Small Claims, winning and stupid offers
Small Claims, winning and stupid offers
Author
Discussion

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
I am in the final stages of putting together my side of a small claims case that I am making against a shoddy tradesman that did some work on my house. I think I in a pretty good position as I believe I handled it well, photo-documented everything and have told the whole story in detail. I have been through this bit of small claims before, but it was settled out of court by the Defendant for practically the whole amount just prior to the hearing so i don't have any experience of the actual hearing part, or winning.

Does anyone have any tips, and particularly I'd like to know how to handle it if indeed I win, and the Defendant makes a stupid offer of £5 a month for 25 years or something. Is there any way to refuse this without it being frowned upon by the judge, is there any negotiation over it, what can i prep in advance to ensure I have the ability to refuse that type of thing, if at all possible etc?

thanks

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Unless my client has given me clear guidelines on what they will accept by way of instalments then I push for:

1. Judgment payable forthwith or no later than 14 days from the date of the hearing.

2. Any offers made at court cannot be accepted unless the defendant has proper (i.e. backed with bank statements etc) evidence of their financial position and even then only if the instalments are reasonable given the nature of the debt.

3. Any instalment order would prejudice the claimant's right to use other enforcement methods.

And depending on the facts of the case:

3. If you've already had to pay to make good the shoddy work, or need to pay to rectify the shoddy work, then it is unjust for you to be kept waiting to be reimbursed.

4. This judgment debt is a debt which has arisen in the course of the defendant's business, as a business debt it should be payable immediately or the business is trading in a state of insolvency - there's obviously been several months notice of the hearing which would give the defendant time to make provision for losing.

5. In the case of trivial offers (e.g. £1 per month for a debt of £xK) where the defendant is an individual and not a firm I cite the case of Alliance & Leicester v Slayford which states an order cannot be made for payment over a period of time which exceeds the debtor's life or any other unreasonable period (however unreasonable is dependant on the facts of each case).

Hope that gives you some ideas.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
very useful indeed thanks! I guess as it's small claims, he won't have a solicitor and i don't believe he has insurance (i know, you live and learn in sourcing these guys) so there will be no-one pushing reason and fairness in his 'camp'. I will make a note of those things though as I am sure it will be useful in the eventuality that it comes up in the hearing and i need to say the right things with no notice.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Blown2CV said:
very useful indeed thanks! I guess as it's small claims, he won't have a solicitor and i don't believe he has insurance (i know, you live and learn in sourcing these guys) so there will be no-one pushing reason and fairness in his 'camp'. I will make a note of those things though as I am sure it will be useful in the eventuality that it comes up in the hearing and i need to say the right things with no notice.
What I would say is don't take anything for granted in your case prep, and if you do receive evidence from the defendant make sure you go through it all thoroughly to check there's nothing that will surprise you on the day.

If there's been no inkling of a solicitor so far that doesn't mean that he doesn't have legal expenses insurance which he might not yet have claimed on, that may provide representation on the day.

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
5. In the case of trivial offers (e.g. £1 per month for a debt of £xK) where the defendant is an individual and not a firm I cite the case of Alliance & Leicester v Slayford which states an order cannot be made for payment over a period of time which exceeds the debtor's life or any other unreasonable period (however unreasonable is dependant on the facts of each case).
Very interesting - what if the amount was for a substantial sum (say £50k) the OP was claiming for & the defendant said (and could prove with statements etc) he couldn't pay that amount?

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
northwest monkey said:
Very interesting - what if the amount was for a substantial sum (say £50k) the OP was claiming for & the defendant said (and could prove with statements etc) he couldn't pay that amount?
Then in that case the court should enter judgment payable in 14 days (the normal time), this then leaves the claimant free to pursue other enforcement methods, which could be (for example) sending in High Court Enforcement Officers to confiscate goods, or to secure the debt on any property owned by the defendant which would then possibly lead to an application for a forced sale of that property. Insolvency proceedings are another option, the threat often produces cash which otherwise would not be admitted to.

What frequently happens is that a Judge will enter a judgment which doesn't allow instalments, then once the thumbscrews are applied a defendant will apply to have the judgment varied to allow payment by instalments. The same arguments against instalments can then be used at that stage.


Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
What frequently happens is that a Judge will enter a judgment which doesn't allow instalments, then once the thumbscrews are applied a defendant will apply to have the judgment varied to allow payment by instalments. The same arguments against instalments can then be used at that stage.
This is my experience. The judge finds in your favour and tells the defendant how much to pay and when by - mine was '14 days' as well (though it was clear the defendant was not poor). I got costs, travel and car-parking too, though I understand this is not usual.

If your defendant then tries playing silly buggers you're into a whole new arena, eg people's cars get towed away to be sold.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
the amount claimed is of the order of £2k. Small claims has a threshold anyway, and IIRC it's around £10k. So, for anything above that there would be solicitors etc and it wouldn't be for me to have to worry about the detail.

Fab32

381 posts

164 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
We took Royal Mail to the small claims court in 2011 and they sent a barrister. He came to speak with us before and was very nice said he was sorry the case had got this for but we should discuss the issues in front of the judge.

