Giving away equity in startup business
Giving away equity in startup business
Author
Discussion

2117885

Original Poster:

1 posts

154 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
I am a regular user of PH but as the parties involved may be on the forum I've setup a new login for anonymity.

I'll try to make this as short and sweet as possible. Myself and business partner have come up with new business venture. We have experience and contacts within the industry to get this started. The idea is a new cloud based software to fill a gap in the market. The issue is, neither myself or business partner have sufficient funds to employ or outsource the development of this software. We estimate it is in the region of £100k + realistically.

Therefore, we have spoken to several developers and will be offering equity in our startup business. I see this is an advantage as we want to partner with a company rather than provide software and shove off.

The question is, when giving away equity would it be reasonable to ask them for set up costs...such as office costs, web hosting, marketing and PR or would this be expected to be fronted by myself and business partner? Also, would it be expected that they recvieve voting rights?

Finally, IF (hopefully not) the company were to fold in the future with debts, would the developers be responsible for their x shares?


griffgrog

740 posts

277 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Without meaning to appear rude, ideas are totally worthless. There is virtually no value to IP within a business unless it's absolutely exceptional - such as a new drug. Everything is in the execution, which in your case means the resources to get things going. If you're going to split the equity in the business based on value brought to the table you are going to end up with very much less than one percent. Also - shares in a business do not = liability for it's debts. So even if you have given them 99% of the shares, you won't necessarily have given them any liability.



Edited by griffgrog on Monday 10th February 21:51

southendpier

6,239 posts

260 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
If you and your mates current employe does something similar they may already have the ip on your idea. Check your contracts.

oh and as the other poster states if you cant put up any money then I doubt anyone is going to bankroll you.

Family friends and fools is where start up capital comes from.

if you can speak to an ip lawyer and see what you can do to owwn the concept.

you will likely need non disclosure and non compete contracts too.

its going to get expensive before you've even put a name plate on your desk and poured your first glass of bubbly.

santona1937

878 posts

161 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
I would expect that the equity is in place of payment, and as such carries no liability. The equity is the cost of my experience in the field in which I work. Without this experience my client would have no business.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
So - you're expecting someone to put in a load of development work against the possibility of future payment, AND fund your startup costs as well? Yikes.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
You're not 'giving away equity' though - you are exchanging for something you need but cannot provide yourself. You are 'selling' the equity.

LooneyTunes

9,521 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
2117885 said:
I am a regular user of PH but as the parties involved may be on the forum I've setup a new login for anonymity.

I'll try to make this as short and sweet as possible. Myself and business partner have come up with new business venture. We have experience and contacts within the industry to get this started. The idea is a new cloud based software to fill a gap in the market. The issue is, neither myself or business partner have sufficient funds to employ or outsource the development of this software. We estimate it is in the region of £100k + realistically.

Therefore, we have spoken to several developers and will be offering equity in our startup business. I see this is an advantage as we want to partner with a company rather than provide software and shove off.

The question is, when giving away equity would it be reasonable to ask them for set up costs...such as office costs, web hosting, marketing and PR or would this be expected to be fronted by myself and business partner? Also, would it be expected that they recvieve voting rights?

Finally, IF (hopefully not) the company were to fold in the future with debts, would the developers be responsible for their x shares?
You're not "giving away equity", you're looking for a full blown partner who can offset your lack of technical skills and cash AND is prepared to accept the risk for doing so.

If they've any sense they absolutely will want voting rights (indeed they should insist on them) and a significant shareholding.

More importantly, they should be seriously questioning what you and your current partner bring to the party and what that is worth... don't say this to be negative but unless you've got a very solid track record it would be easy to dismiss it as lacking substance.

As an alternative, can you borrow say £30k to fund the first six months and/or employ a techie on a low base + options basis?

sunbeam alpine

7,251 posts

219 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
To the poster above me - maybe I'm being stupid, but have you just replied from the wrong account?

Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
sunbeam alpine said:
To the poster above me - maybe I'm being stupid, but have you just replied from the wrong account?
Ooops! hehe

sunbeam alpine

7,251 posts

219 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
sunbeam alpine said:
To the poster above me - maybe I'm being stupid, but have you just replied from the wrong account?
Ooops! hehe
....and his post is gone!

smile

StevieBee

15,511 posts

286 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Equity for services can lead to bunfights of epic proportions further on.

It's easy to be generous with percentages when there's no money at stake but should you ending up selling, this is where things get tricky.


Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
If I had a pound for every time I get this kind of investment proposal, I’d have, well, a lot of pounds.  About half of everything that comes past me can be summarised as

“Hey, Newc, wondered if you’d be interested in this.  Piers and I bumped into each other in Gstaad, and we were chatting and realised that there’s like this enormo market for replica Etruscan camel hoof polishers.  I mean, like, even if we were only 66% of the addressable market we’d be sitting on the yacht with cocktails, yeah ?  So, obviously we’ve locked down the IP and bought the web address, and we have contacts out the wazoo – in fact I was at Bunty and Biggles’ place for dinner last week and they are so up for a bulk order – so we just need someone to bang out a bit of a website and we’ll be golden.  I was thinking a couple of mil should see us through to breakeven, and obviously we’d cut a bit of stock into a staff pool, maybe 5% ?.  Let me know.  Cheers  Tongo.

