Question about using a contractor web developer?
Question about using a contractor web developer?
Author
Discussion

warp9

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

228 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi
Over the last 6 years we've used 2 different agencies to design and build our websites. Without going into the ins and outs, they have each done a reasonable job. However the one thing in common with both, is that the design and build of each site took a long time - around 4 months.

This is mostly due to the time taken to go back and forth with each design change, content and image revision, given peoples availability, work loads and priority of the job.

We have now decided to redesign one of our sites and due to the seasonality of our work, want it finished before the end of March.

I am wondering if it would be quicker to employ an independent web developer for this one off job, to get it done much quicker. My idea would be to employ them for e.g. 6 weeks full time to get it done and ideally sit in the office to get immediate feedback on any questions that arose.

So my questions are:
1) Is this a common and easy thing to do and arrange?
2) We're based in Birmingham, where would be find someone with credibility to do this?
3) Are there any other considerations I've missed?

Thanks.


Altrezia

8,742 posts

242 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
I know this isn't what you're asking for, but we could turn it around before March.

Bigger agencies like to over-plan everything at every stage. We try and do as much as we can at the start and then concentrate on the code once we start building.


bishbash

2,447 posts

228 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
It's definitely something that companies do, your best bet is probably to advertise it as a temporary job on one (or more) of the big Job websites, jobserve.co.uk, cwjobs.co.uk, reed.co.uk etc. But I think you can expect to pay around £200/day for a decent developer who's prepared to work like this. I've done it once before and would do it again, I'm not in Birmingham though.

But, you have highlighted a problem with lots of web development projects, the back and forth between developer and company, it's refreshing to see you've recognised that it's a 2 sided problem as most companies just seem to blame the developer. Proper planning, which should start before even talking to a developer, is key.

There are a few tools that try address this problem, try http://www.gathercontent.com

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
How much are you looking for this to cost?

You really need to employ two people, the designer and the coder. For a 6 week project you'd probably look to have the designer for 2 weeks and the coder for 4, or maybe 3 and 3, depending on the project.

In fact, a lot of web agencies I know will use three people on a standard website project. A graphic designer to create PSDs, a junior web developer to splice those PSDs into raw HTML/CSS and then a coder to implement that raw HTML/CSS into whichever CMS platform or framework is going to be used for the project. Either the junior or coder may then add some JavaScript into the mix to bring the site to life.

Either way, to be on site any decent designer/coder I'd expect will cost you £300/day plus. For 6 weeks that's £9000.

Do you have an example of what this site will be like? Is it a big project? For most average web agencies I know, a £9k website is either big or complicated.

Regardless, you'll have one of two problems:

One, you'll really struggle to find a good freelancer who can do both graphic design and code. I don't know any, and I know a lot of designers and coders in the South East.

Two, if you choose to use two or three different freelancers, then what will you do when you sign off the designs, the coder starts coding and then something changes. There's nearly always times in the project when there is a design change after the designs have been signed off, or the coder suggests something, etc, etc. At that stage your designer will be finished and will have moved on to the next job.

In my opinion, it just sounds like you need to find another agency who have a bit more flexibility. Maybe impose some deadline clause in your contract?

Akiraprise

271 posts

219 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
We could also turn around a website before March - that's a fairly large lead-time for a redesign - but of course it depends on what the site is.

The only thing I would consider about your plan is that what support will you receive after the site launch? What happens if something breaks a few months in and you're no longer in contact with the developer? I think it would only really make sense if you're going to hire someone full time to take care of all of the websites - for just a redesign of one I would seriously consider just going with an agency.

Link removed by mod.

Cheers
Russell

Edited by eybic on Friday 6th December 22:01

warp9

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

228 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
Thank you all for your comments so far, some interesting points raised.

The site we are looking to emulate is bennetts . co. uk. They have IMO really good social media and client interaction which we are looking to get into as my limited understanding shows that this really helps SEO and credibility around a brand (following recent google updates - of which I'm sure many of you know lots about!) We are not bike insurers, but work in another niche insurance area. Note: we are not looking to have a classifieds as I know this will cost ££££!

