Business leasing - idiots guide needed!
Discussion
Me and my wife run a Ltd company and claim mileage; this year most of the mileage on the BMW has been for work and we just claim the standard 45p per mile back. 8k miles (ish) this year.
I've been looking at business leasing but my accountant seems incapable of explaining how it works in a way I understand.
Lets take an M135i for example - there are 24 month leases going for around £300pcm (ish) ex VAT (we are VAT registered). How does the BIK tax work (emissions are 177g.km so band E (I think). Do you pay tax annually? What would be the rough cost for say 10k miles a year, 3k of which would be personal mileage?
I know we're all meant to buy a Nissan Leaf if we want a company car but we don't want one...
I've been looking at business leasing but my accountant seems incapable of explaining how it works in a way I understand.
Lets take an M135i for example - there are 24 month leases going for around £300pcm (ish) ex VAT (we are VAT registered). How does the BIK tax work (emissions are 177g.km so band E (I think). Do you pay tax annually? What would be the rough cost for say 10k miles a year, 3k of which would be personal mileage?
I know we're all meant to buy a Nissan Leaf if we want a company car but we don't want one...
The details of the lease arrangements have no bearing on how the tax benefit in kind works.
The benefit in kind is based on the fact that the company is making a car available to one of its directors.
The BIK is calculated based on a percentage value of the official list price of the car (NOT what it actually costs). If accessories are supplied as extras, the list price of those accessories is also included in the BIK calculation.
The BIK itself is valued using a percentage based on the official CO2 rating applicable to that specific model and make of car. The higher the CO2 emission, the higher the percentage rate used with 35% being the maximum.
For a company car, the BIK details are submitted to HMRC using a form called a P46 (Car) within three months of the vehicle being acquired. It is also notified after the end of the tax year in which the vehicle was acquired on a Form P11D. It is an offence to fail to notify HMRC of a BIK and there can be quite hefty fines for submitting an incorrect P11D or no P11D when one was due.
In the modern age, these forms are actually submitted to HMRC electronically.
Once HMRC has the car details in its possessions, they will issue an amended PAYE Notice of Coding for the relevant director. That means that the tax generated by the BIK is collected through the PAYE system, so the individual suffers a greater tax liability on their salary than they otherwise would have.
There are also additional Benefit in Kind taxes to be paid if the employer also provides some or all of the fuel for the car.
The company itself will have an additional National Insurance burden because of the company car. This is an annual charge collected as Class 1A National Insurance and is paid AFTER the end of the relevant tax year.
With the company itself operating the car, the company will be able to claim some Corporation Tax relief on the costs of operating the car. This will include fuel, insurance, repairs etc (if paid for by the company).
The company MAY be entitled to Capital Allowances on the cost of the vehicle. However, this normally only applies if the car has been bought outright by the company or has been acquired using a simple bank loan or an HP agreement.
Capital Allowances on some classes of cars are very poor. They get worse as the CO2 emission level goes up.
If leased, Capital Allowances are usually not available. Instead, of an operational lease, the rental costs are offset against the profits. If a finance lease, the finance charge element of the rental costs is claimed. With a finance lease, the company is allowed to offset the accounting depreciation charge applicable to the vehicle. This is one of the rare occasions where HMRC allows "depreciation" as a tax deductible cost. Normally, it is not allowed but replaced by the appropriate "Capital Allowance" claim.
Sometimes, it takes a fair amount of reading of the "small print" of a finance agreement to work out exactly whether the agreement is an HP, Finance Lease or Operational Lease.
The benefit in kind is based on the fact that the company is making a car available to one of its directors.
The BIK is calculated based on a percentage value of the official list price of the car (NOT what it actually costs). If accessories are supplied as extras, the list price of those accessories is also included in the BIK calculation.
The BIK itself is valued using a percentage based on the official CO2 rating applicable to that specific model and make of car. The higher the CO2 emission, the higher the percentage rate used with 35% being the maximum.
For a company car, the BIK details are submitted to HMRC using a form called a P46 (Car) within three months of the vehicle being acquired. It is also notified after the end of the tax year in which the vehicle was acquired on a Form P11D. It is an offence to fail to notify HMRC of a BIK and there can be quite hefty fines for submitting an incorrect P11D or no P11D when one was due.
In the modern age, these forms are actually submitted to HMRC electronically.
Once HMRC has the car details in its possessions, they will issue an amended PAYE Notice of Coding for the relevant director. That means that the tax generated by the BIK is collected through the PAYE system, so the individual suffers a greater tax liability on their salary than they otherwise would have.
There are also additional Benefit in Kind taxes to be paid if the employer also provides some or all of the fuel for the car.
The company itself will have an additional National Insurance burden because of the company car. This is an annual charge collected as Class 1A National Insurance and is paid AFTER the end of the relevant tax year.
With the company itself operating the car, the company will be able to claim some Corporation Tax relief on the costs of operating the car. This will include fuel, insurance, repairs etc (if paid for by the company).
The company MAY be entitled to Capital Allowances on the cost of the vehicle. However, this normally only applies if the car has been bought outright by the company or has been acquired using a simple bank loan or an HP agreement.
Capital Allowances on some classes of cars are very poor. They get worse as the CO2 emission level goes up.
If leased, Capital Allowances are usually not available. Instead, of an operational lease, the rental costs are offset against the profits. If a finance lease, the finance charge element of the rental costs is claimed. With a finance lease, the company is allowed to offset the accounting depreciation charge applicable to the vehicle. This is one of the rare occasions where HMRC allows "depreciation" as a tax deductible cost. Normally, it is not allowed but replaced by the appropriate "Capital Allowance" claim.
