Up the garden path with prospect
Discussion
Hi All
Just to share and ask for feedback on something that happened to us last week – we run a PR/marketing firm and we met two Likely Lad business owners who have a good track record in starting and selling on businesses as potential new clients (and know people they know). We had a good initial meeting and were then asked to help out with a press release in lieu of a kick-off meeting and contract.
Well lo and behold, we do this bit of initial work and do a proposal and then get a strange email from one of these guys saying our work wasn't what he was looking for and picking holes in certain (non-financial) aspects of our proposal, oh, and by the way, they have a mate who is cheaper they are going with.
So in other words, I suspect they wanted to milk us for ideas and some initial work before going with 'pay to play' cheap guy for the actual work. I can't otherwise explain the strange behaviour or completely naive feedback on the press release and proposal (all these things are meant to be a dialectic process between parties).
I know there is no avoiding this happening but it really f**ks me off when it does happen!
Anyone else have similar experiences to this?
Cheers
Just to share and ask for feedback on something that happened to us last week – we run a PR/marketing firm and we met two Likely Lad business owners who have a good track record in starting and selling on businesses as potential new clients (and know people they know). We had a good initial meeting and were then asked to help out with a press release in lieu of a kick-off meeting and contract.
Well lo and behold, we do this bit of initial work and do a proposal and then get a strange email from one of these guys saying our work wasn't what he was looking for and picking holes in certain (non-financial) aspects of our proposal, oh, and by the way, they have a mate who is cheaper they are going with.
So in other words, I suspect they wanted to milk us for ideas and some initial work before going with 'pay to play' cheap guy for the actual work. I can't otherwise explain the strange behaviour or completely naive feedback on the press release and proposal (all these things are meant to be a dialectic process between parties).
I know there is no avoiding this happening but it really f**ks me off when it does happen!
Anyone else have similar experiences to this?
Cheers
It's always happened and always will. I call them 'dining table dreamers'.
I went to visit such a man with one of the directors in my ad agency days. I was a naive newbie but the boss had seen it all before. We drove to meet the fellow at his home and had an amicable meeting. On the way back we were discussing things. The boss said 'I'll take him seriously when he puts some loot on the table'. And how right he was.
Whether or not you write back calling them a two-bit cheapskate timewasting outfit is up to you
I went to visit such a man with one of the directors in my ad agency days. I was a naive newbie but the boss had seen it all before. We drove to meet the fellow at his home and had an amicable meeting. On the way back we were discussing things. The boss said 'I'll take him seriously when he puts some loot on the table'. And how right he was.
Whether or not you write back calling them a two-bit cheapskate timewasting outfit is up to you

Simpo Two said:
It's always happened and always will. I call them 'dining table dreamers'.
But these guys clearly aren't dreamers. The OP says that they are successful in starting and selling on businesses. They set the OP a task to test whether he would be an appropriate supplier and he failed. Needs to get over it.In my line of work, I'll have 3 or 4 companies spending £4-6m bidding for a job and only one will win. Makes the OP's inconvenience trivial.
I get it all the time.
Thanks, but no thanks as I have a *(Insert choice from list below) that can do it for me.
Mate
Electrician
Builder
Aerial Rigger
Data Guy
Boss
Employee
Hifi Nut
Computer nerd
...
..
.
I look at it as helping to inform, if they choose to go this route, then at least they have gone into it with a little more knowledge that they had before and that can only be a good thing.
Keep Calm
Smile
Move On
Reap benefits when it goes wrong and they call you in to fix it
V.
Thanks, but no thanks as I have a *(Insert choice from list below) that can do it for me.
- (List not exhaustive, feel free to add your own)
Mate
Electrician
Builder
Aerial Rigger
Data Guy
Boss
Employee
Hifi Nut
Computer nerd
...
..
.
I look at it as helping to inform, if they choose to go this route, then at least they have gone into it with a little more knowledge that they had before and that can only be a good thing.
