The Business of Providing Comprehensive Motor Insurance
The Business of Providing Comprehensive Motor Insurance
Author
Discussion

Glassman

Original Poster:

25,105 posts

246 months

Wednesday 2nd October 2013
quotequote all
Being in the business of repairing and replacing windscreens and glass etc, I've often wondered how much of a difference it would make if I asked for windscreen cover to be removed. It's a question which catches most of them out and to save all the faffing about, it's better just to take the policy as a FC package.

Why do most insurers include glass cover as standard in comprehensive policies? Why not offer it as a bolt on?

I don't understand how, by including glass cover, the underwriters don't see the potential for a premium to be wiped out in one windscreen/glass claim. At least with a collision, there is a chance that there'll be a third party/non fault element, or that the insured may not claim and just pay for the damage themselves if it's more or less the excess they would pay.

Looking at how cheap some insurance cover can be, and comparing the average (private lines) quote to the potential cost of a heated/solar coated/HUD windscreen with rain sensor, light sensor, condensation sensor, active lane assist, lane departure, GPS/TV/radio antennae PLUS trims and mouldings etc etc.

Every comprehensive policy is open to a likely risk of glass damage. How much of a premium is glass cover worth? And why are insurers including it as standard when they usually offer add-ons for ICE, losing keys, legal back up, etc?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
They offer it because it's popular. Getting a cracked screen doesn't happen very often, but it's annoying when it does. Underwriters are very good at pricing up risk, and I can promise you that the price they charge for windscreen cover is sufficient to cover them, plus a bit for profit. They simply wouldn't do it otherwise.

Rick101

7,191 posts

181 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Knocked it off my Allinaz policy as I've never used it in 16 yrs of driving.

Saved £10


Two days later got a rock through the window! £190

Glassman

Original Poster:

25,105 posts

246 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
They offer it because it's popular. Getting a cracked screen doesn't happen very often, but it's annoying when it does. Underwriters are very good at pricing up risk, and I can promise you that the price they charge for windscreen cover is sufficient to cover them, plus a bit for profit. They simply wouldn't do it otherwise.
Fair enough, and not every single policy will net them a profit, but if an insurer can offer a 500 quid premium to insure a car which, if the windscreen (or heated rear window) was to go, they might be in for a +800 quid payout.


_rubinho_

1,237 posts

214 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Glassman said:
davepoth said:
They offer it because it's popular. Getting a cracked screen doesn't happen very often, but it's annoying when it does. Underwriters are very good at pricing up risk, and I can promise you that the price they charge for windscreen cover is sufficient to cover them, plus a bit for profit. They simply wouldn't do it otherwise.
Fair enough, and not every single policy will net them a profit, but if an insurer can offer a 500 quid premium to insure a car which, if the windscreen (or heated rear window) was to go, they might be in for a +800 quid payout.

Fair enough, and not every single policy will net them a profit, but if an insurer can offer a 500 quid premium to insure a car which, if crashed into multiple vehicles and killed or seriously injured a several people, they might be in for a multi-million quid payout.

Glassman

Original Poster:

25,105 posts

246 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Assessing, and calculating risk and on the balance of probabilities, I'm asking why they don't strip FC policies of glass cover and offer it as a bolt on feature.

robnokia

105 posts

201 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Ive thought about it before. I figured they offered to do chips for free as chips are cheaper then windscreens to repair and chips can turn into broken screens. As for not covering the glass totally where would they stop? Not covering bodywork? Not covering wheels?
I reckon people who would strip the cover would strip it all down to third party. I get your thinking that you could repair the screen cheaper then insurance and so the the element of your insurance that covers the glass is probably not value for money for you but it's quite a unique circumstance and people rarely break down costs of a whole policy like that

Steve H

1,172 posts

255 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
What also surprises me is that in my experience, having a windscreen claim does not affect your ncb whereas having a claim for say a dented bonnet does!

Simpo Two

93,115 posts

296 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Steve H said:
What also surprises me is that in my experience, having a windscreen claim does not affect your ncb whereas having a claim for say a dented bonnet does!
I think a cracked windscreen is regarded as 'one of those things' whereas a dented bonnet implies some kind of accident.

I never needed a new windscreen until I had a 2001 Jaguar S-Type; it got through two of them in short order. Just ine little stone and - crack; they're just too thin and fragile. In comparison my 1993 BMW730 was bullet proof.

Steve H

1,172 posts

255 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
I think a cracked windscreen is regarded as 'one of those things' whereas a dented bonnet implies some kind of accident.

