Book shops - doomed?
Book shops - doomed?
Author
Discussion

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
The internet came and transformed markets. For example Blockbusters who cannot maintain a shop based organisation and are looking at going bump, again.

One retailer who looked doomed by the likes of Amazon was Argos. They've very sucessfuly transformed themselves into an online retailer with a physical presence, and use it as one of their strengths.

Amazon have launched a US offering, giving book independents a small percentage of kindle store purchases - but only for two years. I think even the most desperate retailer would be able to see this as a little short-sighted to sign up to.

Ebook ownership is increasing.

So what's going to happen to book shops? There will no doubt be space for a few specialists, but the others are going to have to change as their market disappears.

It's going to be an interesting ride?

Also - what industry is next?

stuartmmcfc

8,775 posts

223 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
I was in Waterstones this afternoon and it was packed. They make it more appealing by having beanbags to sit on and relax and even a coffee shop, something you don't get on the net!

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
That works for now, as it brings in people who will buy paper books. But what happens when people stop buying paper books and start buying ebooks in greater percentage?

Turn themselves into a coffee shop with WiFi?

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
That works for now, as it brings in people who will buy paper books. But what happens when people stop buying paper books and start buying ebooks in greater percentage?

Turn themselves into a coffee shop with WiFi?
There's no guarantee though. A close analogue (if you'll pardon the pun) is vinyl records. Here's a graph of sales (US, but the UK market will be similar.



It's now wholly conceivable that vinyl sales will overtake CDs within the next decade or so.

That makes no sense from almost every point of view. Records are a right faff, can't be fast forwarded, can't be played in a car, and break easily.

But it turns out that the buyers of vinyl are young people rather than old people, and they're buying it because it's a physical artifact. It makes the artwork more real to have a physical connection to it rather than just some 0s and 1s.

While I agree that the mass market will almost certainly fall to digital distribution, we will still see analogue books for what might be referred to as the "quality" end of the market; for example, there will always be a need for seventeen year olds to be able to own a physical copy of Catcher in the Rye to mark them out as serious and brooding. wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
That works for now, as it brings in people who will buy paper books. But what happens when people stop buying paper books and start buying ebooks in greater percentage?

Turn themselves into a coffee shop with WiFi?
This is a decent place with a joint 2nd hand bookshop attached a good place to sirens half a day.
http://didsburyvillagebookshop.co.uk

As for Argos they need to buck up or get kicked, I wandered in out of boredom last week and just the big old catalogues still not a mix of catologues and tablets,
I thought they were going to address this basic issue talking to one of their staff earlier this year frown

Simpo Two

93,111 posts

296 months

Saturday 9th November 2013
quotequote all
Do you mean 'What is going to happen to book shops?' or 'What is going to happen to books?'?

I like the tactility of books. I'm happy to buy them from Amazon etc but will never own a Kindle or an e-book. It's like a protein pill without the food.

Webber3

1,228 posts

250 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
For someone that spends most of their life in front of a computer screen in one form or other, books are a welcome respite.

Sure you can get just about anything as an ebook, but I've never wanted to download books onto my iPad. Getting away from the screens and reading a physical book is far more appealing.

surveyor

Original Poster:

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
speedyguy said:
surveyor said:
That works for now, as it brings in people who will buy paper books. But what happens when people stop buying paper books and start buying ebooks in greater percentage?

Turn themselves into a coffee shop with WiFi?
This is a decent place with a joint 2nd hand bookshop attached a good place to sirens half a day.
http://didsburyvillagebookshop.co.uk

As for Argos they need to buck up or get kicked, I wandered in out of boredom last week and just the big old catalogues still not a mix of catologues and tablets,
I thought they were going to address this basic issue talking to one of their staff earlier this year frown
Not sure what the problem is with the traditional catalogs in the store...they work well, and actually to choose something from a wide variety on the web, with a local store to pickup in an hour they have no competition at all.

Simpo Two said:
Do you mean 'What is going to happen to book shops?' or 'What is going to happen to books?'?

I like the tactility of books. I'm happy to buy them from Amazon etc but will never own a Kindle or an e-book. It's like a protein pill without the food.
Popularity is rising, books will become in time like records, a specialist format.

Webber3 said:
For someone that spends most of their life in front of a computer screen in one form or other, books are a welcome respite.

Sure you can get just about anything as an ebook, but I've never wanted to download books onto my iPad. Getting away from the screens and reading a physical book is far more appealing.
As above. To a degree I agree, but books are heavy, and space consuming where as a kindle/ipad are far more effective.

smifffymoto

5,186 posts

236 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
Book shops will survive.There are many of us whom bought a Kindle and it just frustrates us.Touch the page accidently and you lose the page,bad light and it's near to useless(not the new one).
Books have a certain feel,bending the corners of the page,bend the spine so you can read one handed easily.I do think shops will have to become something else,not just a seller of books,find a new niche so as to compete with online sellers.

Frik

13,695 posts

274 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Webber3 said:
For someone that spends most of their life in front of a computer screen in one form or other, books are a welcome respite.

Sure you can get just about anything as an ebook, but I've never wanted to download books onto my iPad. Getting away from the screens and reading a physical book is far more appealing.
As above. To a degree I agree, but books are heavy, and space consuming where as a kindle/ipad are far more effective.
To be fair, there's a vast difference between reading on a Kindle and on an iPad. I imagine in the future the nature of the screens will improve but at the moment the Kindle is only in danger of replacing the paperback. Non-fiction books in all different sizes with images are much harder to replicate electronically.

