What would you do?
Author
Discussion

Nublust

Original Poster:

25 posts

166 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
So I have an idea. Basically, it uses existing technology but attaching a service to it and various other designs and purposes, along with marketing it a certain way and expanding the uses of the current technology into new markets. My research suggests nobody does what I'm intending to do at all yet.

I don't have the technical expertise to develop a prototype, nor the money or experience to actually get off the ground (and I'm probably going to need tens of thousands of pounds to get other people to make prototypes and what not for me).

So as it stands at the moment, it's a no go. Bit of a weird and hard to answer question I know, but if it was you, what do you think you would do in my situation? Just give it up or are there certain paths you would pursue first? Just after a bit of advice really.

Background on myself, I'm 20 and in the first year of a degree.

DennisCooper

1,340 posts

202 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi,

You've used the word 'probably' for when it comes to cost of the prototype. Have you actually approached specialist companies and asked for a quote? what if the actual cost to develop a prototype was much less than you expected?

Reading between the lines, the 'technology' already exists, so will you be taking that piece of tech and perhaps making something to 'hold' it in a certain way(s) and thus being able to offer a service from the 'two bits added/used together'? If so, take a good look around and get quotes in.

Cheers, Dennis!

GoneBananas

129 posts

167 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
or you could find a business partner who has the technical know how.

Nublust

Original Poster:

25 posts

166 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
It's kind of designing something to hold it, but it would be it's own piece of kit (so for example, not a mobile phone holder, but a new mobile phone device...if that makes sense).

I suppose it can't hurt to approach someone though, any recommendations? I've never done anything like this before so I wouldn't even know where to start. I'm assuming there's some sort of agreement that the company won't then run off with your idea or something haha?

Asking someone already in the know had occurred to me but, but I don't know anyone that knows this stuff well enough, and I don't think I'd trust a stranger.

GoneBananas

129 posts

167 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Could you copyright the idea before asking for advice?

Nublust

Original Poster:

25 posts

166 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
It's an electrical device that would need to be able to send information to an online database (wirelessly ofc), but my idea would entail many different versions for different purposes so it's hard to say. They wouldn't really be very big.

As for the copyright, I'm not sure if I'd actually be able to do it as I'm just using the tech for a different purpose. The tech itself wouldn't really be any different, just inside a different case.


Looking at prototyping, I've just read online that specialists usually charge up to £1500 per consulting session, never mind the actual build. Is it really that much in other peoples experiences?

offshorematt2

868 posts

247 months

Saturday 11th January 2014
quotequote all
Could you engage another student in a different discipline to help build the prototype? Wouldn't have to look market ready yet, I guess - just be functional to attract more funding?

Nublust

Original Poster:

25 posts

166 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice everyone, I'll have a go at trying to get someone else onboard and putting something together ourselves. Failing that, I may have to start saving up on a student budget laugh.

951TSE

600 posts

188 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
Would Kickstarter be of any help with the funding?

http://www.kickstarter.com/

Dr Slotter

409 posts

177 months

Sunday 12th January 2014
quotequote all
What university are you at? Do they have an enterprise unit? It's getting pretty common that they do.

Nublust

Original Poster:

25 posts

166 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
1) Well I think the idea will become a global venture make me a multi-billionaire thumbup But then I may be a little bias...
In seriousness, I think there is a demand for it at the moment, and as the tech involved becomes better I (based the the free research I've managed to find) believe the demand will increase tenfold. Answering Dr Slotter here as well, I did go to my Uni enterprise schemes but this was a year ago. They seemed to think the idea was brilliant at the time, but they didn't really give much information about how to move forward (they basically said, "That's a good idea, go do it! Here's a information sheet on business accounting") and then I had exams and it all seemed to just die off. Then due to family losses it disappeared altogether until I decided to look into it more now.

