Frequent flyers; recline or not?
Frequent flyers; recline or not?

Poll: Frequent flyers; recline or not?

Total Members Polled: 150

Stuff 'em, my seats reclined before takeoff: 15
The lights out, I'm reclining: 42
Not fussed either way: 21
Decline to recline: 18
Recliners are ignorant, selfish assholes: 59
Author
Discussion

deltashad

Original Poster:

6,731 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Its a pet hate of mine, you sit down in your seat, get comfortable, then as soon as the seatbelt light is turned off, the person infront decides they want to spend the next 3 and a half hours taking up your valuable space with their chair reclined back.

I can understand when the flights are long haul (say over four hours or so). This is not about these flights.

I had a minor debate regarding this with others and there seems to be two camps here.
My collegues hate this too, and are with me on this, we all have to travel regularly and although we can choose the airline, we cannot choose business class.
There is a tool you can buy which prevents people from reclining their chairs, it is totally legal and authorised by the FAA. They don't have a problem with the use of these.

Others have stated that using this device is an infringement of their personal rights to recline, and, that if I have a problem with this then I should upgrade to business or 1st class.
I see it as an infringement on my space, and, therefore if they wish to take up my space for their own personal comfort they should pay for the upgrade not me.


Sorry if I'm coming across like a moaning git, I've been a frequent flyer for the past 16 years so it's nothing new to me.
I thought I'd do a Poll just out of genuine interest to see how others feel about this.

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Think that reclining a little bit is ok, so not so bolt up right, but full on reclining in cattle class if the person behind isn't (especially those that do it through the meal, so you have to have your face 2 inches from the seat back!)

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
The seats should be fixed in cattle class. It's bad enough being stuck in there with them.

supertouring

2,228 posts

264 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I usually go for a 50% recline and have in the past suggested to the person in front to do the same.

I really hate those that get on, recline asap and off to sleep. Therefore cannot eat my food in a civilised manner.


Targarama

14,792 posts

314 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
I don't like being fully reclined as I'm tall. However a little bit is OK. However if you're faced (literally) with someone who does the 'slam back' as soon as they can and leaves it there the whole flight then why not just recline your own seat, giving you the same room again.

deltashad

Original Poster:

6,731 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Targarama said:
I don't like being fully reclined as I'm tall. However a little bit is OK. However if you're faced (literally) with someone who does the 'slam back' as soon as they can and leaves it there the whole flight then why not just recline your own seat, giving you the same room again.
Does this not pass the problem on to the person behind you?

Targarama

14,792 posts

314 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
deltashad said:
Does this not pass the problem on to the person behind you?
Yes, but I look behind and warn them at least.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
The person reclining their seat is not taking your space. You are trying to stop them using their space.

Airline seats recline. They - and you - have paid for the use of a reclining seat. As such, they have paid for the space between the back of the seat in front of them when reclined to the back of their own seat when reclined. If the person in front of you happens not to recline their seat, lucky you! They've just temporarily allowed you the use of some of their space.

I fortunately don't have to travel much on business any more, but did so frequently enough for the first 15 years of my career that I managed to get a second passport because I had times where I wasn't in the country for 3 consecutive working days in 3 months to get visas put in my passport.

In all that time, I never understood people taking the OP's view. Do you get hacked off with the person in front eating their dessert rather than giving it to you, whilst in turn saving your dessert for the person behind you?

Edited by Kermit power on Wednesday 5th February 19:44

shirt

25,556 posts

232 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
a new thread for this, really?

i fly long haul frequently in economy. if there is no real reason why i cannot recline, i will do so. i recommend you get a sense of perspective or ask the stewardess to be re-seated.

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
It's a problem for me. I fly frequently, not every day or week, but around 10 times a year on a mixture of business and pleasure. I'm tall, 6ft5 with long legs, and my knees will be wedged in the back of the seat in front of me.

If anyone tried to recline, the metal frame of the seat will embed itself in my knee caps. So when seating myself, I inform the person in front of this fact, and politely ask them not to recline.


hyperblue

2,915 posts

211 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Flew on Cathay Pacific recently, their seats recline by sliding the base forwards, without the rear shell of the seat moving. Pretty neat solution, though I doubt it would work if you're tall.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Dr Interceptor said:
It's a problem for me. I fly frequently, not every day or week, but around 10 times a year on a mixture of business and pleasure. I'm tall, 6ft5 with long legs, and my knees will be wedged in the back of the seat in front of me.

