Legal Advice on Holiday Property deposit
Legal Advice on Holiday Property deposit
Author
Discussion

Corv99

Original Poster:

290 posts

189 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Hi all
bit of a strange one this, hopefully someone can help.. think it may be a contract law type issue..

some years back myself and some other friends ( seperatley) looked into investing in Holiday places in Bulgaria
a Ski resort during winter, and holiday place in summer too.. now place is legit and not a scam and by all accounts
a decent comapany..

So it was sold across as a one stop shop, so they sorted mortgage companies options,currency exchangers, even lawyers etc for the Bulgarian side, done I guess through purchase power and maybe bit of commission for them too and they also would take care of letting them out when you weren't there ( if you wanted to) they had contacts over Europe etc take care of preparing apartments / cleaning them , and as I say the company was proffesional and al a bit of a whirlwind situation..

My mate was ahead of me in the running and was on with his purchase, I decided to go out of my comfort zone and do a bit of an investment, use for holiday, rent out, then sell later type situation, was give n spreadsheets showing projected rental incomes, als went for an apartment that had balcony and could also convert from two bedroom to two one bedroom with shared facilities and lockable bedrooms which also allowed for better rental options... you get the picture..

Now to do this I used some inheritance money from my dad who had recently passed away, not an awful lot, but still a lot, some of my own savings, and sold some items off..

So whats the problem? in short the financial crisis kicked off in a big way.. My mate just got his mortgage through, mine were still in form filling option stages..

the ones on the running were 2 Greek lenders ( mmm yes) so offers dissappeared basically as world went into melt down... now company wennt from faxing forms over to sign and options and spreadsheets to backing away and turing around and saying so have you sorted out your mortgage then!!! I politely said hang on everything has been done
by you guy's, the woman who actually wasn't there much longer said I needed to do it... now this would have been the first time I wuld have to have done any thing apart from follow instructions.. thats why this appealed the flats were going through regualrly with out an issue pre crisis

now there was 2 deposits in this, one smallish one, but one substantial, now in one of the rafts and rafts of paperwork was a contract which did indeed eludes to deposit being theirs and they could resell the flat after 8 week period or something if no mortgage being forth coming for it...

I thought, no mortgages full stop are about so retract, then maybe haggle over the smaller deposit in the small claims court, but get the bulk back..

So I wrote a long emotive letter to them,big of anger in there too! spelling out I'm an individual, not a business the money was everything I had in the world, I was under the impression you would take care of everything, as your guys had said etc etc laying it on thick and appealing to common decency, i.e. I gave you money in good faith what has happened has happened I'm not blaming them for crisis, but equally that works both ways.. particularly how can they sell on my flat, AND keep my deposit ( at this time flat wasn't sold.. not sure if it is now.. but I guess rented out)
I didn't really get stuck into them, as they said they would look into it, and options, they did come back and asked if I could get any more money!!! as this may help move things through.. I obviously went cold to this idea after what was happening... they did say if flat sells they wuld look at something, but couldn't promise etc etc
I emailled for up dates every now and again, nothing really comes of it, talk of shared owners, then that phased out..

so getting nowhere fast, I'm just wondering as time is going on am I screwed with this contract or are there grounds to go for it legally.. or do courts not really see what is right and moral!!

I'm guilty of not using lawyer initially, but I had some any document s through to sign and fill out for mortgage aplications etc my head was spining, I didnt smell a rat with as I knew people who where doing it and had done it, so whay would I , I was doing nothing different

but its a lt of money to me, I accept I may not get it all back, with exchange rate ( as its Euro's) that will go against me... but I just want it back now as it will help with life in general, and chalk it down to painful experience if lose out of some of it... not a n investment, but a bit of a loss.... but not total loss..

I have realy tried hard not to explode over this.. there has been times I wanted to get on a trian and go down with a baseball bat etc... but have remained calm through out, and at least there has been dialogue with a guy there.. but of course if he left??


thanks for reading, sorry its long, but quite an emotive subject, I accept I'm at fault here to a degree, but for me its about what is right..

or do I get the boys together and go down and level there office to the ground ( I don't mean this obviously!!)






Eric Mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Who did you pay the deposit to?

Does that organisation still exist?

Corv99

Original Poster:

290 posts

189 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Hi Eric
it was paid to them, and yes they are still around. this was potential off plan purchase, at the time the buiding had just finished and they were moving the units on, the site is open and in operation now

thanks

Eric Mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
Who's them?