2) Well the idea came around because I was teaching myself Java and I was going to try and write an app for my phone, I had an idea and it just grew and grew. Some of the things I'd like to do, other companies already do so I know some of the products already exist in the market (although it's still pretty niche), but they don't do anything to the extent that I'd like to do it too...if that makes sense.

A lot of the rest of what I'd like my products to do is just using technology in new places. It's nothing groundbreaking or innovative tech wise, it's just using it differently which is why I didn't think making huge, unattractive boards and equipment would be much good, as it's not much different. My uniqueness comes from the services that would be on offer using this technology, with the Human interface.

I did have a look at crowd funding but at the minute I've got nothing to offer other than, "I'm a 20 year old student who's done some research and thinks he has a good idea but it looks like he'll have to pay other people to do it all for him" haha.

So, after all that, what do you think toxicnerve?

Thank you very much for the advice by the way everyone, it's hugely appreciated!


lewisf182

2,242 posts

219 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
I'd have thought your University would have an enterprise unit as previously said. Sheffield Hallam Uni where I went had a lot of support for people starting businesses known as the hatchery, it's also available years after you graduate which is pretty cool.

That would be my first port of call without a doubt in your situation, they will be able to point you in the right direction and will have dealt with similar requests thousands of times!

Johnniem

2,758 posts

254 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
If it is an idea that could be made out of pre-existing technology and isn't a patentable product (this can take years to obtain and cost many thousands of ££££'s) then, presumably, any old taiwanese/korean/chinese etc etc electronics company will take your naiscent product and reproduce it for a fraction of the cost. My suspicion is that there is potential to lose your troosers on this but if it is patentable and it all makes sense to the market place then go for it! But don't be under any illusion that the big boys wont just crack on with it if it is a successful idea. Small business manager at the local bank may be able to make this clearer than I.

Good luck fella. This country needs chaps like you and I hope it make you biwwions!


jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
Forget whether you can or can't make the product for a moment. You say you think there is a demand for the product, which suggests you don't actually know.

What most people do is spend thousands on prototyping and making and refining the product. Then they have the product and realise they need to think about marketing strategies. Those that are then able to work out a marketing strategy then take it to market and realise that there either isn't one, or it's not quite what the market wanted.

Create a website now. Have a graphic designer or 3D artist spend an afternoon creating some virtual mockups. Spend £100 on Google Ads and drive some traffic to the website, either stick a phone number or enquiry form on the website. You could either put a Buy Now button with a price that simply goes through to a page saying the product is still on development, but enter your email address here to receive email updates. If you get no phone calls, emails or clicks on the button then no one wants it.

If you DO get interest, then you have hard data to show there is interest to take to a bank or crowd funding site.

Alternatively you can use Kickstarter or Indiegogo to effectively get people to pre-buy the first batch.

ReaderScars

6,087 posts

207 months

Tuesday 14th January 2014
quotequote all
When you signed up to your uni/college course there may be a binding contract/agreement you've signed up to. It might say that anything you create belongs - in some way - to the uni. Meaning if you discuss it with them then although they could help you develop and commercialise the product/service, they might ultimately hold the patent or something.

In addition you are also perfectly placed to access a start up loan through the Start Up loans company. If your design/product has commecial legs they will approve an unsecured loan at 6.2%ish, up to four or five years (first year interest free).

For starts ups which show real commercial promise - as yours well might - they offer loans of up to £25k, but their due diligence is pretty thorough at those levels.

If I was in your position I would either:

A) sack uni off, get a start up loan and go for it full time, or
B) talk to the uni to see of they will guide you though the development and commercialisation

You might feel that this is too big to consider. Don't look at the big picture - try to break it down into stages and figure out what needs to happen to make each stage managable.

Also, this could just be the first product which you create - it could be the stepping stone to your life as a product developer; go for it!


  • *EDITED TO SAY***: first year repayments on the start up loan can be an INTEREST ONLY option - not interest free.


Edited by ReaderScars on Wednesday 15th January 11:36