Dignified silence or fight?
Dignified silence or fight?
Author
Discussion

bennyboydurham

Original Poster:

1,617 posts

205 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Long story short guys, I run a new set-up company that makes training films. I brought a young whiz kid in to do some motion graphics and editing, by young I mean 17, although I only found this out later as he made himself out to be much older (M'lud). I originally wanted to pay him a set fee but he asked if he could work on a share of the profits from the films instead. To help my cash flow I went along with this idea as that meant no upfront cost to me and he shared the risk should I only sell 1 copy. This lack of pay, however, meant that although he talked a good game, his productivity was at a crawl. Days became weeks, weeks became months and when stuff arrived I was not impressed with it. In the end I found someone else and offered him a reasonable sum of money to buy out the small amount of work he'd already done and he came back with a piss take number that would buy a nice car from the bargain barge thread. I declined this and offered my original more realistic sum once more, at which point he threw his toys out the pram and withdrew, making copyright claims against my YouTube channel and saying that 'he will be making a statement in his defence', which I guess he will put on his Facebook page and/or YouTube channel.

This kid has a small but loyal bunch of young, unwashed fanboi gamers who frequent his own YouTube channel, who he thinks are his friends. They are already making themselves heard, and I'm sure will continue to troll my work in social media and forums for some time yet. This makes little difference in the overall scheme of things as most of the buyers of my material have never heard of him or indeed would care less who did the motion graphics but it's a headache I could do without. I could mount a detailed defence on my own website and Facebook page, but a large part of me thinks that doing so will only fan the flames. He is of little consequence in the big scheme of things and at the moment it's better to delete the trolls and wait for them to become bored and in a fairly short space of time the whole thing will be forgotten.

Any advice?

MacW

1,352 posts

207 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
It takes a fair amount of dedication and purpose to engage in a prolonged online harassment campaign when the other party is refusing to acknowledge your existance.

If most of the grief is coming from his followers then they have no vested interest themselves and will lose their enthusiasm fairly swiftly if you don't respond or give them something new to get their teeth into.

Treat the situation with the disdain it deserves and concentrate on more important things.

Splats

625 posts

193 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
My advice is, do not get drawn into an online pissing contest on social media. It would look totally unprofessional and you have no idea how the back and forth argument could grow. Better to try and distance yourself as much as possible, say nothing, and delete any material that harm your business. At all times, make it clear (off-line) that your original fair and reasonable offer still stands.

Simpo Two

93,093 posts

296 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
First, sort out the legal ground you stand on so you can work out who has the high ground. I'm not sure whether he was technically your employee, as no money changed hands. If he was, then anything he did is your copyright. If he wasn't, then it's his copyright and you can't use it without his permission. In that case you would be correct to remove any of his work that you have posted.

The other angle is that he agreed to a profit share. As his work has generated no profit, he is entitled to no money at all. Just don't use it, and you're in the clear IMHO. WHy he thought he was entitled to anything is the disconnect. Young, greedy and foolish I suspect.

What you do on the social media front is up to you; if you're in the right, defend.