Funk

27,820 posts

240 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
I think a lot of people like re idea of owning rather than renting. I still buy CDs and rip them myself rather than 'rent' the right to listen to a digital version. I detest anything that requires me to have to verify it online - what happens if (when?) that business goes bust? No more music or games for you, sir. Amazon also have a track record of arbitrarily removing stuff people have purchased from their devices without warning.

Physical media for me, thanks. I own it, it'll work without the nod from some server online somewhere. Think how many music services have fallen by the wayside over the years...

I buy books too, but I also acquire them digitally via other means and read on my phone or tablet from time to time, the same as I do with music. No way I'd pay the same for an ebook as I am for a real book!

Vince70

1,944 posts

225 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
I guess the same will happen to bookshops as happened to printing company's.

There were always a few printing company's on the out of town industrial estates all over the country doing small run magazine work and have now all but disappeared even the biggest company which was St Ives multimedia has now gone I don't know anyone who I worked with 10 years ago who is still a printer.

Most printing factory's have been turned into fast fit exhaust centres or tops tiles stores or are just boarded up.

The only difference with a book shop is its in a high street so it will be turned into a Tesco Extra instead, so if you want a book it will be the charity shop or buy second hand from eBay or ironically Amazon.

Chrisgr31

14,299 posts

286 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
speedyguy said:
This is a decent place with a joint 2nd hand bookshop attached a good place to sirens half a day.
http://didsburyvillagebookshop.co.uk

As for Argos they need to buck up or get kicked, I wandered in out of boredom last week and just the big old catalogues still not a mix of catologues and tablets,
I thought they were going to address this basic issue talking to one of their staff earlier this year frown
Why would Argos have tablets in their shops? They would walk out the door within minutes!

I was in Argos last weekend and they had the paper catologue and a touch screen version. So you could search the catologue onscreen and then check availability. Interestingly though the itm I wanted the system said they had 8 in stock. I went to the counter to pay as I had a gift card to exchange and despite their being no queue they said they had none in stock. So I asked about nearby stores (was in Tunbridge Wells Retail Park) and they said the nearest store with one in stock was East Grinstead as none in their T Wells town centre store. So went to McDs, and went online, looked it up again, and checked the T Wells Town Centre store, it was in stock so I reserved it and went and picked it up. I should have checked what the retail store said online and tried to reserve but thought I'd look stupid if they really didnt have it!

The problem with the onscreen catolgue is you can't just flick through it. So at Christmas etc when I am looking for ideas for presents I like just flicking through the Catalogue for ideas, you cant do that on a screen!

Hoofy

80,188 posts

313 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Do you mean 'What is going to happen to book shops?' or 'What is going to happen to books?'?

I like the tactility of books. I'm happy to buy them from Amazon etc but will never own a Kindle or an e-book. It's like a protein pill without the food.
Yep. I'll only read something on my smartphone if it's inconvenient to have a book handy. I love books.

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
Vince70 said:
I guess the same will happen to bookshops as happened to printing company's.

There were always a few printing company's on the out of town industrial estates all over the country doing small run magazine work and have now all but disappeared even the biggest company which was St Ives multimedia has now gone I don't know anyone who I worked with 10 years ago who is still a printer.

Most printing factory's have been turned into fast fit exhaust centres or tops tiles stores or are just boarded up.

The only difference with a book shop is its in a high street so it will be turned into a Tesco Extra instead, so if you want a book it will be the charity shop or buy second hand from eBay or ironically Amazon.
Ironically Amazon is probably the biggest printing company in the country. They don't physically stock a lot of books they sell, but print them on demand.

Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
Argos, oddly for a business that seemed doomed until very recently, seems to be moving into what Amazon will have to do eventually.

For an enormous range of goods the high street will become a "poke it, stroke it, try it on and see if it fits" display showroom where they carry a stock of one of everything but you place an order for actual delivery either to your home or to a range of pickup points. Most major cities will have the economics to support same day delivery too, for a fee.

For many manufacturers this will be so advantageous in stock management that they will pay to have their products on display. Think of a TV maker. One of each model in each major town centre, and everything else in controlled warehousing.



jonah35

3,940 posts

188 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
smifffymoto said:
Book shops will survive.There are many of us whom bought a Kindle and it just frustrates us.Touch the page accidently and you lose the page,bad light and it's near to useless(not the new one).
Books have a certain feel,bending the corners of the page,bend the spine so you can read one handed easily.I do think shops will have to become something else,not just a seller of books,find a new niche so as to compete with online sellers.
Eventually you will be able to fold a kindle, bend your ipad and roll it up in your pocket.

fridaypassion

11,458 posts

259 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
specialist bookshops enjoying a renaissance according to radio 4 recently.

Simpo Two

93,111 posts

296 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
jonah35 said:
Eventually you will be able to fold a kindle, bend your ipad and roll it up in your pocket.
Still not a book, sorry.

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
Newc said:
Argos, oddly for a business that seemed doomed until very recently, seems to be moving into what Amazon will have to do eventually.
yes

eBay's recent purchase of Shutl, coupled with their joint venture with Argos means that you will be able to buy certain items on eBay and collect them from your local Argos or have them delivered to your house within a couple of hours.