any caravan dwelling folk, and are seriously and properly in business, and not just an under trained blagger. Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