Was the payment made to a limited liability type operation - such as the equivalent of a limited company?

Is THAT exact limited company still in existence?

Was the entity to which the money paid a British entity, Greek entity or a Bulgarian entity.

zedstar

1,790 posts

207 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
OP I was in a SIMILAR situation with a UK company about 3 years ago, me and my friend had put 10% deposits on some off plan apartments, by the time we got to completion (2 years late), they had devalued by 40% in some cases plus the BTL mortgages were looking at approx 70% lend so the short story was to complete we needed an extra 45k EACH when we initially thought that a BTL would fund the completion entirely.

I was happy to leave the £15k deposit and walk away but it transpired we were responsible for any shortfall if the developer sold the apartments and lost money from our initital price.

Eventually after many legal battles and much stress we came to a compromise and although i'm legally bound not to talk about the terms of it what I will say is that I wished many times that I could have just walked away losing just the deposit - It was a very expensive lesson learned for me!

I dont know what the legal situation is that you're in but if it boils down to legals and you don't have to make good their loss (like me) then really it's not so bad. Whatever promises they made about mortgages or timescales don't mean anything if the contracts didn't mention it.

Corv99

Original Poster:

290 posts

189 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
zedstar said:
OP I was in a SIMILAR situation with a UK company about 3 years ago, me and my friend had put 10% deposits on some off plan apartments, by the time we got to completion (2 years late), they had devalued by 40% in some cases plus the BTL mortgages were looking at approx 70% lend so the short story was to complete we needed an extra 45k EACH when we initially thought that a BTL would fund the completion entirely.

I was happy to leave the £15k deposit and walk away but it transpired we were responsible for any shortfall if the developer sold the apartments and lost money from our initital price.

Eventually after many legal battles and much stress we came to a compromise and although i'm legally bound not to talk about the terms of it what I will say is that I wished many times that I could have just walked away losing just the deposit - It was a very expensive lesson learned for me!

I dont know what the legal situation is that you're in but if it boils down to legals and you don't have to make good their loss (like me) then really it's not so bad. Whatever promises they made about mortgages or timescales don't mean anything if the contracts didn't mention it.
Hi zedstar
Thanks for reply...
Sorry to hear of your woes, that's a nightmare situation you have too.. And I feel for you!
My word that's a nightmare you were liable for all that!

My situation is not a legal one yet, but for me it didn't complete, and it was a straight forward mortgage at the time, so the only issue is they have a substantial amount of my money, and I have nothing to show for it, I think they would love me to walk away obviously..
Essentially as the mortgage offers that they sourced dried up almost over night, they turned to me and said I needed to sort it out.. If not all the money I had put down was gone..
I don't really want to do legal route if I'm stuffed, as it's even more money to effectively lose on top of the loss already, but if I have a good chance of recovering a good chunk it is worth doing..



johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
How much was the deposit?

Is the other party based here or in Bulgaria?


Eric Mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Corv99 said:
Hi zedstar
Thanks for reply...
Sorry to hear of your woes, that's a nightmare situation you have too.. And I feel for you!
My word that's a nightmare you were liable for all that!

My situation is not a legal one yet, but for me it didn't complete, and it was a straight forward mortgage at the time, so the only issue is they have a substantial amount of my money, and I have nothing to show for it, I think they would love me to walk away obviously..
Essentially as the mortgage offers that they sourced dried up almost over night, they turned to me and said I needed to sort it out.. If not all the money I had put down was gone..
I don't really want to do legal route if I'm stuffed, as it's even more money to effectively lose on top of the loss already, but if I have a good chance of recovering a good chunk it is worth doing..
Can you answer my question as to who it was you actually paid?

You don't seem to be very clear on the actual organisation involved.

Corv99

Original Poster:

290 posts

189 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Hi guys,
The company have an office in London , and one in Bulgaria .. They are a UK company.. I paid them the money

Corv99

Original Poster:

290 posts

189 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I will double check the entity, that's a good point actually , there are ways I guess of transferring companies around on paper
When things are tough..

The Greek connection was potential mortgage offers, it didn't get that far, so it was only really a deposit held by them to be used against final price of flat, so remaining amount would be mortgaged..

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
The key points are:

which entity (a UK company or a Bulgarian one) was your purported contract with?

What are the terms of the 'contract'?


Eric Mc

125,929 posts

296 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
If they are/were a UK limited company, you should be able to find out their current status by doing a check at Companies House. That would be my first line of enquiry.