If anyone tried to recline, the metal frame of the seat will embed itself in my knee caps. So when seating myself, I inform the person in front of this fact, and politely ask them not to recline.
It's not their fault that you're tall. You asking them not to recline their seat - the reclining seat they've paid for - is no different to a fat person sitting next to them spilling into their seat.

Obviously a fat person can go on a diet, whereas you can't do anything about your height, but the other passenger can't do anything about either, so why should they have to suffer for either? You can contact the airline in advance, let them know how tall you are and request a seat in an exit row. Good luck trying to request not being given a seat in front of someone your height if you're the other passenger though!

rsv696

474 posts

174 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Didn't know you could buy these. I believe in being considerate to fellow travellers & I'm not a fan of reclining.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EB65pWVmlg&fea...

Dr Interceptor

8,183 posts

227 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Kermit power said:
Dr Interceptor said:
It's a problem for me. I fly frequently, not every day or week, but around 10 times a year on a mixture of business and pleasure. I'm tall, 6ft5 with long legs, and my knees will be wedged in the back of the seat in front of me.

If anyone tried to recline, the metal frame of the seat will embed itself in my knee caps. So when seating myself, I inform the person in front of this fact, and politely ask them not to recline.
It's not their fault that you're tall. You asking them not to recline their seat - the reclining seat they've paid for - is no different to a fat person sitting next to them spilling into their seat.

Obviously a fat person can go on a diet, whereas you can't do anything about your height, but the other passenger can't do anything about either, so why should they have to suffer for either? You can contact the airline in advance, let them know how tall you are and request a seat in an exit row. Good luck trying to request not being given a seat in front of someone your height if you're the other passenger though!
I'm not saying it's their fault that I'm tall, I simply make a polite request to their goodwill and nature not to use the recline feature on their seat. If they agree, and don't tip the seat back, I can JUST fit in to the seat.

Asking the airline for extra legroom seats due to height never works, not unless you pay their additional charge for them. I even once asked once on the plane itself, the extra legroom seats at the front were empty. The cabin crew staff were happy for me to go an sit there, providing I paid the in flight upgrade charge of £25.

I recall once I was heading over to Portugal on Monarch, I had booked and paid for an extra legroom seat on row 4, based on the layout of an A320/A321 that they showed on their website. When it came to board though, the plane wasn't an A320, it had been switched to a larger A300 (obviously a popular flight). The A300 only had two rows of extra legroom, I was still allocated a seat on Row 4, no extra legroom. So even if you book and pay for it, you don't always get it.

NormalWisdom

2,184 posts

190 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
I have been flying on business regularly for the last 35 years. The seats have a recline buttons so are made to recline.

I "choose" not to recline on my weekly commute to Munich at the moment (in deference to the passenger behind) but am certainly not going to complain about what is someone else's right. buying tools to prevent this right is down-right bloody minded.

You know the score before you get on, it is the way it is and has always been and really isn't worth complaining about (AIMVHO)

mr_spock

3,376 posts

246 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
If I don't recline I end up in serious back pain. It's one reason I try not to fly the budget airlines over an hour or so.

To the tall people - sorry about this, but you pay more for shoes I believe, and probably clothes, and maybe a super-long bed. You may just have to pay for extra legroom seats. [Viz mode] At least you save on stepladders and paint poles[/Viz]


George7

1,130 posts

181 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
I tend to recline a bit, maybe half way, as I find sitting bolt upright rather uncomfortable. I don't tend to recline the full amount, as in most planes I've been on, it invades the space of the person behind (which is scarce as it is) by a shocking amount, and makes using the tray table nigh on impossible.

Muzzer79

13,254 posts

218 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
I expect reclining on an overnight flight, however all seats should be upright when food is served.

Short-haul, I agree that it's the person in front of me's prerogative to recline their seat but, like me, I expect them to have a bit of common sense and consideration for the person behind them.

A look over your shoulder and acknowledgement of the person behind you with perhaps a 50% recline if they're long and the flight is full is simple consideration.

Get-on-the-plane-sit-down-recline-for-entire-flight-fvck-'em-behind-me = Asshole.

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
On planes with the usual short-haul seat pitch an recliners will get a back full of my knees. It's not intentional, I just don't have anywhere else to put my legs. They have paid to be able to recline. I have paid for the space that is occupied with my knees.

I don't find it too bad on long-haul where there is often a couple of inches of leg room and the journey is more pleasant for recliners and me alike.

jshell

12,117 posts

236 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Long-haul night flight, I don't mind. Daytime or short haul I'll spend the whole flight making the recliner in front of me very, very uncomfortable.