Sometimes, it takes a fair amount of reading of the "small print" of a finance agreement to work out exactly whether the agreement is an HP, Finance Lease or Operational Lease.
Jim909 said:
That is very useful; thanks.Based on the fact we pay ourselves low salaries topped up with dividends, it appears than the BIK amount is around £7k with about £1300 to pay in tax or just over £100 a month (assume this just gets knocked off the payslips?). Dividends are paid completely differently to salaries (paid AFTER you know what your profits are so very variable) so I assume they don't count?!
Any idea on VAT too? Prices are usually quoted ex VAT - can you claim it back?
If it's possible, it looks like it could be £300pcm (ex VAT) from the business then £110pcm (ish) off my own payslip. I may be oversimplifying it, or just being a bit thick but that sounds pretty reasonable to me. Of course I've not factored in non work use - anyone know how this would work out?
Thanks hugely - the above helpful advice shows how flipping complex it is - I guess that's done on purpose?!
I don't understand what you mean by "Dividends don't count".
If your combined Gross Salary, Gross Dividend and Benefit in Kind is high enough, you will pay 40% tax on the part of your total income that exceeds the Higher Rate tax threshold.
Also, I did mention that there is the extra cost the company must bear of the Class 1A NI on the BIK value.
If your combined Gross Salary, Gross Dividend and Benefit in Kind is high enough, you will pay 40% tax on the part of your total income that exceeds the Higher Rate tax threshold.
Also, I did mention that there is the extra cost the company must bear of the Class 1A NI on the BIK value.
Just do a personal lease and claim the miles back.
Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
Broccers said:
Just do a personal lease and claim the miles back.
Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
It does seem a lot simpler but they generally seem to cost more and you're paying from net income. Obviously through the business, even if the prices appear the same, because you're paying from the company, it's a fair bit cheaper.Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
The "same" car is £286pcm (6 +23) + VAT business lease (+ £1300 ish personal BIK tax a year) or £365 (inc VAT) on a personal lease on the same 6+23 payment schedule. That's around £10k for two years.
The other alternative is to wait until they get nearer £20k lightly used (say 1-2 years old), sell the 335d privately (say £10k), shell out £12-15k then keep it for however long we want it for - more flexible, could probably pick up one with a fair few options, etc.
It's a tough one!
Edited by Vladimir on Thursday 14th November 16:39
As Eric correctly states - the company car tax liability you will personally pay for having a company car is calculated on 4 variables:
Tax list price of the car (P11D) Value - this is the full retail price of the car including any fitted options, delivery and VAT
The CO2 emissions on the vehicle
The fuel type (diesel attracts a 3% surcharge)
Your income tax level (20% / 40% / 45%).
Taking the M135i 3dr Automatic as an example with no options:
Tax list price: £32,715
CO2 emissions: 175 g/km, equating to a 27% taxable benefit for the current tax year (this increases with each tax year)
0% surcharge for a petrol engine
Calculating your company car tax from here is simple:
£32,715 x 27% = £8,833.05 - this is your taxable 'benefit in kind' i.e. the amount you'll be taxed on.
If you pay income tax at 20%, you'll pay £8,833.05 x 20% = £1,766.61 per year in company car tax, or £147.22 per month. A 40% taxpayer will pay double this.
Tax list price of the car (P11D) Value - this is the full retail price of the car including any fitted options, delivery and VAT
The CO2 emissions on the vehicle
The fuel type (diesel attracts a 3% surcharge)
Your income tax level (20% / 40% / 45%).
Taking the M135i 3dr Automatic as an example with no options:
Tax list price: £32,715
CO2 emissions: 175 g/km, equating to a 27% taxable benefit for the current tax year (this increases with each tax year)
0% surcharge for a petrol engine
Calculating your company car tax from here is simple:
£32,715 x 27% = £8,833.05 - this is your taxable 'benefit in kind' i.e. the amount you'll be taxed on.
If you pay income tax at 20%, you'll pay £8,833.05 x 20% = £1,766.61 per year in company car tax, or £147.22 per month. A 40% taxpayer will pay double this.
Eric Mc said:
Also, I did mention that there is the extra cost the company must bear of the Class 1A NI on the BIK value.
OP - this needs to be taken into account. If it's your own company you need to look at the costs on both sides - i.e. costs to you through BIK and costs to the company through the increased NI. It's different from just seeing what you can get out of a big organisation's HR department or fleet manager where you may only be bothered about your personal costs.I don't know if you run or need two cars, but you may be better looking at running something tax friendly through the company and a more interesting plaything privately.
Vladimir said:
The "same" car is £286pcm (6 +23) + VAT business lease (+ £1300 ish personal BIK tax a year) or £365 (inc VAT) on a personal lease on the same 6+23 payment schedule. That's around £10k for two years.
The VAT is split between the finance element and the services element (maintenance, management fees etc). You can recover 100% of the VAT on the services piece but only 50% on the finance. Also, for cars over a certain co2 threshold you can only use 85% of the lease against Corp tax.It's quite a complicated area, however, is used to be worse.
Best thing to do is to try and find the oldest coolest car worth less than £15k, I worked out I could have a Lotus 2+2 for a BIK of £150pa. Sadly the two-seaters have gone above £15k.
Broccers said:
Just do a personal lease and claim the miles back.
Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
Bloody hell!Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
I'm baffled how the BMW gets more expensive if you lease over a longer period where other cars (eg Golf GTi) get cheaper
Edited by Hackney on Thursday 14th November 17:33
Broccers said:
Just do a personal lease and claim the miles back.
Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
Looking at different terms on that site, I wouldn't be surprised if the pricing is incorrect.Pinched from another forum
http://www.carleasing4u.co.uk/car-leasing-deal-bmw...
Also, with those emissions, the tax treatment would be quite tough.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