I felt he was feeling us out so said very little, turns out I was right. I put our case forward in a straightforward manner and he set out all manner of case law and spoke in what can only be described as Latin at points, he spoke so fast he lost me and I had to ask him for clarification a number of times as I didn’t understand his use of language and felt I couldn’t answer his questions.

The judge hammered him for refusing to mitigate beforehand and for deliberately being difficult in his phrasing of questions. We were awarded the amount in full, afterwards he came to speak to us but I invited him to foxtrot Oscar. Perhaps it was a little petty but I have always thought the moral high ground is overrated!

If I was to offer advise it would be the following;

Be clear in your mind of the facts but listen to the questions you are asked and answer honestly it’s the judges job to fit your answer into the relevant law.

Do all your thinking and preparation before you arrive, we arrived early for a bit of thinking/preparation time but felt pushed into starting early by the clerk.

Don’t be goaded by the other side, I got the distinct impression it was sport for him the money at stake made no difference to him and he had probably stayed over the night before, almost a jolly perhaps. The money to us was huge at the time as was the investment of time trying to get it back.

Good luck

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
yep small claims is intended to be a layman's type scenario (as much as can be) so i am not surprised the judge tore strips off the RM's lawyer for that behaviour. I'm also certain that a fair amount of niceties are built into what a barrister claims as expenses etc, hence their fees being so large.

khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
I just took Orange/EE to court after being with them for 20 years - the whole process took a good 9 months of bull and no-shows on the Mediation option - the big day was last monday and we won our case - full judgement for £2,000 - cheers!!!

During the 9 months they . . . bamboosled me with paperwork and "so-called" evidence, offered NOTHING, then offered £600 incl costs to settle, then failed to turn up at the first mediation appointment - the mediator was a total waste of space at the second go, telling me to settle as "thats what mediation is all about" - the judge, on the other hand was absolutely awesome!!

TBH - I really just wanted my day in court - wasn't bothered about the £££ - I wanted to cause maximum disruption to them - they had fked my about BIG TIME last decemeber and I was very very very angry - this is a good result for the little guy - I am delighted.

Wings

5,975 posts

246 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
khushy said:
I just took Orange/EE to court after being with them for 20 years - the whole process took a good 9 months of bull and no-shows on the Mediation option - the big day was last monday and we won our case - full judgement for £2,000 - cheers!!!

During the 9 months they . . . bamboosled me with paperwork and "so-called" evidence, offered NOTHING, then offered £600 incl costs to settle, then failed to turn up at the first mediation appointment - the mediator was a total waste of space at the second go, telling me to settle as "thats what mediation is all about" - the judge, on the other hand was absolutely awesome!!

TBH - I really just wanted my day in court - wasn't bothered about the £££ - I wanted to cause maximum disruption to them - they had fked my about BIG TIME last decemeber and I was very very very angry - this is a good result for the little guy - I am delighted.
^^^I had a similar experience to the above. My first experience was through a builder issuing legal proceedings against me for an unpaid bill, with my solicitor advising on mediation. The mediator turned out as the above, a waste of space, going 50-50 on the claim against me, so taking out the mediator's fee, and the solicitors fees, both myself and the builder would have been better just settling his bill 50-50.

The most recent experience was of a neighbour of a rental property property i own starting legal proceedings against me. I got the impression from the court papers, that the court frowned against cases coming to court, where the parties concerned had not first attempted mediation. So just prior to the court hearing, i made an offer to settle the claim, and to my surprise it was accepted.







Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
just completed my 74 page bundle!

Wings

5,975 posts

246 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Blown2CV said:
just completed my 74 page bundle!
Did you triplicate your documents, I usually provide one set for the court, the other set for the appellant/defendant and one set of documents for myself.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Wings said:
Blown2CV said:
just completed my 74 page bundle!
Did you triplicate your documents, I usually provide one set for the court, the other set for the appellant/defendant and one set of documents for myself.
yep 3 copies of that. You need to anyway, if the court and the opponent don't receive a copy by a certain date ahead of the hearing then you can't use them in the hearing itself.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
74 page bundle on a £2k dispute.

That's good going for a small claim.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

31,662 posts

234 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
johnfm said:
74 page bundle on a £2k dispute.

That's good going for a small claim.
Undiagnosed OCD and an overbearing desire to facilitate justice!

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Blown2CV said:
johnfm said:
74 page bundle on a £2k dispute.

That's good going for a small claim.
Undiagnosed OCD and an overbearing desire to facilitate justice!
Fair enough - I have no experience of small claims that proceed to court. The mediation service is not very good (their drafting of a settlement agreement was laughable. You could drive a truck through it!)

Simpo Two

93,099 posts

296 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
You're doing the right thing. You don't know what the defendant is going to throw at you so be 100% prepared and cover every angle you can think of. He will be as desperate to win as you are. You don't want to lose on some tiny point you hadn't thought of, or didn't have an answer for, or fall foul of procedure somehow.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Andy_GSA said:
which would then possibly lead to an application for a forced sale of that property.
Andy is this correct?
I did this on a debtor a few years ago and was advised that if it is someone's home you cannot force the sale of it?