I never needed a new windscreen until I had a 2001 Jaguar S-Type; it got through two of them in short order. Just ine little stone and - crack; they're just too thin and fragile. In comparison my 1993 BMW730 was bullet proof.
I can understand that but if your driving along and an object comes up and hits your glass... your OK but a foot lower and it hits your bonnet your not. Both accidental damage claims as far as I am concerned.

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Glassman said:
Fair enough, and not every single policy will net them a profit, but if an insurer can offer a 500 quid premium to insure a car which, if the windscreen (or heated rear window) was to go, they might be in for a +800 quid payout.

I seem to recall someone on here a while back mentioned that the real cost of the windscreens (in general) to the insurer is a tiny fraction of what Autoglass and their ilk charge us as a retail customer. In fact, it was suggested that the excess pretty much covers the cost of the glass, which is probably why they offer it for free.

Might not be true of course, but insurers don't give money away for no good reason.

surveyor

18,708 posts

215 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Super Slo Mo said:
Glassman said:
Fair enough, and not every single policy will net them a profit, but if an insurer can offer a 500 quid premium to insure a car which, if the windscreen (or heated rear window) was to go, they might be in for a +800 quid payout.

I seem to recall someone on here a while back mentioned that the real cost of the windscreens (in general) to the insurer is a tiny fraction of what Autoglass and their ilk charge us as a retail customer. In fact, it was suggested that the excess pretty much covers the cost of the glass, which is probably why they offer it for free.

Might not be true of course, but insurers don't give money away for no good reason.
It would be interesting. Because I have a business policy when I claimed the insurance company wanted me to pay the vat so I saw the invoice - something like £1,000 + VAT for a 520d (rain sensor). I wonder how much (if anything), kicks back to the insurance company, and how much AW get paid to manage the process.

As it happened because I'm on flat rate VAT I could not claim back the additional VAT, and I managed to dodge this bullet as it was an irrevocable loss.

_rubinho_

1,237 posts

214 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Glassman said:
Assessing, and calculating risk and on the balance of probabilities, I'm asking why they don't strip FC policies of glass cover and offer it as a bolt on feature.
Yes but my point when I misquoted you was that they obviously have assessed the risk of a total windscreen replacement payout to be small (see post about premium being ~£10 cheaper without windscreen cover) that they have decided that their cost-benefit is better when providing blanket windscreen protection on comprehensive policies rather than not.

The rules for assessing risk for windscreens is the same as assessing risk for total loss claims with large third-party liabilities. The probability of cracking a windscreen beyond repair is larger than that of being the cause a fatal multi-vehicle incident but the cost is also negligible in comparison.

That they have decided to eschew removing claimants' NCB suggests that they want to encourage claims for windscreen repairs. The reasons for this could be that having cars with undamaged windscreens reduces the risk of other, larger claims.

insurance_jon

4,099 posts

277 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
they do it to keep admin costs down versus earnings

there are some policies which don't included it, but not many.

A lot of motor trade/fleet policies don't include it and you can buy it as a separate bolt on policy

Muncher

12,235 posts

280 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Every car I have had has needed a new screen at some point, I've probably had 5 windscreens replaced in 12 years of driving. Back in the day I used to pay windscreen invoices for an insurer, and even the preferred supplier ones were not as cheap as you might think.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
If it wasn't included, i'd probably insure elsewhere smile


Glassman

Original Poster:

25,105 posts

246 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Super Slo Mo said:
I seem to recall someone on here a while back mentioned that the real cost of the windscreens (in general) to the insurer is a tiny fraction of what Autoglass and their ilk charge us as a retail customer. In fact, it was suggested that the excess pretty much covers the cost of the glass, which is probably why they offer it for free.
Much of the billing is done under retail to protect the details of that contract and how much discount they get, or what the average invoice value is. The deduction would be made retrospectively.

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Glassman said:
Super Slo Mo said:
I seem to recall someone on here a while back mentioned that the real cost of the windscreens (in general) to the insurer is a tiny fraction of what Autoglass and their ilk charge us as a retail customer. In fact, it was suggested that the excess pretty much covers the cost of the glass, which is probably why they offer it for free.
Much of the billing is done under retail to protect the details of that contract and how much discount they get, or what the average invoice value is. The deduction would be made retrospectively.
Yes, I was thinking that would be the case.

Glassman

Original Poster:

25,105 posts

246 months

Friday 4th October 2013
quotequote all
I'm also baffled by the 'unlimited windscreen cover' aspect to it; some insurers will say the number of claims is unlimited and others suggest it's the value of each claim. A lot depends on who you're speaking to on the day, but it can get quite tedious after a while, especially if you're on your fourth/fifth prospective insurer and each time you ask them to explain what the windscreen cover [b]actually[/i] covers you for, they usually put you on hold to go find out.