In fact it’s so much that I now have a standard reply along the lines of

“Hi.  We are two developers with extensive real time high volume transactions experience.  We’ve spotted a B2B opportunity and have built a fully functioning setup in AWS, with real time scalability, mobile support, ops centre monitoring, customer DBs and payment interfaces.  We’ve done this as a weekend hobby project but we want to go full time. We have 12 months seed capital, but we really need a full time salesperson who has contacts in the sector.  Our question is: should we offer stock options for this role, or given that salespeople are readily available should we just stick with base+comm ?” 

santona1937

878 posts

161 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
The issue I have with such equity offers ( I work in the hospitality industry and specialize in new openings) is that the originators of such offers tend:
A) not to have enough capital
B) because it is "their" business ( in which they have little technical experience) are loathe to listen to others about good practice
C) generally resent giving away ( selling) equity
D) expect a lot more than they are paying for

Tuna

19,930 posts

315 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Unless there is a proven business (i.e. you are currently able to get someone to pay you to deliver something), then at best you're offering a punt.

Most of the other posters have covered the bases here, but I have to add I've come across a lot of people in various industries who've 'spotted an opportunity' and just need a tech guy/team to make it happen. Either they offer equity, or in some cases, they've raised funds to pay for some expensive development work.

The two things wrong with this picture is that:

1) You've established that the IT part of the game is core to your new business, yet you're going to 'buy it in' from some random supplier. Besides the issue of finding that rare gem who really knows their sh*t, you're almost certainly going to have the relationship of 'founder' and 'first hire'. If the IT part is core to your business, it's implementation should be core to your business, and all decisions relating to it should be able to be made freely and with flexibility. In other words, to get the best out of the relationship, you should be looking for another founder. Otherwise, you are certain to get an implementation that's "perfectly reasonable" at best. To use a trite analogy, when Pope Julius II decided he wanted the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel a different colour, he didn't hire a painter and tell him what to paint - he gave Michelangelo free reign to do exactly what was needed.

2) If your business model is untested, planning out the end deliverable (a complete cloud service with all the bells and whistles) means that you're not going to be able to test out your theory, or your ability to make sales until all of that expensive work is complete. You should be working out how you and your mate can test the market, prove the value and learn about sales way before then. Any IT solution that takes more than three months to deliver is going to be off the mark simply because you're baking in assumptions that you aren't able to test. Simple things like user sign up, account management and so on can make or break a product, so you have to start delivering early and iterating. That means that you stand a chance of bringing in money early, learning from your mistakes early and getting vital customer feedback early.

You can tell from the above I'm a big fan of Steve Blank and the Lean Startup ethos - it's worth reading up about Minimal viable products and market validation.

LooneyTunes

9,521 posts

189 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Tuna said:
2) If your business model is untested, planning out the end deliverable (a complete cloud service with all the bells and whistles) means that you're not going to be able to test out your theory, or your ability to make sales until all of that expensive work is complete. You should be working out how you and your mate can test the market, prove the value and learn about sales way before then. Any IT solution that takes more than three months to deliver is going to be off the mark simply because you're baking in assumptions that you aren't able to test. Simple things like user sign up, account management and so on can make or break a product, so you have to start delivering early and iterating. That means that you stand a chance of bringing in money early, learning from your mistakes early and getting vital customer feedback early.
Exactly.

That might mean that V1 is a bit of a lash up, followed by a V2 once you know what the market actually wants... all of which adds time, cost, and frustration. Especially if the tame techie thinks/thought that V1 was good enough/going to make him a millionaire.

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

243 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
Tuna said:
2) If your business model is untested, planning out the end deliverable (a complete cloud service with all the bells and whistles) means that you're not going to be able to test out your theory, or your ability to make sales until all of that expensive work is complete. You should be working out how you and your mate can test the market, prove the value and learn about sales way before then. Any IT solution that takes more than three months to deliver is going to be off the mark simply because you're baking in assumptions that you aren't able to test. Simple things like user sign up, account management and so on can make or break a product, so you have to start delivering early and iterating. That means that you stand a chance of bringing in money early, learning from your mistakes early and getting vital customer feedback early.
Exactly.

That might mean that V1 is a bit of a lash up, followed by a V2 once you know what the market actually wants... all of which adds time, cost, and frustration. Especially if the tame techie thinks/thought that V1 was good enough/going to make him a millionaire.
Exactly this. Don't waste tens of thousands getting someone to build something that isn't viable.

The Lean Startup (http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Lean-Startup-Innovation-Successful/dp/0670921602/ref=pd_bxgy_b_img_z) is almost compulsory reading if you want to find out how to test viability before pumping in great wads of cash.