Advice on sacking an employee.
Advice on sacking an employee.
Author
Discussion

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Hi,
Little bit of history first..
He has been employed by me since May 2012 on a full time roll. Around September last year he went 'AWOL' due to him splitting up with his misses. (He didn't turn up for work on Friday and didn't ring me until Sunday and ended up having the whole week off)
I gave him a verbal warning for this and expressed my concerns.

A few months ago he didn't turn up for work again and after many missed calls his misses rings me to tell me he has had a bad stomach and been throwing up all night etc.

Today is the same thing, first job booked in for half 8, customer rings me at 9:15 to ask where he is. Obviously I am concerned so ring him only to get his voicemail (work and personal). Rang his house phone and spoke to his mum, she told me he stayed out last night... Again after many missed calls etc his misses rings me to tell me he has a really bad stomach and a bad migraine.
I checked on find my iphone and his phone was at his misses and was on charge but she told me he had left his phone at his house??

Anyway, obviously this is unacceptable and I've got to the point where I feel if I keep him on, he will feel like he can do what he wants.
What I want to know is, I know I need to have a meeting with him and then review it and go from there but what actions can I take whilst doing the right thing?

Hopefully this makes sense, just unsure what to do..

Thanks.

Terminator X

21,038 posts

235 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Verbal warning (meeting + note issued), written warning (meeting + note issued) x 2 then out the door imho, you can only do so much. This is the procedure we followed when I worked for a global company with 2500 employees. In this day and age it's hard to get shot of people even if they are ste.

Can't recall when the new employment laws kicked in albeit if the chap had started recently you'd be able to get shot of him for almost any reason within the first 24 months (up from 12). Benefit of hindsight you left it too long, should have pulled the trigger within 12 months.

TX.

Edit - checking phone location thing is a tad OTT?!

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
You're in a strong position because he just falls into the 2 year bracket for unfair dismissal.

I'd still go by the book - have a look at acas guidence for performance review.

Invite him with 24 hours notice to a performance review noting that a decision will be made after the meeting as to his continued employment.

Raise your concerns about his performance and listen to what he has to say in the meeting. Adjourn and take time to make the decision.

Reconvene and dismiss with 7 days pay in lieu of notice (or whatever his contract says) if you see fit.


rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Yep you're right but at the time i couldn't afford to get rid of him as we were so busy and he was 50% of my business in reality.

jules_s

5,297 posts

264 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Playing devils advocate

He's been sick two days in a few months?

Sounds like he needs to man up and ring in himself though

Agreed iPhone location is OTT; if my boss did that I wouldn't be happy at all

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
I check it to see where he is. If he wasn't answering his phone, I wanted to know where he is. I wanted to be able to say to the customer that he must be driving but he is on his way.

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
If I remember correctly, you have to give permission to someone to access your location. If he's not happy with that situation he can revoke that access.

He could also go to work and not get his missus to call in sick for him, the sniveling stbag.

OP there's tons of people out of work who would be grateful for the opportunity. Get rid and get some new blood in.

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
On the info I have posted, what would the grounds of dismissal come under? Or even the written warning really!

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Repeated absence without informing his employer. Assuming his t&cs state that he must call in the morning he is ill or as soon as reasonably practicable. Getting his missus to call later in the day when he's got a dickie stomach is not acceptable and doesn't give the business an opportunity to put plans in place to deal with his absence.

General suitability. You sound like a small business and need someone you can rely on, he doesn't sound like that guy.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Final written warning IMO. Make it very clear what is expected in terms of absence, and that if he doesn't meet with it again he's binned. If he's inside the 2 years, bin him now if you're that annoyed.

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Still haven't heard from him and he has turned his work phone off. Surely he isn't expecting to turn up for work on monday like nothing has happened?

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
What's the rule for reporting sickness?

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Submission of a medical certificate or sickness self-certification absence form, although giving us the reason for your absence, may not always be regarded by us as sufficient justification for accepting your absence. Sickness is just one of a number of reasons for absence and although it is understandable that if you are sick you may need time off, continual or repeated absence through sickness may not be acceptable to us.

2. In deciding whether your absence is acceptable or not we will take into account the reasons and extent of all your absences, including any absence caused by sickness/injury. We cannot operate with an excessive level of absence as all absence, for whatever reason, reduces our efficiency.

3. We will take a serious view if you take sickness/injury leave which is not genuine, and it will result in disciplinary action being taken.

4. If we consider it necessary, we may ask your permission to contact your doctor and/or for you to be independently medically examined.

