a LTD company name very close to my own..not friendly.
a LTD company name very close to my own..not friendly.
Author
Discussion

SidJames

Original Poster:

1,399 posts

264 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Okay.

I work for a mainstream public company, but I do have an eye on how I might earn some cash when they can me.

Given I might be pastured out in the next 5 years or so I decided to create a dormant LTD company a few years ago to save the trouble of doing it at the last minute. It has a fairly unique business name, lets say "theSidjamesLtd". A registered LTD company.

After a while I hired an outside contractor on a project management basis (for my day job) , for a high profile retail build. The contractor had a generic gmail address so I thought I would rent him an address from my Ltd company, to make him look more professional. I'm talking £12.

Anyway, bloke didn't complete the build, then went onto create his own business called

"Sidjames Ltd", and has been trading on that name for some time unbeknown to me.

....
/
how do I MAKE HIM PAY

southendpier

6,239 posts

260 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Hmm there is a law about 'passing off' but you would have to prove a loss I expect.

I doubt there are any other links to you eg does he have a website stating your are working with him...google ads etc?

Close your company and start a new one. Honestly it will not be worth a fight.

You are not trading if I understand your post so therefore have not suffered a financial loss.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Are you still renting him an email address?

-Wrings hands evilly-

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Legally a "Passing off action " is your prime remedy. Goes right back to the Panhard Levasseur action in about 1910. Umpteen cases since all confirm deliberate misuse of similar business names is actionable. However if your company has never traded I am doubtful of success. Where is you loss? The essential requirement of such actions. Since you are not trading with a dormant company I cannot see a legitimate claim. Up to you.

Simpo Two

93,090 posts

296 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Looks like it's frozen sausages and hammer time...

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Looks like it's frozen sausages and hammer time...

Du1point8

22,974 posts

223 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Steffan said:
Legally a "Passing off action " is your prime remedy. Goes right back to the Panhard Levasseur action in about 1910. Umpteen cases since all confirm deliberate misuse of similar business names is actionable. However if your company has never traded I am doubtful of success. Where is you loss? The essential requirement of such actions. Since you are not trading with a dormant company I cannot see a legitimate claim. Up to you.
This absolutely...

I set up a company called XXXXX Products Ltd as XXXXX Ltd was gone and dormant.

We bought all the websites we could at the time, leaving .org.uk as I dont see that being worth it as a website address.

XXXXX Ltd has been dormant for 4-5 years and then all of a sudden they have a website using the .org.uk claiming to sell something similar to us about 6 weeks after we go live, even though our site is up and trading and they never have been.

8 months later they then change their website onto Log homes instead of similar products to ours, we suspect they were going to try and use the passing off rule for a quick buck and told to go away by everyone they contacted.

They have done no trading since and still have no creditablity in the Log home industry, probably cause their site looks like a 5 year old did it with a crayon.

P-Jay

11,422 posts

222 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
I'm not sure you could prove 'passing off' as, as far as I can tell, your company has never traded?

Ltd Co name and Trademark are very different, ultimately Companies House decide on company names, they have rules governing new incorporations using names too close to existing ones, if he's been able to incorporate that name then he's entitled to use it.

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
SidJames said:
Okay.
dormant LTD company

I thought I would rent him an address from my Ltd company, to make him look more professional. I'm talking £12.
If the company now has £12 income it's no longer dormant and you'll need to submit company accounts etc etc. I'm sure Eric will be along soon.....

Eric Mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
Mr Overheads said:
SidJames said:
Okay.
dormant LTD company

I thought I would rent him an address from my Ltd company, to make him look more professional. I'm talking £12.
If the company now has £12 income it's no longer dormant and you'll need to submit company accounts etc etc. I'm sure Eric will be along soon.....
Correct. A company that has any activity at all is not "dormant".

SidJames

Original Poster:

1,399 posts

264 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies.

I guessed from the outset there wouldn't be a lot I could do as I'm not trading.....(let's assume the £12 wasn't traded through the company), or nothing much to be gained from a lot of stress.

I guess my point was that :

a) It took me a few days of research through company names and available domains, that he got for "free".
b) It was a future for me, and I mistakenly shared the fact that I might use some sort of franchising model for it, with him being in a similar trade.

Clearly I didn't know the guy well enough at all, and I should have kept schtum until I was ready to go.

Just angry that this dick didn't seem to think he'd done anything wrong, morally or otherwise, when I arrived with the sausages at an address..


Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Saturday 15th February 2014
quotequote all
SidJames said:
Thanks for all the replies.

I guessed from the outset there wouldn't be a lot I could do as I'm not trading.....(let's assume the £12 wasn't traded through the company), or nothing much to be gained from a lot of stress.

I guess my point was that :

a) It took me a few days of research through company names and available domains, that he got for "free".
b) It was a future for me, and I mistakenly shared the fact that I might use some sort of franchising model for it, with him being in a similar trade.

Clearly I didn't know the guy well enough at all, and I should have kept schtum until I was ready to go.

Just angry that this dick didn't seem to think he'd done anything wrong, morally or otherwise, when I arrived with the sausages at an address..
Indeed an unpleasant experience. 40 years in Accountancy made me aware just how close to your chest cards must be kept in business. Working in companies at the point of collapse when the workforce are completely unaware of what is likely to happen, makes you very cagey with conversations and comments and you learn never to reveal anything to anyone. I suggest that the experience will make you much more careful in your revelations and observations to others. There are sadly a lot of shysters in business but fortunately the majority of business people are honest. No doubt you will learn from this and not repeat the error. People who create opportunities in business are bound to make mistakes. Rough with the smooth IMO.