another hate my business partner post!
another hate my business partner post!
Author
Discussion

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Changed my name as I`m sure he`s on here too!

Started a company (A) approx 18mths ago with 2 business partners. There is a 34/33/33 share in my favour.

One of the partners is like me. Wants to work 100%, comes up with ideas, monitors the direction of the company with spending/advertising/ planing/ staff management/development, you know, everything a Director is meant to do.
The other t**t rolls in when he wants, disappears for hrs on end with phone turned off, lies about where he`s been, is out of the door at 5:00 when the other 2 stay they till 7 then work till 11pm+ at home. He thinks that because he is the one who put the most money in, he is the one who`s risked the most and is his own boss so can work as he chooses! (yes I know this doesn`t make sense but follow me).

I run my other company (B) successfully with £100k net profit this year. Due to me putting 100% effort into company A my company B is suffering. I honestly think I could of made £200k this year on company B.

Company A is running at a loss but I believe with time and effort it will be a successful company, I`m not one to quit and know with the commitment, I and the other director has, we can make a success in a year or 2.

The other director, lets call him Director T**t in this case, is moaning that the company is running at a loss and says whats the point on making an effort anyway and is clearly not motivated, even though he bank rolled the venture.

I have brought the idea,experience,business knowledge and time and effort/hrs to the table when he hasn`t got any experience and wanted to leverage me and give up the day job.

I`m at my wits end now as I cannot work with someone who doesn`t give a f**k!

I have the majority share and my other partner is backing me, how do I go about getting rid of Director t**t?

There`s approx 2/5 left of the initial investment of which I put in 1/5. Do I offer to give him what`s left and I could easily bank roll the rest until it profits, or wind it down, which I don`t really want to do as I`m not a quitter?! I don`t think he`d accept an low offer as he thinks he`ll be out of pocket. I think he`d rather see us all go under than accept a pay off of less than 100% he put in.

All advice will be appreciated but please guys don`t start with the morals as I`m pissed off for making this mistake in the first place! Yes I now know a partnership is a sinking ship!
I just want to resolve this and get on with my businesses.


paulrussell

2,311 posts

192 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Why don't you and the other director offer to pay him all of his money back to get him to leave the company?

evo4a

737 posts

212 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Do you have directors meetings to discuss work loads etc

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
evo4a said:
Do you have directors meetings to discuss work loads etc
Every week! It goes in one ear and out of the other!

I`ve told him it`s not fair and my family hardly ever see me! It`s falling on deaf ears.

I`m seriously thinking about what Paul said above. However, why should we carry 100% of his loss due to him being a lazy t**t!

TallPaul

1,524 posts

289 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
head done in said:
I`m seriously thinking about what Paul said above. However, why should we carry 100% of his loss due to him being a lazy t**t!
Because you either sink with him or swim without him!

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
If you have a shareholder's agreement then consult that.

If not then you would be able to depose them as a Director but not as a shareholder. If you want them out as a shareholder then you need to negotiate with them and agree, there is no way of forcing them out.

paulrussell

2,311 posts

192 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
head done in said:
However, why should we carry 100% of his loss due to him being a lazy t**t!
Just to get rid of him. Playing devil's advocate here, might he want the business to go under, so he can start up a new company, and do whatever company A do whilst taking all the ideas you and the other director have come up with instantly making profit with little risk and less work?

Chimune

4,377 posts

254 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
TallPaul said:
head done in said:
I`m seriously thinking about what Paul said above. However, why should we carry 100% of his loss due to him being a lazy t**t!
Because you either sink with him or swim without him!
and in another 18 months you can repost here saying it was painful, meant even more work, but ultimately the right decision.

you can also tell us who you are - and who he is laugh

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
Siscar said:
If you have a shareholder's agreement then consult that.

If not then you would be able to depose them as a Director but not as a shareholder. If you want them out as a shareholder then you need to negotiate with them and agree, there is no way of forcing them out.
nail. head. hit.

at the end of the day all shareholder disputes come down to money - how much will it cost to get rid of him? us lawyers will always be hapy to take your money, but it might be better spent coming to some sort of agreement.

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
paulrussell said:
Just to get rid of him. Playing devil's advocate here, might he want the business to go under, so he can start up a new company, and do whatever company A do whilst taking all the ideas you and the other director have come up with instantly making profit with little risk and less work?
Paul, no chance, he hasn`t got the nouse nor the balls!

Simon, think you are right as I know with my determination,commitment and financial backing I WILL turn this around.
That Muppet needs to go back to a day job and regret his opportunity in a few years time!

paulrussell

2,311 posts

192 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
head done in said:
paulrussell said:
Just to get rid of him. Playing devil's advocate here, might he want the business to go under, so he can start up a new company, and do whatever company A do whilst taking all the ideas you and the other director have come up with instantly making profit with little risk and less work?
Paul, no chance, he hasn`t got the nouse nor the balls!