Thanks.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
How much of Bennets site are you looking to emulate? How many pages do you think this site will end up with? Do you need a section for visitors to get quotes? Do you want integration with any other systems?

Also, the social media is a separate thing in itself - depending on your company size it could almost be a job in itself.

bishbash

2,447 posts

228 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
I'd be surprised if Bennets didn't have a small team working on that site full time.

jonamv8

3,302 posts

197 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
March, well we could turn it around before that, echoing others above.

Most projects I know required design changes during development, even with the best planning.

I like that you realise this is a two sided issue but I'm afraid you will still run into issues getting a contractor/s in.

Happy to discuss this with you if you would like.

Good luck with the project

jonamv8

3,302 posts

197 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
March, well we could turn it around before that, echoing others above.

Most projects I know required design changes during development, even with the best planning.

I like that you realise this is a two sided issue but I'm afraid you will still run into issues getting a contractor/s in.

Happy to discuss this with you if you would like.

Good luck with the project

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
How do you guys all know you could turn the project around before March without yet knowing the project deliverables?

billythekid001

57 posts

162 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi OP,

In short yes you will be able to find a web developer who will fit all your requirements i.e. do everything, work in house etc but by placing these requirements on the ideal candidate it could take a long time to find them. Try posting an advert on freelancers.net and seeing what kind of response you get. Perhaps another PH forum user can recommend a Birmingham specific web dev/design community forum to use as well?

I would second previous advice in this thread and split the project into design and then code as it will almost certainly lead to better results. Most web developers (i.e. coders) are capable of filling in the blanks from a design point of view if given some initial Photoshop files but they struggle to come up with the 'big idea' for the overall brand.

I think adding in the 'social' side of the product you insure is a very good idea to bring traffic to your site. As a biker I've read the 'bike social' section on the Bennetts site before and found it genuinely interesting and useful (although I get my insurance from Carole Nash as it was cheaper :-)). It would also be advisable to start creating your content and maybe some rough wireframes before engaging a designer/developer so that they have something to work with, as their first question will almost certainly be to ask for these.

Thanks,

Billy

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
jammy_basturd said:
How do you guys all know you could turn the project around before March without yet knowing the project deliverables?
Exactly what I was thinking. I don't understand how you can commit to a date until you have all of the requirements and estimated the effort for them and know what resources will be available (including client resources). I guess I'm just a bit old fashioned like that.

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Saturday 7th December 2013
quotequote all
At least when you use an agency, there is post go live support available...in months to come if there is a bug, defect etc you know where to go to get recourse or a fix

Cheers

warp9

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

228 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi all. Thanks again for your comments. I was aware that we'd at least need a separate graphics designer and then someone to build the site. I hadn't quite got to that point yet. I also hadn't considered the post go live support aspect of the build, which as a business would be important to us.

I'm in the process of speaking to our current agencies, I appreciate some of your offers for help, let me speak to them first and I may be in touch!
Cheers.

Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
My 2peneth: Don't do it. You will have 1-2 people who will say 'What do you want us to do?' Do you know exactly? Will you know if they are average, good or great ta what they do?

I manage all sorts of designers and coders and there isn't a chance they could produce a website if dealing direct with people. You absolutely should use your current agency or another one. The agency should be able to provide a far more effective website for you from their collective resources. Whatever you think you are saving by going direct will cost you much much more in the long run.

grumbas

1,178 posts

222 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
Based on a bit of internet stalking if you're in the motor trade niche, if you're looking at a rebrand of the current site plus a bit of SEO etc it really shouldn't be a 4 month build for the right team - we've just done a ground up rebuild of our comparison engine in not much more and without stacks of resource.

You've got 2 things to consider:
1) structure of the site, what will the content be, how will it interact etc
2) content, you'll want some sort of CMS for this and will form the basis of your SEO articles, blog, etc

I haven't dealt with him but Altrezia who commented at the top of the page often gives advice on similar threads and looking through his portfolio should easily be able to turn around what you need well within the time frames you mention.