Keep Calm
Smile
Move On
Reap benefits when it goes wrong and they call you in to fix it
V.
Hi V8mate - just to clarify, this wasn't an agreed part of a procurement process, it was a deliberate attempt to imply work had been awarded when the intention was not to award that work. Sure, this stuff happens, but IMHO it is a particularly dishonest and below board way of conducting new business with suppliers, especially in a high-end B2B industry...
I take your point on properly managed RFQ/RFP processes.
I take your point on properly managed RFQ/RFP processes.
Edited by Blue One on Monday 20th January 10:22
A depressing and annoying fact of business life unfortunately. In my experience if they have a 'mate who can do it for less' let them go that route. It smacks of small scale thinking.
The most recent one we had was a transport company. I met them and gave them a good quote, not too expensive at all. They went with a friend and their new site is a joke. Ours would have made them thousands in new clients but their new one won't make a penny. Annoying but that's life.
The most recent one we had was a transport company. I met them and gave them a good quote, not too expensive at all. They went with a friend and their new site is a joke. Ours would have made them thousands in new clients but their new one won't make a penny. Annoying but that's life.
This is always a risk when selling professional services.
I find it's best to:
I find it's best to:
- Make sure that any prospects know your day rate and/or ballpark cost for the job as early as possible once communications begin. Although this will rule you out of a lot of work if they can't afford you it was likely a dead end anyway.
- Never give more detail away than you absolutely have to.
- If someone wants a detailed proposal then I push to create a separate contract for it. The product they are buying is a document that they can take away and use elsewhere so they're definitely getting something useful for their money. I think most serious prospects would understand your position in asking for this. If they don't then I would question whether you really want to work with that prospect in the long run.
Yep, have been there. We used to offer a free quote, an initial meeting, but tried to keep it to 1 or 2 hours. After getting burned a few times by offering more information and detail than was necessary we kept the free quote, but then started to give as little information as possible and spend max. 1 hour. It's hard if you are the person winning new work and completing the work. A wasted quote or meeting hits you double. You also start to get a feeling about a client and start to notice the words and terms they use. No more B2C anymore, B2B all the way now.
We also used to have some clients who needed an initial meeting that day or the next day - asap. but then would p!ss around making a decision and then complain if other work had come up which you'd agreed with other clients..! Of course these were always the ones who paid late or lost/forget/ate their cheque book..
We also used to have some clients who needed an initial meeting that day or the next day - asap. but then would p!ss around making a decision and then complain if other work had come up which you'd agreed with other clients..! Of course these were always the ones who paid late or lost/forget/ate their cheque book..
V8mate said:
But these guys clearly aren't dreamers. The OP says that they are successful in starting and selling on businesses. They set the OP a task to test whether he would be an appropriate supplier and he failed. Needs to get over it.
True, I misinterpreted the brief. But I doubt the OP had a fair chance, they just suckered his good nature and desire to get work.I had a Christmas Card from a supplier once. On the back it said 'Printed from recycled estimates'. How true this is.
V8mate said:
But these guys clearly aren't dreamers. The OP says that they are successful in starting and selling on businesses. They set the OP a task to test whether he would be an appropriate supplier and he failed. Needs to get over it.
In my line of work, I'll have 3 or 4 companies spending £4-6m bidding for a job and only one will win. Makes the OP's inconvenience trivial.
Interested to know what line of work you are in, companies spending £4 - 6m bidding for a job ? In my line of work, I'll have 3 or 4 companies spending £4-6m bidding for a job and only one will win. Makes the OP's inconvenience trivial.
That's a massive amount to layout on just bidding for the job with only a 25% chance of being awarded the work.
The possible end return must be massive.
billythekid001 said:
- Make sure that any prospects know your day rate and/or ballpark cost for the job as early as possible once communications begin. Although this will rule you out of a lot of work if they can't afford you it was likely a dead end anyway.
- Never give more detail away than you absolutely have to.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



ks it up, they feel happy to give me a call. I have won several good clients that way....