That Muppet needs to go back to a day job and regret his opportunity in a few years time!
That's good for you and the other director. Could you put some of company B's profit into buying the director off?

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
paulrussell said:
That's good for you and the other director. Could you put some of company B's profit into buying the director off?
Yes that was my thought`s. I`m sure I`ll have to pay tax on the transfer, unless it`s accounted as a loan, say repayment over 3yrs (or is it a 9mth max term??). I`m sure Eric will be along to correct me.

Either way even if I pay the prick back 100% of his investment, I know I`ll be able to move the company on in the direction it needs to go and not listen to moaning about the cost of paper clips!

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
A close friend of mine went 50/50 on a business venture and things were going really well until the other guy started doing what you describe and swanning in late, clearing off at 4:59 each day, taking random days of to go fishing, ignoring phone calls, sitting about in his 'executive leather office chair instead of actually doing hands on work... you name it.

His excuse was, as you found out: "we are company directors, we are the bosses, we can come and go as we please"... laughable as there was only the two of them plus 2 guys working there, it wasn't like it was a huge company with loads of middle managers.

My mate had it out with him in a meeting and told him he would buy him out... to which other guy said "I'm not leaving! We are making good money here!"

unbelievable...

So my mate just left and watched the firm promptly go bust from a safe distance.

I find it staggering each time I hear someone talking about starting their own company/business and stating that their reasons for doing so is that they can 'be a boss' and just take it easy while the employees do the work.

Are people really that naive??

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I want to keep the name going due to have links to my other company and local branding. I think it`ll have to be either this or a buy out. It`s less than £100k and I could raise it via a loan from my other company but I`m not going to offer his full investment back for him taking the piss over the last 18mths.

For the experienced on here, would you just value the company in it`s present condition inc funds in account/assets/invoices due in for next month, then divide by 3 for his share? Can`t see him accepting this though.

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
If he's as much of an a**e as you say then make sure the 1st offer is a low ball one, so when he manages to negotiate you up he thinks he's getting a good deal.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
head done in said:
I want to keep the name going due to have links to my other company and local branding. I think it`ll have to be either this or a buy out. It`s less than £100k and I could raise it via a loan from my other company but I`m not going to offer his full investment back for him taking the piss over the last 18mths.

For the experienced on here, would you just value the company in it`s present condition inc funds in account/assets/invoices due in for next month, then divide by 3 for his share? Can`t see him accepting this though.
That may be a good way of explaining a valuation to him but at the end of the day it's all about what you can persuade him to take, that could be anything.

897sma

3,607 posts

175 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Offer him cash to go at whatever you feel is fair and reasonable based on the value of the business, bad feeling or disappointment in his effort should not come into it. If he doesn't accept, just close the business. You don't need his permission if the other two shareholders make the decision and providing you aren't writing off any debt then you won't need to use a liquidator.

Providing there aren't any non-competition clauses in your shareholder agreement then you could start again the day after it closes - not whilst you are trading though as this could be in breach of your responsibilities as a director with the existing company.

Keeping the existing name with the newco won't be an issue either as ABC Ltd or as XYZ Ltd T/as ABC, unless one of you owns the IP/trademark/etc.

Dick Dastardly

8,326 posts

294 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
I'd seek legal advice before closing it down and starting again using the same identity. He could accuse you of asset stripping, which AFAIK can get you into hot water.

fellatthefirst

622 posts

186 months

Friday 8th November 2013
quotequote all
Same thing happened to me, there was 3 of us at the start and after a couple of months it was clear that person 3 was not working on the same level and myself and other person. We sat him down and said we don't want to go forward with him and offered him an amount to go. It was a very decent amount really, more than what he put in, but he agreed and left.

Best thing we ever did! 5 years on we are making very good money and the amount we gave him seems like peanuts now.

You mentioned you already have 1 company which is profitable and this company B is making a loss. I made our guy an offer because it was our only company and we had to proceed with it. Are you not in a position to close down company B and start it up again with your other director? This would mean the t**t gets nothing?

If this is not possible just sit the t**t down and offer him an amount to go. If it's making a loss though i wouldn't offer too much. Make it clear to him it's either take the offer and go or you'll end up going bust and he'll get nothing.

Try not to go to a solicitor you will just end up paying out fortunes in bills and still getting no where. It's always best to try and sort it out as amicably as possible.

head done in

Original Poster:

86 posts

156 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
coyft said:
head done in said:
I run my other company (B) successfully with £100k net profit this year. Due to me putting 100% effort into company A my company B is suffering. I honestly think I could of made £200k this year on company B.



Why not ditch company (A) and concentrate on company (B)?
Tempted but I probably won`t because I believe both will eventually be successful as the other and it`ll increase my streams of income. When he goes I`ll replace him with someone competent and spend more time on my other company whilst overlooking this one.

Been some good advice on here. Thanks guys. :-)