Landlords: rolling vs fixed contracts
Landlords: rolling vs fixed contracts
Author
Discussion

trashbat

Original Poster:

6,318 posts

184 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
We found out today that come the end of our fixed term rental, our landlord intends to ask us to sign for another 12 months, ad infinitum, rather than - in my experience - the usual rolling contract with 1 or 2 months' notice in either direction. If we don't sign, he apparently intends to find new tenants - "that's how I run it as a business".

He can legally do this, but I don't intend to sign said contract, as it's horribly inflexible and leaves me with a huge liability if I absolutely must move due to unforeseen circumstances in the early months. There's some benefit to us in stability, but not really that much. If I'd known this was coming, I'd not have moved in in the first place, but I never even considered it.

I can see the benefits to him, especially that he knows he'll only have to look for tenants in June of any year rather than being stung with notice at Christmas.

However I can also see risks and costs: the burden of having to re-let, and sacrificing a stable income from reliable tenants in exchange for an unknown quantity, all potentially to gain no benefit.

So, to BtL landlords on here: do any of you seek the same approach? Where would a happy compromise be in negotiation?

Edited by trashbat on Saturday 23 November 17:22

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
If the LL only wants a 12 month AST you have to be prepared for the fact that you may get served a Section 21 if you won't sign.

Most LLs would prefer the guarantee of a 12 month AST but they have to weigh that against the benefit of a good tenant. However - only your LL can decide what's best for him.

trashbat

Original Poster:

6,318 posts

184 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
Yep, as it stands, expecting a S21 if I say no. Just trying to get some perspective on whether that would be a sensible business decision in most people's eyes.

I've never seen this attempted before, with two exceptions: student lets, and planned sale of the property.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 23rd November 2013
quotequote all
In my experience it's normally the agent that wants a new contract as they charge am admin fee.

My last 2 LLs were more than happy witn letting the contract roll onto a periodic as they valued a good tenant over a long tenant.

Even with the S21 you will be able to stay for a few months so time to find another place. Best of luck!

H18 ENF

700 posts

200 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
trashbat said:
We found out today that come the end of our fixed term rental, our landlord intends to ask us to sign for another 12 months, ad infinitum, rather than - in my experience - the usual rolling contract with 1 or 2 months' notice in either direction. If we don't sign, he apparently intends to find new tenants - "that's how I run it as a business".

He can legally do this, but I don't intend to sign said contract, as it's horribly inflexible and leaves me with a huge liability if I absolutely must move due to unforeseen circumstances in the early months. There's some benefit to us in stability, but not really that much. If I'd known this was coming, I'd not have moved in in the first place, but I never even considered it.

I can see the benefits to him, especially that he knows he'll only have to look for tenants in June of any year rather than being stung with notice at Christmas.

However I can also see risks and costs: the burden of having to re-let, and sacrificing a stable income from reliable tenants in exchange for an unknown quantity, all potentially to gain no benefit.

So, to BtL landlords on here: do any of you seek the same approach? Where would a happy compromise be in negotiation?

Edited by trashbat on Saturday 23 November 17:22
The Ad-infinitum part of the suggested agreement is of some concern as it has implications to me that you are agreeing to a rolling 12 month contract, which would renew automatically at the end of each term unless you back out of it.

12 month Contracts often have a break clause in them half way through, or sometimes earlier if that is more agreeable.

12 month contracts are not uncommon for renewing tenancies as the fear of the 'unknown' for the landlord becomes less and it is a more stable proposition for them.

My recommendation to you would be to request a break clause after a period that is agreeable to you both.