Selling Half a Business
Selling Half a Business
Author
Discussion

Aerate

Original Poster:

323 posts

179 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
My wife is a director of a limited company operating a clothes shop on a well-known London shopping street. Four years ago we moved to the country and what with one thing and another she has been on maternity leave for much of the past three years. She has now come to the end of her maternity leave and has started another career closer to home. She would like to sell the business, but the other director doesn't want to sell. They are still good mates and they want to find a fair and amicable way out.

The business is independent, has been operating for thirteen years and has a very loyal following, the shop is leased and the only assets are the stock in the shop. On paper it is a very small fish: turnover is £175k per year and profit is £17k (however this £17k is paid out as a dividend to make the salaries up to £20k for each director). My wife's business partner organised a valuation which he thought would be on the low side and they came back with £160k as the value of the business! Obviously he doesn't have the cash to buy her out and my wife thinks the valuation is ludicrous.

The solution that is on the table at present is that my wife will take £15k cash from her partner plus £5k benefits and consultancy from the business and then he gets sole ownership. If he were to sell the business next year she would get 50% of anything over £40k, if he sold the year after it would be 40% and so on.

Is this a reasonable way out, or is someone going to end up out of pocket? Are there any buyers who would a half share in a menswear shop for £80k? Opinions and views please...

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
You haven't mentioned, but I'm assuming they're both 50% shareholders?

Aerate

Original Poster:

323 posts

179 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
joewilliams said:
You haven't mentioned, but I'm assuming they're both 50% shareholders?
Yup - 50 / 50 split

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
In situations like this it's certainly worth keeping things amicable - to do otherwise is a quick way to lose the lot. It sounds like there isn't much to stop the bloke reopening and continuing as normal with another limited company if things turn sour.

It seems like your wife is being reasonable about the situation and the proposed solution doesn't sound too badly structured to me although the actual value of goodwill/the brand is impossible for us to determine - really I'd say you're wife is best placed to decide on this so if she's happy and if so it's a good result.

Get anything regarding future payments etc written up by a solicitor although such things rely on good relationships regardless as it's easy enough to work around them and enforcement will still cost a fortune.

Edited by rpguk on Friday 18th October 10:46

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
If both parties are happy with the arrangement, then get it drawn up legally and get it done. Its only if one half feels screwed over that it would get nasty.

Frimley111R

19,436 posts

265 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
My wife says £50-60K value at best (she works in this field, albeit with SME+ sized companies).

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
If both parties are happy then go for it. She could go back and say she wants more, but that's just likely to draw the whole thing out and increase the likelihood of damaging the good relations they currently have, for the amounts your talking then it's just not worth it.


sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
My back of the envelope given limited info is 45-50k based on an immediate payout.

So this could be structured in many ways you should get an accountant or solicitors advice.

David

Aerate

Original Poster:

323 posts

179 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
My wife says £50-60K value at best (she works in this field, albeit with SME+ sized companies).
sumo69 said:
My back of the envelope given limited info is 45-50k based on an immediate payout.

So this could be structured in many ways you should get an accountant or solicitors advice.

David
Are you talking total value of the business or value of her half? Where would these values have got the £160k figure?

Simon Brooks

1,527 posts

282 months

Friday 18th October 2013
quotequote all
45-50k in today's market isn't to be sneezed at, also the idea of a contract agreed by both parties that pays out in X years if business sells for X pounds seems extremely reasonable

TurricanII

1,516 posts

229 months

Sunday 20th October 2013
quotequote all
Don't forget cash in the bank.if there is 20k in the bank at the time of sale then I would want half of that..

singlecoil

35,897 posts

277 months

Sunday 20th October 2013
quotequote all
I would suggest avoiding arrangements which promise money in the future, especially if there is any way at all in which the other party can manipulate the figures.

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Sunday 20th October 2013
quotequote all
Aerate said:
Are you talking total value of the business or value of her half? Where would these values have got the £160k figure?
Half!

As noted elsewhere. If there is excess working capital then I would be adding half if that as well.

David

eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
I would suggest avoiding arrangements which promise money in the future, especially if there is any way at all in which the other party can manipulate the figures.
Plus you become an unsecured creditor - if the company goes bust, you loose your money.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
singlecoil said:
I would suggest avoiding arrangements which promise money in the future, especially if there is any way at all in which the other party can manipulate the figures.
Obviously this is a danger, but the future payment is only linked to a future sale (referred to as an 'anti-embarrassment provision') and is designed to help avoid a situation whereby you sell at a low price and the next day the new owner sells at an inflated (and therefore more realistic valuation). Clearly there is always the danger of manipulation - if the provision lasts a year then he can wait for day 366 to sell, and so on - but generally speaking these clauses do as they are supposed to. It sounds like it would be worth having a clause in the agreement, but to treat anything you may get out of it as a bonus.

Not sure how his accountant got to £160k, but a useful tool to remind him that he's getting a very good deal from your wife. ;-)

If I were you I'd be getting his lawyer to draft a suitable agreement (and him paying for it) and then finding a lawyer to do a very quick review of it, rather than both sides paying for full legal costs. You shouldn't be offering any warranties other than title to the shares - the other party already knows the business inside out. £15-20k doesn't really warrant spending lots of money on it if you can get cash on signature.