3D Secure - worth it?
3D Secure - worth it?
Author
Discussion

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm currently finalising arrangements for an online payment gateway thingy for a new web retail business and discussions came to 3D Secure (if this means nothing to you, it's the window that pops up during a checkout transaction, where your bank asks you to enter a few digits of a password as a secondary chek that you're actually the cardholder).

The provider expalined that having this feature is entirely up to the retailer, and the positive impact on the transaction fees is minimal. Upside of having it, is that it minimises chargebacks from fraudulent (or alleged fraudulent wink ) card use, but the downside, so the salesperson told me, is that having it results in 17-22% of transactions being abandoned.

One in five customers decides - according to this quoted statistic (I know!) - that they don't want your product after all, simply because they can't (be bothered to?) remember their password, or whatever yikes

Any web traders here care to comment on their experiences of having/not having 3D Secure as part of their transactoion checkout?



V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
In fact, I'd also be interested to hear if anyone (at all, as opposed to just those who trade online) does abandon purchases when faced with a 3D Secure stage.

Bullett

11,193 posts

215 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I don't think I've ever abandoned a transaction at that stage.

Would some of those abandoned transactions not be potentially fraudulent? so it actually stopped then transaction.
Others would be for people who don't transact online much I suspect. It would be interesting to see how that breaks down, probably depends a lot on your market as well.


igiveup

2,875 posts

313 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
As a customer I use 3D Secure, and nearly every time I have forgotten the password. Not a problem as there is a Password reset button which is easy enough to use and create a new passcode on the fly.

I have only once aborted buying something because of the password hassle, but that's generally because I will reset it at another time and come back to the purchase another day.

Note: I no longer forget my password so it is a doddle.

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
How, if at all, does the use of the 3d secure impact on the liability of the trader/bank in terms of fraud?

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
TooLateForAName said:
How, if at all, does the use of the 3d secure impact on the liability of the trader/bank in terms of fraud?
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.

aizvara

2,067 posts

198 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Conversely, in the event of a password being guessed or reset (using the laughably insecure password reset info - DoB, or even card/account details) by a third party, the card holder will find it harder (impossible?) to escape liability for that fraud.

The ease with which I reset the password with one issuer who used this system led to me cancelling that card. None of my other card issuers seem to have implemented 3d secure, so far.

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
aizvara said:
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Conversely, in the event of a password being guessed or reset (using the laughably insecure password reset info - DoB, or even card/account details) by a third party, the card holder will find it harder (impossible?) to escape liability for that fraud.

The ease with which I reset the password with one issuer who used this system led to me cancelling that card. None of my other card issuers seem to have implemented 3d secure, so far.
Which is another tick in the box for me, with my e-tailer hat on.

aizvara

2,067 posts

198 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
V8mate said:
Which is another tick in the box for me, with my e-tailer hat on.
Short term this is good for shifting liability from you and the bank to your customers.

Personally, I won't sign up for it again if at all possible, as I feel it is at odds with good security*, it makes me liable and therefore even more reliant on the card issuer and retailer's security, and is an extra nuisance which offers me little benefit.




* Both in terms of protocol used, and the way it educates users to trust difficult-to-verify third-party websites with passwords, reset and even sign-up info, mid transaction.

Fastdruid

9,413 posts

183 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
aizvara said:
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Conversely, in the event of a password being guessed or reset (using the laughably insecure password reset info - DoB, or even card/account details) by a third party, the card holder will find it harder (impossible?) to escape liability for that fraud.
This is one of the reasons I refuse to use it. Its for the protection of the bank not the customer and it means that if there is any fraud you cannot 'defend' it. Especially as a customer you do not have technical access to be able to verify proper PCI compliance (and that in itself is a joke).

Most implementations allow you to bypass it if you haven't set it up already but some online systems aren't implemented properly and either take a "refused to sign up" as a failure or don't allow you to continue without signing up. Those sites don't get my money.

Worst one I've come across for it is scan.co.uk, didn't even give me a "no thanks" or cancel option and using the only other option of using the back button lost my "basket".


MrReg

1,939 posts

253 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
I think of it from a retailer point of view as another way to stop possible frauds. Only last week it stopped a £7k fraud for me so I'm happy to continue to use it - I suppose it depends on your average selling price - something at £5 is it worth the hassle?

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I know what it is, I was asking if its use changes liability in any way.

If a fraudulent transaction does go through, who pays?

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
TooLateForAName said:
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I know what it is, I was asking if its use changes liability in any way.

If a fraudulent transaction does go through, who pays?
It's not as simple as that (as it depends on lots of different variables), however, more often the liability shifts away from the merchant's bank to the customer's bank.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Fastdruid said:
aizvara said:
V8mate said:
It doesn't. It's simply a step which will mean that someone who steals your card can't use it to order goods on a 3D Secure website. And also means that a cardholder will have less chance to (fraudulently) suggest that the card was used without their permission if 3D Secure was present in the transaction.
Conversely, in the event of a password being guessed or reset (using the laughably insecure password reset info - DoB, or even card/account details) by a third party, the card holder will find it harder (impossible?) to escape liability for that fraud.
This is one of the reasons I refuse to use it. Its for the protection of the bank not the customer and it means that if there is any fraud you cannot 'defend' it. Especially as a customer you do not have technical access to be able to verify proper PCI compliance (and that in itself is a joke).

Most implementations allow you to bypass it if you haven't set it up already but some online systems aren't implemented properly and either take a "refused to sign up" as a failure or don't allow you to continue without signing up. Those sites don't get my money.

Worst one I've come across for it is scan.co.uk, didn't even give me a "no thanks" or cancel option and using the only other option of using the back button lost my "basket".
That's incorrect. It's for the protection of the merchant. Without 3DS, if a chargeback occurs the funds are taken out of the merchant's funds pretty much regardless of what happens. With 3DS, as a merchant, if it's all been fully 3DS authorised, the merchant's funds are safe. The grey area is when you've got business/international cards etc.

The reason scan don't allow you to cancel is because they used to have it as an option (with the cancel button), but that's a complete joke and negates the need for it!

I must be honest, 3DS is a pretty badly implemented option, but it's currently the best available as a merchant.

As the cardholder, it's your responsibility to ensure your details are kept safe. As a merchant, why should I be financially punished if you haven't done so?

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
I still can't decide whether to implement 3D Secure or not. Got to sign the contract tomorrow.

Any more online traders got a view?

cuneus

5,963 posts

273 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
http://www.58bits.com/thesis/3-D_Secure.html

Survey data at the bottom is interesting

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
That is certainly an interesting article.

I think it's important to note that it's three years old now though. Technology, and people's comfort levels with it, are a fast moving feast.

cuneus

5,963 posts

273 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
Nationwide:

"Recent improvements to Verified by Visa

In response to customer feedback and to improve our customer experience when shopping online, we no longer require a password to verify a purchase"

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
cuneus said:
Nationwide:

"Recent improvements to Verified by Visa

In response to customer feedback and to improve our customer experience when shopping online, we no longer require a password to verify a purchase"
Uh?

I completed a VbyV window on a purchase today.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
By choice I pay by Amex but if that's not accepted I use Visa, if the site then asks for this stuff I generally abandon the purchase.