NOTIFICATION OF INCAPACITY FOR WORK

1. You must notify us by telephone on the first day of incapacity at the earliest possible opportunity and by no later than 10.00am. Other than in exceptional circumstances notification should be made personally, to your manager. You should try to give some indication of your expected return date and notify us as soon as possible if this date changes.

2. If your incapacity extends to more than seven days you are required to notify us of your continued incapacity once a week thereafter, unless otherwise agreed.

B) EVIDENCE OF INCAPACITY

1. Doctors’ certificates are not issued for short-term incapacity. In these cases of incapacity (up to and including seven calendar days) you must sign a self-certification absence form on your return to work.

2. If your sickness has been (or you know that it will be) for longer than seven days (whether or not they are working days) you should see your doctor and make sure he/she gives you a medical certificate and forward this to us without delay. Subsequently you must supply us with consecutive doctors’ medical certificates to cover the whole of your absence.

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
That's clear. Although missing a need to call in every day of sickness until a dr's cert is obtained. I stand by my original comment, invite to performance review and consider his responses. Based on what you've said, I'd be getting shot of him.

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Ok, thanks for the advice everybody.

xaby82

87 posts

171 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
To keep everything above board you need to give him (in writing) 24 hours notice to an INVESTIGATION meeting. You also need to give him the option to bring a third party if he so chooses.

You should also bring a third party yourself to minute the meeting. Make sure you inform him from the off that his job is at risk. When it's all done tell him you will take 24 hours to make a decision and again inform him in writing of what was said at the meeting.

Then finally invite him back for a DISCIPLINARY meeting (again with third parties etc.) where you will inform him of the outcome. Again, everything backed up in writing.

Not sure on the size of your company but if you want to be extra watertight. You could get a subordinate to carry out the investigation and you do the final disciplinary or vice versa. This way the other party is neutral to the situation.

Burrito

1,705 posts

251 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
xaby82 said:
To keep everything above board you need to give him (in writing) 24 hours notice to an INVESTIGATION meeting. You also need to give him the option to bring a third party if he so chooses.

You should also bring a third party yourself to minute the meeting. Make sure you inform him from the off that his job is at risk. When it's all done tell him you will take 24 hours to make a decision and again inform him in writing of what was said at the meeting.

Then finally invite him back for a DISCIPLINARY meeting (again with third parties etc.) where you will inform him of the outcome. Again, everything backed up in writing.

Not sure on the size of your company but if you want to be extra watertight. You could get a subordinate to carry out the investigation and you do the final disciplinary or vice versa. This way the other party is neutral to the situation.
I agree you should give him notice of the meeting of at least 24 hours and allow him to bring a colleague or union rep, but I would go with a "performance review" rather than a disciplinary hearing. I differentiate the two because the employee is within the 24 month period where unfair dismissal can be brought so there is a reduced requirement (from my POV) to go through the full disciplinary procedure - where your time could be better spent elsewhere.

I also disagree on a requirement of 24 hours to make the decision. If it's clear that his performance is short of what is expected without good reason and no additional investigation is required, you could come back after 15 minutes.

The full procedure is available from ACAS: http://www.acas.org.uk/media/pdf/k/b/Acas_Code_of_...

One small point. Does your employee fall into a category who may being a discrimination case against you? If so, you would be better following the ACAS regs exactly.

IANAL and the above is based on my experience as a manager.

rich12

Original Poster:

3,468 posts

185 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Nothing to note on the discrimination front..
He has just rung me now, saying he owed me an apology blah blah blah, then proceeded to go on about how he had lost his voice, been throwing up etc (obviously it may be true) also asked me if his misses had rung me as he wasn't sure.
I asked him if he would be turning up for work on Monday, his response was 'hopefully, aslong as I feel better'.

Told him I would like to have a chat with him about it on Monday and his first reply was 'Am I getting the sack?'


khushy

3,984 posts

250 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
unless YOU follow the correct grievance procedure - YOU dont have a leg to stand on - no matter what he has/hasn't done, and no matter how long he has been employed!

if you sack him and he takes you to a tribunal (which he probably will) YOU WILL BE SCREWED!!!

Take some proper advice - follow procedure - get rid - re-employ - learn - move on!

khushy

Birkin1932

791 posts

170 months

Saturday 2nd November 2013
quotequote all
Khushy, that's not correct. The guy was employed after 6th of April 2012. He needs two years employment to qualify for a tribunal.

I wouldn't be getting yourself work up about it. Just sack him.

https://www.gov.uk/dismissal/what-to-do-if-youre-d...

He hasn't got a leg to stand on and can complain to nobody, unless you have dismissed him for being a socialist